FishHobby99
Fish Gatherer
This is one of my cats.
Don’t miss out on the best deals of the season! Shop now 🎁
An absolute tragedyA terrible tragedy happened in Dallas today...absolutely heartbreaking
MID-AIR COLLISION: Airshow disaster caught on video as planes crash into each other
Two planes in Texas collided in midair during the Commemorative Air Force air event at Dallas Executive Airport on Saturday afternoon.www.foxnews.com
Thanks for your input, very useful information.Accidents at airshows get so much more coverage than a scheduled airline flight or military flight accident purely due to the fact that when things do go wrong, its usually infront of hundreds or thousands of people
Reading up on various sites such as PPRUNE about the Redbird (Dallas) crash........I find it quite incredible that some are commenting that the P63 was flown intentionally into the B17.
I'm not saying that it is impossible that the P63 pilot intentionally flew his aircraft in that manner. But I do find it highly unlikely.
There does, however, seem to have been issues immediately prior to the collision that will need careful investigation. Airshows tend not to have ATC (air traffic control), rather a ground to air advisory or "Air Boss" system where one individual who is qualified does a full briefing with all pilots before the display and then acts as communication with the aircraft during the display
There appears to have been a significant amount of air to ground and air to air discussion, some 20 minutes or so, prior to the collision. That is very unusual and tends to indicate potential display format confusion.....a bit like an actor forgetting his or her lines and needing to be prompted.
Watching the variety of footage taken from several angles, there certainly appears to be substantial spacial awareness and blindspot issues with the P63 pilot.
People will doubtless ask how someone flying a small plane manages to lose sight of a ruddy great big plane.....it is extremely easy given the canopy framing, the closing speed and things such as sun glare etc
I still receive reports from the NTSB aviation division and it will be interesting to read their ultimate findings. I suspect it will be accredited to spacial awareness/spacial disorientation on the part of the P63's pilot. The crew of the B17 will likely be exonerated of all and any blame.
One thing that I do question though in regard to the B17. Why so many on board. Five person crew is more than is permitted here in the UK. I have flown as crew in both B17 and B25 in the UK and mainland Europe on display flights and we had a max of three in the aircraft. So I do have to wonder who exactly was on board and what their designation was...afterall both aircraft involved were Houston based, so no need for extended flying hours crew on the B17.
Undoubtably everything will come out in the prelinary and ultimate reports 6 months to 3 years time.
A very sad loss to loved ones, friends and especially with it being Remembrance weekend, a poignant reminder of how fragile life can be when flying warbirds.
It has been confirmed within the display circle that no fare paying or free riding pax were on board the B17 at the time. The five were all connected to Texas Raiders display team, as was the pilot of the P63. When I say "connected" they may have been family of the pilots if not actual ground crew members from the display team.Thanks for your input, very useful information.
As far as the amount of people onboard the B17, I can tell you, when I've attended airshows here (near Beaumont), and a B17 was part of the squadron that participated, rides were offered aboard the B17 to the public, for a fee...unsure if that were the case here, and also unsure if those rides were offered during the actual airshow, or before/after the event.
At any rate, a heartbreaking situation, no doubt...she was one of only about a dozen B17s that are still operational..and the loss of life at any airshow is disheartening, to say the least
Do keep us informed, please...and I agree, these aircraft were part of The Greatest Generation...they should never be forgotten, and continue to be sharedIt has been confirmed within the display circle that no fare paying or free riding pax were on board the B17 at the time. The five were all connected to Texas Raiders display team, as was the pilot of the P63. When I say "connected" they may have been family of the pilots if not actual ground crew members from the display team.
The pilots of both aircraft are...or were...former American Airlines pilots with several thousand flying hours. However, that being said, there is still a questionmark over display hours/experience, which will obviously be one of many things that the FAA and NTSB will be looking into.
I know from experience that pax are not usually permitted during the display but can be carried for the proverbial "circuit & bump" flights...ie...just taken for a short flight around the locality and back to the field they left from. Insurance and FAA rules (as all aviation authorities) forbade pax during display flights following past fatal accidents.
These warbirds are not easy to fly, they are very basic and in order to fly nowadays require substantial upgrades to instrumentation and communication systems.
The B25 that I was involved with is now a wreck....they are extremely difficult to restore and keep flying
North American Aviation B-25 Mitchell Registry - A Warbirds Resource Group Site
The North American Aviation B-25 Mitchell registry follows the history of all B-25s that survived military service.warbirdregistry.org
The B17 is still going strong, she is a fixture on the airshow circuit and has been for a very long time now
B-17 Preservation Ltd - The Sally B Website
The official website of Sally B, the UK's last airworthy B-17 flying fortresswww.sallyb.org.uk
These warbirds are precious, they allow younger generations to see first hand what those who went through the wars had to deal with every day.....they need to be kept flying. After this weekend's tragedy there will doubtless be calls for displays to be banned. That is wrong imho. These warbirds must be allowed to fly, they are keeping the memories of those who died alive....along with those who died in display flying....these people need to be remembered and there is nothing better than the sound of those engines and the smell of the leather and oil to keep their memory alive.