hi ren&stumpy
this is just my opinion, and may only be what ive seen but i often find that tigers/reds are a lot more lively than lutions, and in that case they will bully lutinos if not raised together from day one, lutinos are very submissive,quite shy.
when i had jambo he bullied day day ( white) and anything else that went into the tank, including the plec, tho i do think that he treated the plec like a toy when he was bored
day day i didnt have any problems with at all, he had a silver dollar in with him for a while and on a few occassion had other fish in for a few hours/days.
which ever you go with.. inform the lfs before you buy him that you intend to home him with scar, and that should things go wrong he will need to go back, id be very surprised if scar murdered him instantly, and for sure you would notice any bullying going on, this would include behaviour like the new oscar slowing turning on his side when scar came near him, spending time away at the back/other end of the tank, just generally staying out of his way,
the best way may be to remove scar from the tank, rearrange the decor, then add the new O then half an hour later put scar back in,
oscars in general will chase anything just to check if it will fit in there mouths, even out of bordom.
he will need carefull watching with anything new that goes in there,, even when you go to bed and the lights go off you will need to watch him ( he will think that no one is watching him
)
its noit as staright forward as getting another oscar and adding at as you know, as they are very intelligent ,, i wish it was that easy tho, i would have themn crammed in 10 high ( joke!!)
maybe nelly could have a word here, i dont know if as far as personalities go you would get a less personality ( shyer) or a stronger more out going oscar, really dont know what would be best, tho equall would be good, there bound to be a pecking order with them
i really hope that whichever you chose it all goes smoothy for you and scar , if it dosent then maybe you can consider other fish. large cichlids rather than an O, but i spose thats like having a bike instead of car in terms of choice
wish you all the best
shelagh xxxxx
thanks for the lovely comments on Bo
.. in my sig he looks like his pic has been taken in black n white
yes he has coloured up really well.. must be all those prawns he fills his face with