🌟 Exclusive Amazon Black Friday Deals 2024 🌟

Don’t miss out on the best deals of the season! Shop now 🎁

What Mistakes Have You Made While Fishkeeping?

One mistake I made that still bugs me; is when I would do water change - during the winter the new water was a bit colder than the tank water. I never thought much about it and my fishes never seemed to really mind. However - in my 29 i had a pair of gold rams - and they did mind - they minded a whole lot. The female shrugged it off but the male never ate again and died a week later. I was really bummed. Now i heat the water over night so it is more or less the same as the tank.
 
One mistake I made that still bugs me; is when I would do water change - during the winter the new water was a bit colder than the tank water. I never thought much about it and my fishes never seemed to really mind. However - in my 29 i had a pair of gold rams - and they did mind - they minded a whole lot. The female shrugged it off but the male never ate again and died a week later. I was really bummed. Now i heat the water over night so it is more or less the same as the tank.
How big was the water change. Usually if you do a 25% water change with cold water the temperature will drop around 4 degrees which won't be a problem for the fish. I have only ever done water changes with cold water, usually I just bring the garden hose in through the window and fill it up.
 
How big was the water change. Usually if you do a 25% water change with cold water the temperature will drop around 4 degrees which won't be a problem for the fish. I have only ever done water changes with cold water, usually I just bring the garden hose in through the window and fill it up.
30% to 40% and the water changed by 5ish degree. The rams were just very sensitive. Most fishes I have actually enjoy the cooler water and swim into it.
 
30% to 40% and the water changed by 5ish degree. The rams were just very sensitive. Most fishes I have actually enjoy the cooler water and swim into it.
That's a shame you lost your Ram, could there have been another reason for it dying
 
How big was the water change. Usually if you do a 25% water change with cold water the temperature will drop around 4 degrees which won't be a problem for the fish. I have only ever done water changes with cold water, usually I just bring the garden hose in through the window and fill it up.
My biggest tank is 40 G. I use water from the kitchen sink. I siphon old water into as big a bucket as I can carry, 40-50 pds, & toss into a toilet. Not a long distance. I carry 2 big pitchers at a time from a smaller conditioned bucket, ~5 G in the kitchen that is mixed with some hot water. It’s a long walk from the kitchen to the tanks, and I can’t carry more than 10-15 pds. Many trips. Good biceps workout🏋️‍♀️.
 
2. OVERSTOCKING: I personally am not guilty of this but I see so many pictures and videos where there are TOO MANY FISH in the tank. I think the rule of 1" of fish per gallon is pretty good. That means that if my 4 DoJos all reach 24" long then I'll STILL be overstocked with a 90 gallon tank.
Good stuff, Jan. Regarding this one: The 1" per gallon rule is a pretty good rule of thumb as a maximum for small fish. I kind of abandoned that rule after I saw a 15" oscar in a 20 gallon tank. Poor guy could barely turn around. I know you already know this, but there are a lot of beginners reading this, so I want to make sure it's clear.

So, please listen, my children: 1" of small fish per gallon is OK as a maximum, as in "I have more than 1" per gallon. I'm probably overstocked."

It is not OK as a minimum, as in "This goldfish is only 10" long, so he'll be happy in a 15 gallon tank! And I can add five neon tetras! Yay!"

Quiz time: Out of the two examples above, which person is in serious danger of doing something idiotic?
 
30% to 40% and the water changed by 5ish degree. The rams were just very sensitive. Most fishes I have actually enjoy the cooler water and swim into it.
Hm, usually if it's within about five degrees, the fish don't seem to notice. I too wonder if something else was going on. Sorry for your loss either way.
 
Doing a fish-in cycle. While I didn't have much choice since the fish was brought home without concent, it was still a bear. On the plus side it got me to the point that I get a certain satisfaction from water changes. And I've developed a better system for it. Made a 40' hose that hooks to the sink tap and has a shut-off at the tank side. Leave it slow and do other things. Beats carrying over 20 gallons back and forth by the pitcher-full!
 
Doing a fish-in cycle. While I didn't have much choice since the fish was brought home without concent, it was still a bear. On the plus side it got me to the point that I get a certain satisfaction from water changes. And I've developed a better system for it. Made a 40' hose that hooks to the sink tap and has a shut-off at the tank side. Leave it slow and do other things. Beats carrying over 20 gallons back and forth by the pitcher-full!
But do you still remove water from tank by the bucketfull? If you got a python with a hose extension added to it, you could syphon tank water from the tank and do a substrate vacuuming at the same time.
 
But do you still remove water from tank by the bucketfull? If you got a python with a hose extension added to it, you could syphon tank water from the tank and do a substrate vacuuming at the same time.
I do use a bucket for removal with a regular gravel vac. I looked into a python, but reviews aren't great. I'm thinking possibly quality has gone down recently?
My other issue with it was the fact I will waste water to create the siphon. Shouldn't be an issue, but my city charges your first born for water usage.
 
Hm, usually if it's within about five degrees, the fish don't seem to notice. I too wonder if something else was going on. Sorry for your loss either way.
Unlikely; btw I lost another ram when the power went out for 23 hours and the tank cooled down to 72. When the power came back on all the rams ran next to the heater as soon as it came on but alas one of them never ate again. they are just rather sensitive. I could tell you stories about my 5 year old swordtail and the abuse he has seen over the years yet he keeps on ticking (though he is now showing his years).
 
What mistakes have I made?
I have made all of them so this is going to be a long list.

Back in the day when I started fish keeping there weren't a lot of books and people that ran pet shops wouldn't give out any information on how to keep fish. So it was all trial and error and you kept fish until they died and went back to buy more.

Starting off I kept 2 small fantail goldfish in a fish bowl that held about 4 litres of water. Each week I caught the fish out with a plastic cup and put them in an icecream bucket with a bit of their water. I washed the bowl and gravel out and refilled it with tap water. Added some "water conditioner", which turned out to be sodium chloride (salt) with Methylene Blue added to it, basically blue salt. Then put the fish back in the bowl. They lasted 6 months.

Bought a 2 foot long tank and put goldfish in that. Did the same thing as the fish bowl. Lost heaps of fish. Tried tropical fish in the 2ft tank and they did better.

Picked up a 14 and an 18 inch tank and set them up. Tried keeping fish in them and some did ok but most didn't.

Tried using air operated box filters with filter wool/ floss in. I was told to replace the floss every month and did that when I cleaned the tank. The fish didn't do well.

Kept angelfish, swordtails and neon tetras in the 2ft tank for a while.

Tried keeping marine fish in the 2ft tank. Went to the beach and got some sea water, beach sand, rock and fish from rock pools. Put them in the tank and the fish ate well and did great for a week, then started dying. The tank wasn't cycled but nobody would tell me anything.

Managed to find a book of marine fish and it took me a while to save up enough money to buy it. The book was about $20.00 but that was back in the 80s. It told me all about the nitrogen cycle and how to cycle a marine tank. If that book was available when I first started fish keeping I wouldn't have killed as many fish as I did.

Did water changes on my tanks and filled them up with a hose from the tap. I added a double dose of dechlorinator when I started filling the tank and it worked for a few years. Then one day the water company did work on the pipes and increased the chlorine in the tap water. I did water changes and filled the tanks like normal. Within 5 minutes I lost half the fish in my fish room. Never added chlorinated water to my tanks again.

Did a water change on a tank during winter and forgot to turn the heater off before draining the tank. The cold water overloaded the heater and the water never warmed up. The following day I had a tank with 5 degree Celsius water and a heap of dead fish.

Cooked fish when a heater failed and got the temperature up to about 40C in an hour.

Had fish and moray eels jump out of tanks and dry up on the floor because I didn't have coverglass on the tanks.

Poisoned heaps of fish because I didn't know how to and didn't bother trying to work out how much water was in them. I simply used the tank volume the shop said was in the tanks. eg: 50 gallon. Turned out the tanks held a lot less water than that and I overdosed and killed heaps of fish.

Poisoned fish because I tried using medications to try and treat diseases I knew nothing about and nobody at the pet shop would help. They just said try this, try this, try this.

Tried to keep fish that nobody had kept before and there was no information about keeping them in captivity. There is now thanks to me and a few others like me, but we killed a lot of fish learning how to look after them.

Experimented on rainbowfish and other types of fish trying to stop them dying from various diseases including ulcers and TB. Those 2 problems are linked and there is no cure for Fish TB.

Kept real nasty Rift Lake cichlids with tetras, barbs and Corydoras. The cichlids were young and had nice blue and yellow colours but quickly turned bad.

Fed fish the wrong types of food and killed them all. Tropheus cichlids are true vegetarians and do not do well on frozen bloodworms and marine mix (prawn, fish & squid blended up).

Bought fish from a shop and the young guy who caught them chased the fish around for 20 minutes even though I was saying stop, don't worry about it, your stressing them out. I lost half the fish on the way home and the rest where dead the following day.

Bought fish from a shop on the day they came in and lost them the next day.

Bought fish from a shop when they were doing water changes and lost those fish over the next few days.

Tried using CO2 in the tank to encourage plants to grow. It went badly. and killed everything from CO2 poisoning and a massive sudden drop in pH.

Fed goldfish a heap of dry food and watched them float around for the next 2 days while they farted the air out.

Didn't clean power filters until they stopped flowing, about 6-12 months later, and wondered why the fish were sick and dying.

Didn't test the pH or anything else on a regular basis and wasn't doing regular water changes.

Tried growing plants in tanks but it turned out the plants were garden plants and rotted under water. They were nice colours though, pretty reds, purples, silver and pink.

Kept black fin pacu in a 4ft tank. They were only babies and started off at 2 inches but quickly hit 4 inches in a matter of months.

Let my pet ferrets run around the fish room when I wasn't home and came back to find them swimming in a tank and sitting on the coverglass eating the fish they caught.

Been electrocuted by salt creeping onto light units and faulty heaters. Blown up fuses in the fuse box by draining too much power for the fish tanks and heaters.

Cracked fish tanks by putting them on the lawn in summer and the glass heated up and split the base. Also chipped and cracked tanks trying to move them myself when I should have had someone help me. And cracked tanks by putting them on a wooden stand without a sheet of polystyrene foam under the base.

Cut my leg open with a sheet of coverglass that was cracked and should have been thrown out but didn't get chucked out. It was leaning against a wall but fell over when I walked past pulling a garden hose into my fish room and the glass hit the back of my leg above the ankle and cut my leg open. Lots of blood and my mum and aunty laughing saying look at him, he's gone white as a ghost.. A couple of bandaids and I hopped around for a couple of weeks. It got infected so I was taken to the beach and told to go play in the ocean. Surprisingly enough that actually cleaned the wound and it healed after that.

I'm sure there's other stupid things I have done regarding fish but that is probably enough for now.
 
Last edited:

Most reactions

Back
Top