State: New York
City: Fishkill
Store: Fishtopia
Variety/ Selection: 8
Cleanliness and quality: 7
Staff friendlyness and Knowledge: 9
Great selection, and knowledgeable staff. Some of the tanks do have dead fish in them though, and some of the fish I have gotten from here had shorter lifespans than that of other stores I've purchased from.
State: New York
City: Nanuet
Store: Pets Place II
Variety/ Selection: 10
Cleanliness and quality: 10
Staff friendlyness and Knowledge: 10
GREAT fish selection, the tanks are crystal clean and all my purchases have been healthy. I wish I could go to this place more often but it's out of the way for me.
State: New York
City: Fishkill
Store: Wal-Mart
Variety/ Selection: 2
Cleanliness and quality: 1
Staff friendlyness and Knowledge: Didn't ask....
Pretty much what you expect from a Wal-Mart fish section. I feel bad for these fish, Iridescent Sharks being crammed into 10gal, and their Goldfish selection, there were at least 9 or 10 dead fish in there for a LONG time, they only recently cleaned it! I have also seen ich ion these tanks. I have never made a purchase here but my advice: avoid at all costs!
State: New York
City: Poughkeepsie
Store: Petco
Variety/ Selection: 7
Cleanliness and quality: 5
Staff friendlyness and Knowledge: 7
There are a lot of fish here, and this is the only store I know of that does not sell any dyed/painted fish. However, I see a lot of dead fish in these tanks. Worth a look, but use caution as there might be disease in these tanks.
State: New York
City: Fishkill
Store: Pet Supplies Plus
Variety/ Selection: 6
Cleanliness and quality: 4
Staff friendlyness and Knowledge: 9
Staff are helpful, but these tanks are a little fishy (no pun intended). I have seen obvious cases of ich, and somebody must have pointed it out because they are currently not allowing fish purchases because of illness. They do occasionally have some rare fish, but I am avoiding buying from here due to ich. The staff are very friendly, but some of the people who put the fish in the tanbks may not know which fishes to mix and not... for example, I saw a tank of Tiger Barbs and Dwarf Gouramis. The Gouramis were being harassed and looked scared! Another tank had Redtail Sharks with Elephantnoses, and the sharks were also being harassing. They have a great selection of decorations for tanks, though.
State: New Jersey
City: Ramsey
Store: Fishtown USA
Variety/ Selection: 6
Cleanliness and quality: 4
Staff friendlyness and Knowledge: ?
The tanks were hard to see in there was so much algae! Their website showed a great selection, so I made this hour-long trip to this store, and was very disappointed. No rare fish, even though they claim to have some on their site. I'd pass on this one unless you wanted to buy a pre-setup tank, as they had VERY impressive ones.
State: New York
City: Newburgh
Store: Pet store and Tropical Aquarium
Variety/ Selection: 8
Cleanliness and quality: 10
Staff friendlyness and Knowledge: 10
One guy runs this store, and he definately knows a lot about fish! This store has a great selection, and I have seen some rare fish here. The only store I've been to that had not a single dead fish in all of the tanks. All my purchases from here have been happy and healthy!
State: New York
City: Newburgh
Store: Pet Store
Variety/ Selection: 7
Cleanliness and quality: 6
Staff friendlyness and Knowledge: 1 <- got bad advice here
While I have seen some rare fish here, they are in TINY tanks. I saw a freshwater Stingray in a 5-7 gallon tank... multiple Silver Dollars in tanks the same size. I also even saw a corydoras catfish, a fish that needs company, in a tank all by itself. Also, above I mentioned I got bad advice here. We were looking to purchase an Albino Redtail Shark and they insisted we got a Redtail Shark to be a companion. I was new to the hobby at the time and bought both. Shortly after, the Black shark killed the White shark.
State: New York
City: Yorktown
Store: Petland Discounts
Variety/ Selection: 6
Cleanliness and quality: 8
Staff friendlyness and Knowledge: ?
Not the greatest selection of fish, but the tanks were well mantained. But the 'Dicounts' in the name of the store is right on - these are VERY cheap fish. I bought my Dwarf Gourami for only $2 or $3... and he is a healthy fish! I have also seen fish here for under $1, healthy.