I recently went to my LFS to get live plants but the guy there told me I needed to buy an air pump. Do I absolutely need to or is it just optional? I've seen many people with live plants not have an air pump so I figured I didn't need one either. Anyway, please let me know if I need an air pump. Thanks!
Silent cycling...do I need an air pump?
- Thread starter fishiee
- Start date
Retired Viking
Fish Connoisseur
Air pumps do provide water movement and help with gas exchange on the surface but if you are only having plants and no fish it may not be necessary IMO
Metalhead88
Fish Herder
- Joined
- May 31, 2019
- Messages
- 1,037
- Reaction score
- 697
How are you cycling?
You don't necessarily need an air pump, but you do need surface agitation. That can be done by a filter or air pump.
You don't necessarily need an air pump, but you do need surface agitation. That can be done by a filter or air pump.
As long as your filter provides water movement for gas exchange you dont need one
Martyn87
Fish Fanatic
Do you have a filter? If you do I wouldn’t bother. As long as the water can move and circulate then you do not need to buy an air pump
I concur with what others have posted, and will just expand a bit on the surface disturbance because this is crucial in planted tanks.
You may or may not need a filter for filtration in a planted tank, depending upon the fish and plants (species and numbers of both). But surface disturbance is important, and especially so at night. It is possible to poison fish from CO2 during the dark (night) period.
Fish, plants and some bacteria respire 24/7, taking in oxygen and expelling CO2. CO2 is also produced in the bacterial breakdown of organics, primarily in the substrate. The CO2 from this latter source is almost always considerably higher than the respiration, again depending upon the specifics. All of this is on-going 24/7.
The plants during photosynthesis continue to repire but they also take up CO2 for their carbon needs. The light intensity drives photosynthesis, but it cannot continue if CO2 (and the other essential nutrients) are not sufficient. With fast-growing plants, and depending upon the light intensity and duration, it is common for all of the available CO2 to be utilized by the plants. During photosynthesis, oxygen is produced and released by the plants as a by-product. During the daylight (under the tank lighting) this should cause no issues, but at night it can.
The uptake of CO2 by plants is non-existent during the night, and CO2 can build up. This is what can cause trouble for the fish; the CO2 level increases and oxygen depletes. Maintaining a good amount of surface disturbance especially at night will allow the CO2 to partially out-gas, and more oxygen will enter the water.
I had evidence of this a few years ago in my 70g tank. One morning just after the lights came on I noticed the Corydoras were respirating faster than normal, and surface breaching more. I increased the surface disturbance by adjusting the filter return so it rippled the water surface much more at the one end. Problem solved; from then on, the cories in the early morning are respirating normally, and rarely surface breach.
You do not need a raging whirlpool, but some good surface disturbance to maintain an exchange of oxygen and CO2 at the surface. Air stones do not achieve this, it has to be surface disturbance. The filter is the usual means of achieving this, so this is the primary need for a filter. Water circulation is also improved obviously.
You may or may not need a filter for filtration in a planted tank, depending upon the fish and plants (species and numbers of both). But surface disturbance is important, and especially so at night. It is possible to poison fish from CO2 during the dark (night) period.
Fish, plants and some bacteria respire 24/7, taking in oxygen and expelling CO2. CO2 is also produced in the bacterial breakdown of organics, primarily in the substrate. The CO2 from this latter source is almost always considerably higher than the respiration, again depending upon the specifics. All of this is on-going 24/7.
The plants during photosynthesis continue to repire but they also take up CO2 for their carbon needs. The light intensity drives photosynthesis, but it cannot continue if CO2 (and the other essential nutrients) are not sufficient. With fast-growing plants, and depending upon the light intensity and duration, it is common for all of the available CO2 to be utilized by the plants. During photosynthesis, oxygen is produced and released by the plants as a by-product. During the daylight (under the tank lighting) this should cause no issues, but at night it can.
The uptake of CO2 by plants is non-existent during the night, and CO2 can build up. This is what can cause trouble for the fish; the CO2 level increases and oxygen depletes. Maintaining a good amount of surface disturbance especially at night will allow the CO2 to partially out-gas, and more oxygen will enter the water.
I had evidence of this a few years ago in my 70g tank. One morning just after the lights came on I noticed the Corydoras were respirating faster than normal, and surface breaching more. I increased the surface disturbance by adjusting the filter return so it rippled the water surface much more at the one end. Problem solved; from then on, the cories in the early morning are respirating normally, and rarely surface breach.
You do not need a raging whirlpool, but some good surface disturbance to maintain an exchange of oxygen and CO2 at the surface. Air stones do not achieve this, it has to be surface disturbance. The filter is the usual means of achieving this, so this is the primary need for a filter. Water circulation is also improved obviously.
Salty&Onion
Fish Aficionado
I agree. I recently bought the Hidom air pump and I tried it and it is sooo loud when you put your ear next to it but its alright when sleeping. Honest.Technically Air pumps can be noisy so it wouldnt be a "silent" cycle
Yup i like the white noise air pumps create puts me right out zzzz...
Martyn87
Fish Fanatic
He’s concerned about cycling here, so all we need to make sure is that the water is moving to the nitrifying bacteria so there are not any dead spots. Either a filter or an air air pump will sort this. The bacteria needs the ammonia delivered to it and the more turnover the tank has the faster the bacteria will replicate thus assisting the cycling process.
Don’t listen to LFS staff until you know which ones talk sense! Many of them don’t have a clue.
Don’t listen to LFS staff until you know which ones talk sense! Many of them don’t have a clue.
Salty&Onion
Fish Aficionado
So annoying isn't? Its worse with internal power filters. I promise you sleepless nights. I survived this somehow lol
I agree
I'm putting fish in my tank but right now it just has a few plants (I'm planning to get a lot more) and two decorative items (I'm also planning to add my driftwood).
I'm silent cycling with plants.
Retired Viking
Fish Connoisseur
Alright, Silent cycle is what I do with my tanks but I do run my filter and have an air pump going. Are you using anything for the plants like flourish?
Similar threads
Most reactions
-
376 -
221 -
216 -
180 -
179 -
164 -
159 -
130 -
125 -
116 -
102 -
102 -
86 -
77 -
73