Need List Of Compatible Fish Please.

itsmedeanna64

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Nov 27, 2005
Messages
69
Reaction score
0
Location
Georgia
Hello, I am a beginner with a new 29 gallon tank I just set up yesterday. So far everything is fine. I am going to use the 'Add and Wait' method and would like to put non-aggressive fish and some live plants in my tank. I love mollies, swordtails, platies and guppies. My question is, can anyone give me a list of other fish that will be compatible with these? Thanks for any info that anyone can give me. This is a great forum.
Deanna Cronan
Covington, Georgia
 
Hello, I am a beginner with a new 29 gallon tank I just set up yesterday. So far everything is fine. I am going to use the 'Add and Wait' method and would like to put non-aggressive fish and some live plants in my tank. I love mollies, swordtails, platies and guppies. My question is, can anyone give me a list of other fish that will be compatible with these? Thanks for any info that anyone can give me. This is a great forum.
Deanna Cronan
Covington, Georgia
There's quite a fun community builder here, the list of :fish: isn't huge, but may give you a bit of an idea :D
 
I haven't heard of the "Add and Wait" method of cycling a tank. Would you elaborated for me please?
The list you gave of fish are all compatable community fish. You won't be able to keep many more fish in there if you have male & females since you will need to have one male and three females of each species to keep agression down between the males. If you have 3 males of a species and one female the males will fight and the female will be stressed by the males chasing her constantly. These fish should be kept at one inch of adult length per gallon of water. Swordtails and mollies = 3" each so 4 swordtails is about 12" which is equal to 12 gallons of water. The guppies and platties are about 1-1/2" each. Then there are lots of fry coming from livebearers. Platty and guppy females have a brood about every 28 days. Swordtails and mollies are about 6 weeks between broods.
My platties and guppies have about 20 fry every 28 days, my swordtails have about 30 fry every six weeks, and the mollies have been good for about 30 or more fry every six weeks.
If you want to add some fish that are compatable with the livebearers, I have found cories, glowlight tetras and some of the other small egglaying tetras to be compatable. Here is a link to one of my favorite sites with information about feeding, temperment and size Aquazoo.
You should be able to search this site and find some compatable fish you like. Research the fish before you buy and the fish will be healthier in the long run.
:hi:
Bryan
 
All four of the fish you mentioned (platies, mollies, guppies and swordtails) are livebearers that WILL breed and need to b kept at a ratio of 2 or mroe females per male. I also generaly would not reccomend going for a tank that contains all of them as they are not entirely compatible.

As for cycling - I suspect you are reffering to a cycle with fish. Don't do that. Your fish will either die or have serious health issues for life and will suffer through-out and are likely to die young. Read the links in my signature about new tank syndrome as well as about fishless cycling. It's a lot to go through but I guarantee you won't regret it.

Just a note, there's an 'inch epr gallon guideline' for stocking fish that states that for every inch of ADULT fish, there should be one gallon of water. This means that a fish that gets to 3" needs at least 3 gallons of water to itself. The guideline is rather innacurate as it does not take into acount activity levels or behaviour but it is useful none the less.

Mollies get to about 4", though large females can even get to 6" and balloon mollies, on the other end of the scale, rarely reach 3". Mollies are generaly peaceful but can be nippy towards certain fish (eg gouramies) and can produce huge batches of fry. Try to stick to a single-sex group.
Male guppies get to about 1", females up to 1.5-2". They were once considered hardy. They are now rather fragile and short-lived though the larger, less fancy, ones tend to be quite healthy. An all-male group is probably best (unless you want to breed).
Platies get to around 1.5". These are great fish, hardy and small. Still, they are prolific and a single-sex group is best.
Male swords reach about 2-3" while females can get to almost double that. It's best to avoid mixing them with platies (because they can cross breed) and also best to not put them in with guppies or anything else prone to being nipped because they can get rather boisterous. Males may sometimes get into scraps so it's best to keep 1 per tank.

As you can see, if you want to combine all the above, you won't realy have much room for all that much else. Anyway, concentrate on fishless cycling first of all. While you're at it, look at some of the other fish at your LFS. You'll probably decide you don't want so many livebearers after all.
 
You could always get mixed genders of one livebearer species and only one gender of another, to keep the fry population under some sort of control.

IME out of those four, platies and guppies tend to get on really well together and even seem to derive pleasure from each other's company, being very similar in their habits and patterns of moving about the tank.

Tbh I would not get mixed genders of any livebearer unless I had access to two tanks so I could start splitting the fry up as soon as they can be sexed; otherwise the siblings will start breeding with each other and the population will explode.

You might also want to consider keeping one species of livebearer and some sort of bottomdwellers. Corydoras are nice peaceful bottomdwellers, fairly hardy, and entertaining to watch.

In any case, do do the fishless cycle! It is SO worth it!
 
Thanks so much for taking the time to give me such great information! Oh yes, and I am doing a fishless cycle! (((c:
 
Sorry guys to plug another website but I found this www.timstropicals.com - Click on the compatibitlty at the top. Havnt really used it my self but might be worth a look
 
I found this chart a while back. I really haven't studied it much to see if it is truely correct or not though.

LiveAquaria.com
 
my fish below all live happily together in my 70ltr, i started the tank off with the 3 Sunset platy's and then added 3 tuxedo platy's 3 days after, 2 of the tuxedo's died :( my male platy is boysterous tho and keeps all 3 females happy hehe

Hope this helps
 

Most reactions

Back
Top