moving from gravel to sand

Grim Reaper

Fish Addict
Joined
May 31, 2004
Messages
732
Reaction score
0
Location
Wembley, London, U.K
Ok tomorrow I am going to convent my gravel set-up to sand set-up
So I need help on what to do and what to keep
I am going to keep my most of my water
Not going to wash my filter
What else do I need to do???
 
Do you have plants? (live)
If so keep away from sand. The roots on the plants dont grow well in sandy conditions.

James
 
first thoroughly wash all the sand....

Turn off heater....

fill large bucket with water from the tank....

catch fish and place in bucket with heater and an air supply with airstone if you can...

Use a dustpan with holes drilled into the bottom for removing gravel(gets into corners great)

use a cup/jug to place sand in tank...lower carefully to the bottom and tip slowly(only important if you're running your filter still)

Turn off heater in bucket...

Level out...replant/plant....

If not doing the above step then wait at least 15 mins for heater to cool down...

replace and switch on heater.......

return fish and most of the water from the bucket...if you have the space then carefully lower the bucket into the water and tip to let the fish just swim out...less stressful than catching them again... :)

EDITED to add.......Plants love sand and will grow really well... the sand allows plants to forem root hairs on thier roots which helps them get nutrients from the substrate.... you will need to add root tabs for the plants :D
 
Discomafia said:
Coral platy said:
Do you have plants? (live)
If so keep away from sand. The roots on the plants dont grow well in sandy conditions.

James
Not true...

Plants grow in sand in nature, don't they?
Yes But the sand does something to the roots on the plants. Dont they? I am not arguing. Just something my lfs told me today. Any newz on this and i am going to get sand for my rio 180.

James
 
Put your plants in clay pots filled with aquatic soil. That should solve the root problem. You could have a layer of aquatic soil then sand.
 
Coral platy said:
Discomafia said:
Coral platy said:
Do you have plants? (live)
If so keep away from sand. The roots on the plants dont grow well in sandy conditions.

James
Not true...

Plants grow in sand in nature, don't they?
Yes But the sand does something to the roots on the plants. Dont they? I am not arguing. Just something my lfs told me today. Any newz on this and i am going to get sand for my rio 180.

James
HOW DARE YOU CONTRADICT ME!!!!:sly: :sly: :sly: :sly: :grr: :grr: :grr:
























j/k. :p :p :whistle: Don't worry, we're just having a civilised conversation. :nod: What do you mean sand does something to roots? Damage the roots you mean? Can you elaborate, because I've never heard of this before. I think your best bet would be to PM one of the Plants forum regulars like Lateral or Konrad, they should know better than me. All I know is that sand is A-OK to be used in planted tanks, apart from that, I have no experience with sand as my tanks are all gravel substrate.
 
this is my planted tank... been running with sand for several years.... I have to chuck out plants every month....or you can't see the fish :)

5-foot-discus-FF.jpg
 
Nice tank! What's those plants on the background on the left? All I can see is water sprite I think it is...
 
Plants are :- vallis..... about 10 varieties of cypts.... hygrophilia...echinodorus tennelus.... amazon swords.....barclaya longifolia... nymphaea stellata and a couple of others I can't remember the name of, :D sorry.
 
Yup - same as babyfish, but with fewer plants, when I switched from gravel to sand my plants grew like mad. Sounds like typical dodgy LFS advice to me... Had they run out of sand? Perhaps the 'assistant' got commission for gravel but not sand! But then again, I'm no plant expert.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top