Hunting with the Badger 2024

Always a good idea to check out where you plan to hunt. When I worked in forests I got to know where the animals were generally, but you still have to check out your hunting areas. Will watch for new posts indicating your success. Elk can be pretty good eating, with all the sagebrush do they get a bit more gamey flavor? Mule deer in the Kootenays from the South Country (dry rain shadow area with sagebrush) have a tendency to get gamey, though never really badly.
 
Always a good idea to check out where you plan to hunt. When I worked in forests I got to know where the animals were generally, but you still have to check out your hunting areas. Will watch for new posts indicating your success. Elk can be pretty good eating, with all the sagebrush do they get a bit more gamey flavor? Mule deer in the Kootenays from the South Country (dry rain shadow area with sagebrush) have a tendency to get gamey, though never really badly.
Elk don't really eat sagebrush--maybe a little in the winter. They eat the grasses that grow between that sage brush. That's probably why they taste so good. Mulies will eat sage brush, but they generally prefer other stuff if they can get it. They rely on it heavily in winter because there isn't much else. Elk are big enough to dig through the snow and find the grass.
 
Updates.

I have debated whether to include this story, but I think it's important to talk about the failures and low points, not just the successes. A couple weeks ago, I injured a small bull, and it got away.

It was a textbook call-in, after a multi-mile, multi-thousand-foot hike to get the wind in our favor, at the end of a truly epic day. The area we were hunting is a patchwork of BLM and private land, and absolutely full of elk. In the evening, we saw a couple bulls and worked in to a spot we could legally shoot, setting ourselves up on a little rim on the edge of some thick timber, with a long, extremely steep, wide-open mountainside stretching above us. My teenage daughter, suffering from bad blisters on her feet, was sitting a couple hundred yards up the mountain watching the whole thing. She wasn't hunting or carrying a bow, just along for the experience.

For once, the elk did what they were supposed to. We heard branches popping for several minutes as we softly cow-called; I saw the antler tips appear through some dog hair aspens, thought he was going behind me toward my partner, but then he suddenly turned and popped out exactly where I needed him to, about 25 yards away, a range I'm very comfortable with. He was facing me, trying to figure out what I was but not alarmed. After a few seconds he turned broadside. I zeroed in on the sweet pocket behind the shoulder and sent my arrow.

Then disaster happened. The bull decided to pull a whitetail move, spinning around while the arrow was in the air. I saw him disappear into the aspens with the arrow stuck in his rump. I felt sick. Two bulls popped out onto the wide-open hill; we weren't sure if either of them were "mine," since there were several small bulls in the immediate area. One of them trotted way up high, coming within a few feet of my daughter. Watching them through binoculars, we could see the arrow in his butt. He and a few buddies goofed around on the mountainside for a good half hour or so; none of them seemed to have any idea what had happened.

The arrow was very high on the elk's rump, pointing straight back. We watched him for a long time, trying to figure a way to get close enough for a finishing shot. I told my buddy, a compound shooter, to pop him if he got the chance. But there was no chance--that slope didn't have enough cover to hide a prairie dog, and any move on our part would have spooked them further.

The elk was annoyed by the arrow, occasionally reaching his head back like he wanted to pull it out, but there was no blood on the arrow or on his rump patch. None at all. He didn't show any sign of weakness or wobbliness; he wasn't even limping. All of that led us to the conclusion that the arrow was sitting just under the skin. It had penetrated a good ten inches or so, but it it was barely in the muscle if at all. There wasn't any blood and the elk didn't seem distressed; in fact by the time he got to where I could try to pull a sneak on him, he had started grazing again.

By this time it was getting dark. "My" elk was grazing on the edge of a little draw with some tall sagebrush where I thought I could have a go at it. I blitzed up to the top of the mountain while my buddy and daughter stayed a little lower to keep an eye on him. But by the time I got to the top, traversed a couple hundred yards over, and snuck down the draw, he had wandered off and it was too dark to find him again.

I've hit a few animals badly with a rifle before, but I've always been able to get on them again and put them down. I made a good shot; I'm not blaming myself for that. My friend saw the whole thing from just a few yards away and he said the same thing: My arrow went right where it should have; I had no control over the elk switching ends and no way to know that's what he was going to do.

But I've been chasing elk with trad archery gear for over 20 years, and have yet to be successful. Shot opportunities are few and far between, and for various reasons this might be my last year to try. All the years, all the hours of making my own gear and practicing, practicing, practicing, trying to work things out with the family so I can be gone for days at a time, honing my arrows, getting myself in shape, scouting to find an area with really good chances, studying maps to plan an approach, hiking for hours to get into position, putting my daughter through all that pain...it all comes down to the moment of release, and my arrow went in an elk's butt, and it got away. It makes a person question their life choices.

But it isn't just the years and hours and stupidly lost opportunity. I really love elk. Not just hunting them. I love seeing them, watching them, talking to them, reading about them. They are admirable, courageous, magnificent creatures. I've killed a few (with a rifle) and I'm fine with that. But seeing that arrow in one, and knowing I did that to him, and he was suffering because of something I did, and there ain't a thing I can do to make it right. That's heart-breaking.

Now that I've had a couple of weeks to process the experience, think about what happened, and talk to several more experienced hunter friends, I know this is just part of it. It shouldn't happen often, but it does happen. I'm sure that bull is just fine; the arrow has probably worked itself out and he's probably forgotten about the whole thing by now. But. It's just about the worst thing that can happen to a hunter. Since part of my purpose here is to give non-hunters a taste of what it's like, I thought I should be honest about that. Sometimes you do everything right, and an animal gets hurt and doesn't die. It sucks. But that's the way it is.
 
That’s hunting . You hear about that kind of thing every so often but a guy never thinks it will happen to him . Silver lining to this dark cloud ? It won’t happen to you again and somewhere some other guy got your elk and is wondering about that arrow .
 
That’s hunting . You hear about that kind of thing every so often but a guy never thinks it will happen to him . Silver lining to this dark cloud ? It won’t happen to you again and somewhere some other guy got your elk and is wondering about that arrow .
Wondering about this weird scar on his hip, more likely. But yeah. You never think it will happen to you.
 
Friday we were back after them. Part of the Badger ethos, I guess: Once I decide something is worth doing, I don't give up easily.

We didn't see any elk Friday night, but heard a couple of distant bugles that told us where they were. Saturday morning, we spotted a bachelor herd at first light. It's weird for them to be hanging with other bulls this late; they should be rutting and chasing cows. But elk are notional critters that do what they want, and if you're going to hunt them you have to roll with it.

We snuck in about 100 yards from a small group of bulls and started cow calling. Like I said, they should be eager to find a cow this time of year, but they were only mildly interested. They kind of filtered our way through the timber, but not close enough for a shot. When we'd call, they'd look our way, shove each other around a bit, and rake trees with their antlers. They were like middle school boys: They realize girls are interesting, but have no idea what to do about them, so they just eat and fight each other instead. :lol:

After hunters and elk took a long break through the heat of the day, we went back in Saturday evening. My buddy spotted a solitary bull grazing across the canyon, and I thought I could pull a sneak on him. It's hard to see with an iphone picture, but he's in the middle of that little open spot in the top center of the picture.
little beaver.jpg


I left my pack with David and headed across the canyon. Once I was within 100 yards I took off my boots to move more quietly. About that time, I realized my elk had two buddies. Dang. Every set of eyes, ears, and nose you add to the equation roughly doubles the difficulty of getting into bow range without being detected.

There's an elk in this picture. Can you find it? I can't. :lol: But he's there.
hidden elk.jpg


There were a big bull, a medium six point, and a small but cool-looking, non-typical raghorn. 50 yards out, the elk had no idea that a predator was lurking nearby. They were eating, resting, shoving each other around, just elk doing elky things. So fun to be that close to them.

40 yards out, I'm belly crawling through the sagebrush. Not an easy thing with a longbow, but I can be a sneaky son of a gun. The big bull spotted my movement and jumped up; I blew a soft cow call and they settled right back down. I had to pull back and go in another direction to keep the sun out of my eyes.

30 yards. I was so close I heard the brush crunch when the big bull bedded back down. The two smaller bulls were feeding up over the hill. I moved when their heads were all down, froze when one of them looked up. Elk have amazing all-around vision, so if you can see its face, it can see you. Patience, patience.

20 yards. I'd been within 100 yards of these guys for over an hour now, and they have no idea I'm in the area. Wind is good, in my face. Take 'er slow, be patient, be ready to act decisively when the moment comes. I get off my belly, get an arrow on the string, contort my feet under me without poking my head above the sagebrush.

There. One of the smaller bulls has its head down, shoulder and chest exposed, 15-20 yards away. His head is down; he won't see me come up. All I need is one second to rise and shoot. I come up into a crouch and draw Big Red, picking a spot in the fold behind the shoulder.

But the bigger bull was still bedded, only about ten yards away. Seeing the movement (but probably still having no idea what I was), he thundered to his feet. My chosen target spun in my direction, with a "WHAT, WHAT, WHAT??" look on his face. I thought for a moment he was going to run over me. He turned broadside at 10 yards but I'm not going to shoot at a moving animal. I let out a chuckle to try to stop him, just for half a second, but they weren't having it. They trotted out over the ridge up-canyon, leaving me empty handed and awash in elk awesomeness.

My buddy was watching the whole thing from across the canyon. He saw the elk go trotting off, left his pack, and blitzed up the canyon, hoping to get ahead of them. They traveled 100 yards or so then started feeding again. He was able to sneak in, cut one off, and put it down with a spine shot. He credits me with the solid assist. :lol:

But elk will have their revenge. This is where he died. Field dressing him in the bottom of the creek, in the mud, in the dark, then carrying several hundred pounds of meat back to camp on our backs? It was every bit as fun as you'd imagine.
david's elk.jpg


We'll be heading out to the desert tonight to try to connect with a herd, and give these guys a night off. We might head back into this canyon tomorrow, though. It's a real honey hole.
 
To the victors belong the spoils . You’ll feast like a King this winter . You do get your cut don’t you ?
The usual deal is that if one partner scores and the other doesn't, the meat goes 50/50. But I'm still hopeful.

We got our butts handed to us in the desert. :lol: 🌵 There were tons of elk, hundreds of them. And not one chance in God's earth of getting within a quarter mile of them.

We actually did get up fairly close to a bull and five cows, but cover was extremely limited, and they zigged when we needed them to zag. Monday evening we got close to another bull with two cows. But just as we were about to start throwing out our most seductive cow calls, he suddenly winded a herd that was moving to water over a mile away. There must have been a hot cow in the bunch, because he got up, bugled, and took off in their direction, refusing to even throw a glance our direction. The disrespect!

This morning? We saw elk, we heard elk, we pursued elk, we got close to elk, elk saw us, elk went away. Sorry; I just woke up from a two-hour nap and that's about as much story telling as I'm up for now. ha ha
 
That’s beautiful country . Open and wild like an ocean . People don’t appreciate that kind of country enough but I like the wide open spaces like that .
The comparison with the ocean is right on: Wild, vast, isolated, wide-open but with great mysteries under the surface. Except out here, the hills don't move. Except sometimes, when the wind blows really hard. :lol:

People think the desert is ugly, and it is through the windows of a car speeding along I-80. To get the desert, you have to put in the time walking through it.
 
Decided to take a day off from hunting and regroup a bit: Sick family members, hunting gear in need of attention, and tanks that need some maintenance. Today I plan on getting the rifles sighted in, as firearm season starts Tuesday. I'll head back out Sunday afternoon, and I have Monday and Tuesday off, so I should get in another day and a half of chasing desert elk with the longbow. If nothing happens, perhaps I can score with the .270 on opening day.
 
OK, @Fishmanic , the photo you've been waiting for. But first, a story. It's amazing how quickly a lousy day can change into an amazing one.

Yesterday was the last day of bow hunting. I had a terrible time locating any elk. It was hot, for one thing, and the heat waves off the desert made it impossible to tell whether animals seen through binoculars were elk, wild horses, or cattle. Monday evening I spotted a herd in the distance, two or three miles away. I usually use my truck to get within a mile or so, then stalk from there. Long story short, some antelope hunters came along and blew my chances at calling in an elk, but I didn't think they spooked the herd too much.

So this morning, I was on them at first light. I spent about two hours crawling through the sagebrush trying to get within rifle range, using every tiny fold of land to stay out of sight (have I mentioned that I can be a sneaky son of a gun when the situation calls for it?), only to have another hunter shoot the bull when I was still about 500 yards away. I walked over to say hi and see this bull. The hunter was a young guy on his first elk hunt, with his wife, baby, and dad along. I couldn't get too ticked off: They were friendly, and he was super happy, and I must admit he did make a heck of a shot. They were locals, which is always a nice surprise. And it was a really cool bull, with several tines broken off while fighting for his cows. Cool to see. But...DANG. Desert elk bed down and disappear by about 8 a.m., and I had wasted the best part of the day.

I grumbled my way back to the truck. Decided to move away from Cyclone Rim, the big landmark in the area where both elk and hunters tend to hang out. Headed out north on an extremely sketchy two-track through the hills, glassing distant sagebrush flats for little black heads that indicate bedded elk. Before long, I saw antlers. Couldn't see the animal that was presumably connected to them, and my first thought was that it was a really big mule deer. But on further inspection, the tips were pretty far apart...if this was a muley, it was trophy book material. Or it might be a small elk.

I pulled the truck a little further down the road, out of sight of the mystery critter. I grabbed my rifle and my shooting sticks, just in case, scooted over the rim as sneakily as possible, and lifted my binos. First thing I saw was a whole bunch of little black ears sticking out of the sage, with a big set of antlers right in the middle of them. Yippee! I set my sticks and got the bull in my sights, then waited. I could only see the top of his head, no chance for a shot. The elk weren't looking my direction; they really seemed pretty satisfied to continue lounging around. I ranged them at 209 yards, a very comfortable range for my .270. After a few minutes of waiting, I remembered that I had an elk call in my pocket, so I blew a few cow calls. The cows--about five of them--jumped up and stared at me, but the bulls stayed bedded. Eventually the cows got nervous and started milling around, and the herd bull stood up. I waited until he turned broadside, and squeezed off a round. I knew I had hit him in the lungs, but bull elk are outrageously tough critters, and the elk hunters' maxim is "keep shooting until he's down." I took a couple more shots at him as he trotted up the hill; one hit him in the neck and the second apparently missed. Within probably 30 seconds of my first shot, he was down for the count.

So, I didn't score with the longbow, once again. But I guess this'll do.
bull!.jpg

It took me about three hours, working solo, to quarter out this beast and get all the meat loaded up. Definitely a job that's more fun--not to mention a lot safer--with a friend. But we do what we must.
quartering.jpg

A herd of wild horses moseyed by as I worked, so I took a break and watched them for a while.
horses.jpg


Here's a beautiful thing for a hunter to see in the rear view mirror. :lol: I had the music playing on the loud side for the two hour drive home.
rear view.jpg

Now the meat is safely in my buddy's walk-in cooler, and I'll get the test for CWD going tomorrow to make sure it's safe to eat. CWD doesn't tend to affect desert elk, so it should be fine. Should get around 250 pounds of meat to feed my family--and probably several friends--this coming year. Ain't life great?
 

Most reactions

Back
Top