Can someone tell me which of these cherry shrimp are male and female and if any of them are pregnant?

[Tacocat]

I have 4 cherries in my 5 gallon tank, and ever since I got them I've been hoping to see the propagation of the species, but I was disappointed the first time, due to the fact that they were both female. Since then, I got 2 more, and am now confused as to which ones are which. The 2 biggest ones are the originals.

 

[Sgooosh]

I have 4 cherries in my 5 gallon tank, and ever since I got them I've been hoping to see the propagation of the species, but I was disappointed the first time, due to the fact that they were both female. Since then, I got 2 more, and am now confused as to which ones are which. The 2 biggest ones are the originals.

just wait and time will tell because the females will have eggs onto them when it is time to breed

a(berried) shrimp
ps. this is not mine( i dont have shrimp yet)

 

[Naughts]

They all look female in the photos, the second photo is clearly female. The males are slimmer on the undercarriage between the legs and tail. Males may be less red as well.

 

[Slaphppy7]

They all look female in the photos, the second photo is clearly female. The males are slimmer on the undercarriage between the legs and tail. Males may be more red aswell.

Agreed.

We need pics of the profile of the shrimp, from the side.

RCS are easy to sex, even as juvies, males will have a concave belly (between the legs and the tail), and females will have a convex belly.

 

[Tacocat]

Agreed.

We need pics of the profile of the shrimp, from the side.

RCS are easy to sex, even as juvies, males will have a concave belly (between the legs and the tail), and females will have a convex belly.

Here, Unfortunately not all of the shrimp were in prime position to be photographed, and only 2 of them had their abdomen open to see.

 

[Tacocat]

Cherry shrimp 3 is the biggest, and has undergone 2 molts in 2 weeks. I'm almost 100% sure it's a she

Edit: The most in pic 2 is Shrimp 3's

 

[Slaphppy7]

All females, from what I see

Are they readily available up there? In the States they are, and not terribly expensive.

I'd recommend getting more, 10 if you can, to increase your odds of adding some males to the mix...

 

[Sgooosh]

All females, from what I see

Are they readily available up there? In the States they are, and not terribly expensive.

I'd recommend getting more, 10 if you can, to increase your odds of adding some males to the mix...

+ try getting them from a different source too

 

[Madisonkeug]

All females, from what I see

Are they readily available up there? In the States they are, and not terribly expensive.

I'd recommend getting more, 10 if you can, to increase your odds of adding some males to the mix...

They’re pretty readily available up north here! My Petsmart and Mr. pets have them all the time and they’re about 5-10$ each depending on what species of shrimp. RCS are usually on the lower end. Here in BC we had a hold on all crustaceans and molluscs sales as there was a contamination from a whole seller with a parasite that would be devastating to the ecosystem so at least the lower mainland has to wait three more days to sell any of those! May be why you’ve had a tough time getting some! I’d say get a decent number and throw them in a tank you’ll be sure to have at least one male if you get like 6+

 

[Tacocat]

All females, from what I see

Are they readily available up there? In the States they are, and not terribly expensive.

I'd recommend getting more, 10 if you can, to increase your odds of adding some males to the mix...

I would, but I was told my aquarium was already almost overstocked. Here's my other thread about it (https://www.fishforums.net/threads/...ore-waste-for-my-fluval-spec-5-gallon.472766/). I'm not really prepared to get more fish right now, as I already have 10 life forms in my 5 gallon, and I"m afraid the guppies might eat the babies and/or the female.

 

[Tacocat]

They’re pretty readily available up north here! My Petsmart and Mr. pets have them all the time and they’re about 5-10$ each depending on what species of shrimp. RCS are usually on the lower end. Here in BC we had a hold on all crustaceans and molluscs sales as there was a contamination from a whole seller with a parasite that would be devastating to the ecosystem so at least the lower mainland has to wait three more days to sell any of those! May be why you’ve had a tough time getting some! I’d say get a decent number and throw them in a tank you’ll be sure to have at least one male if you get like 6+

It's not a lack of shrimp that's the problem, it's actually finding a male. When me and my brother went to the fish store last time, they were looking for males, and the guy gave us a free shrimp, but we got 2 females.

 

[Madisonkeug]

It's not a lack of shrimp that's the problem, it's actually finding a male. When me and my brother went to the fish store last time, they were looking for males, and the guy gave us a free shrimp, but we got 2 females.

What else is in this little tank? I’d say shrimp aren’t really a huge impact on what you can stock tbh... they’re so small and help to breakdown fish and plant waste if anything they’re a bonus to any tank in my opinion!!! Lol

 

[Tacocat]

What else is in this little tank? I’d say shrimp aren’t really a huge impact on what you can stock tbh... they’re so small and help to breakdown fish and plant waste if anything they’re a bonus to any tank in my opinion!!! Lol

Is it possible to upgrade my built in filter to handle more waste for my Fluval Spec 5 gallon?

I have a fluvial spec 5, and I obviously didn't do my research because 2 weeks in I already have 10 life forms in it, and an algae bloom. I'm afraid I overstocked my tank and my parents won't let me return any fish due to the fact that we bought them. For this reason, I'm seeing if I can upgrade...

www.fishforums.net

Check my thread about it.

 

[Madisonkeug]

Is it possible to upgrade my built in filter to handle more waste for my Fluval Spec 5 gallon?

I have a fluvial spec 5, and I obviously didn't do my research because 2 weeks in I already have 10 life forms in it, and an algae bloom. I'm afraid I overstocked my tank and my parents won't let me return any fish due to the fact that we bought them. For this reason, I'm seeing if I can upgrade...

www.fishforums.net

Check my thread about it.

Okay sounds to me like maybe your not sure what combos will work on your tank! I don’t think you are iver stocked but maybe the fish are a bit incomparable... I get it we’ve all been there! You get a tank and you get super excited about all the possibilities and the store employees don’t actually know enough about the fish’ needs and compatibility or they just straight up don’t ask any questions bag your fish and send you off etc!! In my opinion, I would say you don’t need to worry about the number of shrimp. If you have like 10 shrimp and a 5 gallon tank I count it as two full-size fish towards stocking/bio load. Now what would be compatible with your cherry shrimp? The answer is not guppies LOL! Guppies are a hard water fish and although some people can manage to keep cherry shrimp in hard water I just don’t recommend it as it was really hard for me to keep measuring and adjusting the hardness when I tried it and it didn’t do well so I switched over to softer water and my red cherry shrimp are doing great. I have a bout 30 in a 5 gallon tank because they just breed like crazy! Something to keep in mind, they will only breed to the extent of a population that will survive in the tank, any remaining or extra shrimp will just die off and feed the ecosystem and you’ll have less shrimp and you won’t even notice because the other shrimp will just devour them and use the nutrients from that shrimp to survive. I would say getting a bunch of cherry shrimp and a bunch of little neon tetra (6) swimming around there will give you lots of movement and great colour against all the plants that you had in there and bonus: with a relatively low bio load!!!!! If you absolutely can’t get rid of the guppies then I would still get a couple more shrimp add maybe 4 more RCS pick the smaller slimmer looking ones to get a male but make sure they’re still lively (photo below of red cherry shrimp comparison) ask the employee to catch a bunch of them and look at them in the container and pick out the ones you think are females and put them back so you keep the males! Try to keep up with your water changes every week do about a 33-40% change with de-chlorinated water. If you go to a pet store some times they have little turkey basters that help remove fish poop for smaller tanks such as these (good idea to keep your tank looking as clean and nice as it is!!) and if needed for extra filtration you can always set up a very small sponge filter which will help with biological filtration and give your shimplettes a place to hide and eat and also give your tank a bit of extra surface irritation to help with oxygen levels

hope this helps if you have any questions feel free to message me or reply I’ll try to answer quick for ya!!

 

[Tacocat]

Okay sounds to me like maybe your not sure what combos will work on your tank! I don’t think you are iver stocked but maybe the fish are a bit incomparable... I get it we’ve all been there! You get a tank and you get super excited about all the possibilities and the store employees don’t actually know enough about the fish’ needs and compatibility or they just straight up don’t ask any questions bag your fish and send you off etc!! In my opinion, I would say you don’t need to worry about the number of shrimp. If you have like 10 shrimp and a 5 gallon tank I count it as two full-size fish towards stocking/bio load. Now what would be compatible with your cherry shrimp? The answer is not guppies LOL! Guppies are a hard water fish and although some people can manage to keep cherry shrimp in hard water I just don’t recommend it as it was really hard for me to keep measuring and adjusting the hardness when I tried it and it didn’t do well so I switched over to softer water and my red cherry shrimp are doing great. I have a bout 30 in a 5 gallon tank because they just breed like crazy! Something to keep in mind, they will only breed to the extent of a population that will survive in the tank, any remaining or extra shrimp will just die off and feed the ecosystem and you’ll have less shrimp and you won’t even notice because the other shrimp will just devour them and use the nutrients from that shrimp to survive. I would say getting a bunch of cherry shrimp and a bunch of little neon tetra (6) swimming around there will give you lots of movement and great colour against all the plants that you had in there and bonus: with a relatively low bio load!!!!! If you absolutely can’t get rid of the guppies then I would still get a couple more shrimp add maybe 4 more RCS pick the smaller slimmer looking ones to get a male but make sure they’re still lively (photo below of red cherry shrimp comparison) ask the employee to catch a bunch of them and look at them in the container and pick out the ones you think are females and put them back so you keep the males! Try to keep up with your water changes every week do about a 33-40% change with de-chlorinated water. If you go to a pet store some times they have little turkey basters that help remove fish poop for smaller tanks such as these (good idea to keep your tank looking as clean and nice as it is!!) and if needed for extra filtration you can always set up a very small sponge filter which will help with biological filtration and give your shimplettes a place to hide and eat and also give your tank a bit of extra surface irritation to help with oxygen levels

hope this helps if you have any questions feel free to message me or reply I’ll try to answer quick for ya!!

Me without any testing stuff and have no clue how to treat hard water and have no clue what RO water is and how to get it

Actually what sort of stuff do I need to test my aquarium, and are the shrimp compatible with tetras?