neither guppies or tetras (i presume neons?) are hardy anymore, they've been weakened massively by inter-breeding.
adding the first fish is pretty tough, a lot of the fish that used to be hardy are now weakened! dwarf gouramis used to be tough but are now notorious for carrying a fatal infection that wipes them out pretty quickly, so just be wary where you get your stock from!
i think maybe start with mollies, they may be the toughest of the bunch. mollies like to have a bit of salt in their water, if you need to know more about that, venture over the livebearers forum, i haven't kept mollies myself.
but bear in mind if you have salt in with the mollies, this limits your choices of "algae eater", as most plecs, otocinclus and corys are intolerant of salt in the water. avoid at all costs the "chinese algae eater" or "golden sucking loach" these guys are monsters in disguise!