OK , time for an update.
(To those of you also on UKAPS this is the same as what I put on my journal there. I am duplicating because there are some contributors on here who are not on UKAPS and I appreciate the input from all of you
)
The smelly substrate saga is over (I hope). I have taken out the substrate I had just in case it was that, but I have to be honest, so many others have had success with JBL aquabasis+ and the Tesco cat litter that I think it must have been the bogwood I had in there. That is now back at the shop I bought it from and the owner has agreed it does indeed pong !
I have 1.5 bags of wet cat litter and 1.5 bags of dry cat litter. If anyone wants this and is near to Eastbourne, you are welcome to it. Just flick me a message. I will be listing the Aquabasis plus for sale, to see if there is any interest there. There is about £20 to 25 worth of it. Just got to weigh it first.
What I have chosen to do
After a LOT of deliberation and great advice and guidance from guys on here and elsewhere (some of whom are double ups, LOL) I have decided to go with the Colombo Florabase. One thing I did not realise about it in the first place was that it had a high CEC and the thing that put me off was that it might just become an inert substrate after a while. But now I have been put right on that I am far happier using it.
I have got 10L of brown and 2 x 5L of black. The shop only had that, and not all black. Actually I don't mind that. I have a few choices...
1) Put the brown under the black and keep a uniform colour. I perceive a problem though, in that if I pull plants out at any time, they will drag some of the other colour to the surface and I will have a blotchy affect.
2) Cut a swathe through with the black like a river bed or some such feature.
3) Have the black to the fore and the brown to the rear where there will be denser planting and less of it will be visible.
Any thoughts on this as to what would look best would be welcomed...
A few questions...
Do I wash it ?
Can i just chuck it in, plant, and fill, then deal with the ammonia leaching by frequent water changes, or should I let it soak with a number of water changes first ?
If (when) I put purigen in the filter, do i do it after the tank water is clear (a day or so I am anticipating) ?
Cheers.
Now finally you might start to see some movement on this.