Why are her gills red?

Thanks for all the tips! I am planning on eventually replacing most of my fake plants with real ones, this was a second hand tank so the decor is EXTREMELY fluorescent :sick:. I will try to do more water changes. A little background, this is my first tank and I am also a teen who currently cannot get a job, so I don’t have a ton of money to spend on things. They get tropical flakes once a day, with a fasting day every week and some occasional blanched/boiled veggies such as peas and cucumbers. It’s not the best food in the world, but it’s what I can give them.
I did get my water tested my by LFS when another one of my fish died a couple months ago, and both the (seemly knowledgeable) employee and my uncle who keeps fish said that those nitrates are on the higher end of safe, yet shouldn’t cause any issues.
Not all bad, to be sure.
The nitrates may be within the 'safe' zone, but they're at the edge of that zone, meaning far from perfect.
Water changes, which should cost practically nothing, bar the small amounts of essential water conditioner, refresh the tank water and should keep toxin levels to a minimum.
Fish exposed to less-than perfect conditions are stressed and the effects of that stress can be cumulative.

Did you identify what caused the death of your other fish?
 
Not all bad, to be sure.
The nitrates may be within the 'safe' zone, but they're at the edge of that zone, meaning far from perfect.
Water changes, which should cost practically nothing, bar the small amounts of essential water conditioner, refresh the tank water and should keep toxin levels to a minimum.
Fish exposed to less-than perfect conditions are stressed and the effects of that stress can be cumulative.

Did you identify what caused the death of your other fish?
I believe it was either swim bladder or dropsy. I tried fasting her and feeding her peas, but it didn’t help. Another thing that didn’t help was I had to leave for a couple days and my dad had to take care of them, but he didn’t know how to take care of her so he didn’t do anything except add some salt when I asked him to. By the time I got back, it was too late :(
 
I believe it was either swim bladder or dropsy. I tried fasting her and feeding her peas, but it didn’t help. Another thing that didn’t help was I had to leave for a couple days and my dad had to take care of them, but he didn’t know how to take care of her so he didn’t do anything except add some salt when I asked him to. By the time I got back, it was too late :(
The LFS said she might have reacted to a weird spike in my alkalinity, which skyrocketed to around 200-210 the day before I started noticing symptoms, even though I did a water change immediately after seeing it was that high.
Edited to add that no, I don’t know what caused the spike, there hadn’t been anything out of the ordinary and my pH was still the same.
 
A healthy fish gills are naturally a vivid pink/red color, They should not look a brown or silver color as this will indicate there is some sort of infection in the fish.
 
Look I’m a Pilot I have 101 things to think about every minute of everyday as well as my pets

My pets always come first before work before flying and before myself that’s my golden rule

I’m over and out on this one now

Said all I need too
 
Look I’m a Pilot I have 101 things to think about every minute of everyday as well as my pets

My pets always come first before work before flying and before myself that’s my golden rule

I’m over and out on this one now

Said all I need too
You’ve made your point. I have already said that I will try to do more frequent water changes. Right now, I’m trying to figure out if there is something wrong with my fish that I can help right away. Thank you for your advice.
 
You know, @Avel1896 might be right. Gills are supposed to be red, afterall. Maybe we're overthinking this. :)
Funny you should say that...
I returned to the post this morning and I've been watching that video in the original post for well over half an hour now and, once I got over the trauma of seeing the poor fish sat in a glass ( ;) ), I couldn't really see anything wrong with it.
It's rate of breathing seems fine and she doesn't appear to be overly stressed.
 
That is true, however her gills didn’t use to look this red… I’m hoping it might just be a problem with my parameters that will become apparent when I get the better test kit
You know, @Avel1896 might be right. Gills are supposed to be red, afterall. Maybe we're overthinking this. :)
 
Funny you should say that...
I returned to the post this morning and I've been watching that video in the original post for well over half an hour now and, once I got over the trauma of seeing the poor fish sat in a glass ( ;) ), I couldn't really see anything wrong with it.
It's rate of breathing seems fine and she doesn't appear to be overly stressed.
I know, I felt really bad I just couldn’t get any pictures of her in the main tank besides the one that I posted :( she was returned immediately after I finished taking the video
 
I know, I felt really bad I just couldn’t get any pictures of her in the main tank besides the one that I posted :( she was returned immediately after I finished taking the video
Given that a good, clear photo is usually essential for a good diagnosis, this method is used by many, just as you used it.

Of course, you could easily have wound up us by saying that that was your tank and asking what else did you need for it. ;)
 
Given that a good, clear photo is usually essential for a good diagnosis, this method is used by many, just as you used it.

Of course, you could easily have wound up us by saying that that was your tank and asking what else did you need for it. ;)
Lol, I could’ve but that wouldn’t have helped her, would it? 😁
 

Most reactions

Back
Top