🌟 Exclusive Amazon Black Friday Deals 2024 🌟

Don’t miss out on the best deals of the season! Shop now 🎁

Which Shrimp For My Community Tank?

PlatinumAngel

Fish Crazy
Joined
Jun 13, 2008
Messages
225
Reaction score
0
Location
Ontario Canada
I would like to add a few shrimp to my tank.
Locally I've seen ghost shrimp and cherry shrimp, but I'm open to mail ordering.

Are they at risk of being eaten by anything in my 75gal tank? (see sig)
I'd really like to add them, but not if they're just going to be lunch.
 
Bad news I am afraid:-

2 Platinum Angels --------------3 african dwarf frogs
2 Bala sharks

Not a good idea putting any of these in with shrimp, especially not the frogs and the bala sharks. Not unless you are adding them as food anyway.

Ade
 
well the frogs are alone in the 10 gallon....


so no go with the balas? Anything else you can recomend to control alge?
 
Most live bearers are pretty good algae eaters, including platies, sword tails and guppies. Bristlenose catfish can be quite good as well. However by far the best way to control algae is to actually find the cause and fix it, rather than putting things in to eat it. Have a look in the planted tank area for some hints on causes and fixes.

Ade
 
Thanks. I think cycling has something to do with it a bit? My ammonia levels just got to 0 yesterday so it's just starting to finish cycling.

My guppies don't get down there to bother with it. Usually just see my angels nipping at the plants, or the balas occasionally.
 
Ammonia is often one of the biggest causes of nuisance algae, so it could well be that your problems reduce as your tank finishes cycling properly. You could try adding more fast growing plants (things like hygrophila difformis and mexican oakleaf) as this will help, also make sure that your light aren't on for more than 8-10 hours a day as too long a lightng period doesn't help any.

To be completely honest snails are probably one of the most efficient algae eaters that I have found. Most fish just nibble it a bit, same with shrimp (believe me, I have enough of them! lol), where a good group of snails (apple snails (bridgesi, not the giant ones! lol) or nerites are good) will decimate even diatoms in pretty short order. Not much though that will touch cladophora algae or black beard algae. Blue green algae (cyanobacter) is usually a good sign that you have dead spots/poor flow or just too much ammonia.

One observation however, you say your tank has only just started to finish cycling, yet you have quite high initial stocking levels. This probably hasn't helped. Been such a young tank shrimp wouldn't have been a good idea even if you had had suitable tank mates really.

Don't let the algae panic you, most tanks go through an algae rich phase at some point.

Ade
 
well it has so many fish because they were moved from a 25 gallon tank.
Seems I've finnished cycling, as my ammonia and nitrite have been at 0 now for a couple days. The guy at my LFS said catfish grow big and eat smaller fish, so I didn't get any. I got two flying fox', which he recommended.
I thought about adding more plants. Seems my LFS don't have a very good selection right now, so I'm going to mail order some.
The fox's seem to be going at the algee a bit, but it's the long stringy stuff I'm wanting to get rid of.
What do you think about the catfish comment? that they eat smaller fish once they grow.
 
i have ghost shrimp in my community tank. i thought they were dead but lately i randomly turn the light on at night and fight a few out scavanging.

ive got countless places for them to hide in my tank though...id suggest you to have the same if youd like to keep them

the good thing is ghost shrimp are cheap, if they get eaten they get eaten! some will always survive for a while though
 
The guy at the LFS probobly thought you were talking about l;arge predetory catfish as opposed to the sucker mouthed loricarids(sp?) which generally eat algae. If your tank has lots of diatoms or green algae I'd recomend otos.
 
Either that or the guy in the LFS doesn't realise that loricarids, corydoras, brochis etc are also species of catfish. lol. I've always like to go for something a bit more old fashioned for bottom dwellers though, liking a large group of kuhli loaches rather than corydoras or brochis.

Flying foxes are nice fish, and very tough on algae. Reason I don't usually suggest them however is that in my experience they are also quite tough on plants. I have kept them a few times and found them even more destructive than plecs. They're also quite territorial, and I would strongly suggest getting a few more to spread the aggression a bit.

Ade
 
Otos? Ok, I'll look for them. Gah!! should I get one, a pair? A few?

As for the flying foxes.. how many would you recomend? He said they weren't semi-agressive at all. They do seem to be going to town on the alge though lol although right now they're going after each other a bit, not sure if they're fighting or playing or what. Will try to find an oto catfish in my city, hopefully I can find one.

and I'm not sure which alge, diatoms or green I have... it's long and stringy and only on my two small plants really.
 
Stringy algae is hair algae - there's green hair algae, which I get occasionally, and black beard algae, which tends to grow on tanks. I don't know about the black algae, but flying foxes go for hair algae, but my otos don't touch it.

If you get otos, get a group. They don't hang around together like most schooling fish, but they like their own company and are easier to feed in bigger groups.
 
looking again at my plants, looks like the foxes did their job already! There isn't any of that alge left on them! :good:
 

Most reactions

Back
Top