jollysue
Fish Connoisseur
The Cut and paste below is Ian's post at this link
here
Ian's post:
Aug 3 2007, 03:43 PM Post #32
Fish Crazy
Group: Members
Posts: 132
Joined: 28-August 06
From: Kidderminster, Worc's
Member No.: 24242
Just a word on trilineatus and julii and without casting any doubt on anyone's identification capabilities, unless the actual collecting site is known. i.e. the river from which the fish were caught it is impossible to state that the fish called C. julii are actually that species. The colour patterns of both species is variable with spotted and wavy streaked patterns showing up, the variability is probably more prominent in C. trilineatus.
Most if not all SA exporters purport to have C. julii and because none report where the fish have been collected from any true identification is impossible. I certainly would not put money on an id from pictures no matter how close to type they look.
Ian
here
Ian's post:
Aug 3 2007, 03:43 PM Post #32
Fish Crazy
Group: Members
Posts: 132
Joined: 28-August 06
From: Kidderminster, Worc's
Member No.: 24242
Just a word on trilineatus and julii and without casting any doubt on anyone's identification capabilities, unless the actual collecting site is known. i.e. the river from which the fish were caught it is impossible to state that the fish called C. julii are actually that species. The colour patterns of both species is variable with spotted and wavy streaked patterns showing up, the variability is probably more prominent in C. trilineatus.
Most if not all SA exporters purport to have C. julii and because none report where the fish have been collected from any true identification is impossible. I certainly would not put money on an id from pictures no matter how close to type they look.
Ian