What Fish Are The Best To Put Into A Cycled Tank First

Platys, Swordtails, Mollies, Guppies and Endlers are all among the livebearers and as such you have to think about the possibility of tons of baby fry. Most of these will breed non-stop. This can create a couple of problems for beginners: first, it can unexpectedly raise your tank stocking load, having cycling implications if your filter is immature; second, it can get you into a cycle of always trying to find people who will take fish from you so you don't have to buy new tanks. There's nothing wrong with this - I only point it out so you can go in with your eyes open. For some people these things are what its all about and what they want!

Of these, platies and swords and perhaps endlers present the fewest problems. Mollies have the trickiest water chemistry needs and guppies can be rather non-hardy sometimes these days. I can't comment much on endlers, which are great for tiny tanks. Mollies are definately "do-able" by beginners but I usually think beginners would at least be better off if they did more research on them before getting them.

There are probably tons of fish that make great "first community fish after fishless cycling." A few that come immediately to mind are Zebra Danios, Rasbora Heteromorpha (Harlequins), 2 or 3 male platies, many of the larger corys, lots of types of shoaling tetras. Plenty of barbs are hardy but they of course usually work better in tanks of bigger fish.. cherry barbs might be an exception, not sure. Researching the various common tetras is a good direction for beginners to go in I feel. There's lots of choice with many different looks and productive and clear cut things to learn from the research.. certain ones are very nippy, so you'll not want them but others may be great. Nearly all of the tetras will have minimum shoal numbers to find out about.

Angels, cichlids and various other big fish more often fall into the "centerpiece" category for many beginners who don't happen to have huge tanks. Often people will wait some months on these just because they are expensive and they want the tank to be even more stable. Beginners often don't realize how much more stable there tank will be (ie. water will be even nicer for the fish) at 6 months and at 1 year, but that's usually a reality.

~~waterdrop~~
 
Simon

I'm a newbie having cycled my tank earlier this year.

I have Gold Barbs in a 180 ltr tank with a pair of Pearl Gouramis and a shoal of Emperor Tetras amongst others.

No issues after 2 months or so.

In fact my gold barbs just play around with eachother and have not once bothered my Emperor Tetras or my pearls.

When I was researching my stocking wish list I too was wanting Barbs as i'd seen so many and fell in love with the Tiger Barbs,Rosy Barbs and Black Ruby Barbs but members on here and my LFS said they were prone to be nippy.

The advice I got though was that the Gold Barbs and Cherry Barbs were fine and they were right from my experience so far of the gold barbs.

I think the Cherry Barbs look cool as well and are smaller if size of tank etc is an issue but I read/was told they are or can be quite timid so I went for the Gold Barbs instead.

Very playful and fun to watch,but very very gready and nearly doubled in size already :)

Hope that helps
 
Hmmm, it's just platys, danios and endlers that are almost fool proof isn't it?
Surely not everyone starts with those?
Would it perhaps be easier to say which fish are definite no-nos for a freshly cycled tank? :lol:
 
i actually cycled my tank with platies :blush: and from this experience i can say they are extremly hardy. they make excellent community fish too, and if u get all males or all females u won't have to worry about excessive breeding. the same applies for swordtails from what i've seen. both are very active fish, and great to keep u entertained. both come in a wide variety of colors and patterns and u should be able to find something that will complinant any future additions to ur tank.


if u do decide to go this route i would get at least three, as they will school together and be much more active and fun to watch.
 
Hmmm, it's just platys, danios and endlers that are almost fool proof isn't it?
Surely not everyone starts with those?
Would it perhaps be easier to say which fish are definite no-nos for a freshly cycled tank? :lol:
Somehow we're all too lazy to make up these lists. :lol:

I'm always repeating harlequins, danios, platies and a handful of others as very foolproof but there are no doubt dozens of others. All those tetras out here are one of the main families I think of but there are plenty of hardy cories too, although cories are peppered with delicate ones so you have to be careful. (there are 100's of types of cories.)

Then another thing that tends to limit the comments here in the beginner section is that often we're only suggesting beginner community fish, whereas if you moved to a larger faster tank then lots of barbs are hardy starters and same will be true for even more exotic fish in many cases.

~~waterdrop~~
 
I cycled mine with 4 zebra danios about a year ago before I found this site and knew about fishless cycling.

Luckily I still have all 4, so I can confirm the danios are extremely hardy and pretty.

Andy
 
I've always started with zebra danios and never had any problems with them. They are a nice active fish and don't grow too much or fast either. I personally think they are universally recommended for beginners because they are also about the cheapest fish you can find as well as being hardy. So if you do have problems learning the ropes of cycling and testing and changes and cleaning, they can withstand a few small mistakes by a newbie.

JMHO


I cycled mine with 4 zebra danios about a year ago before I found this site and knew about fishless cycling.

Luckily I still have all 4, so I can confirm the danios are extremely hardy and pretty.

Andy
 

Most reactions

Back
Top