I can't really tell you (though the one in the 1st photo on the right (Aquarium water)looks ever so slightly greener but so does the one on the right on the second photo but you say that this time it's the tap water on right, You need to see the surfaces of the liquid in the tubes to be in the same light (there is every chance that you could have more ammonia in your tap water, I think water authorities in the UK are allowed to let water with ammonia at 0.5ppm get to our homes, your filter could process this out)