Red Sea Marine Tests

Crazy fishes

Fish Addict
Joined
Jan 21, 2008
Messages
873
Reaction score
0
I have been testing with the red sea marine lab but I think the ammonia and nitrite tests are faulty. They never change colour; they remained the same colour throughout the whole cycling period and even now with my new livestock they refuse to change colour. I do know that the chemistry is changing but they don't follow these conditions. Anyone had anything similar? I think I may have to replace them with a different kit. :blink:

Regards
 
You could add something that will rot into a jar and find out what your ammonia test kit will say. But that serves a merely theoretical purpose if the test kit should turn out not to be sensible enough.

I got API and Dry-tab test kits and two different tanks that are in different rooms and I'm too lazy to swap test kits.

The API test kit I use with the brackish tank and it shows now always 0 on ammonia/nitirite/nitrate as the tank has some plants and is rather under-stocked.
In the past, during cycling, and subsequent mini-cycles, and occasional HEAVIEST overfeeding (I'm overfeeding all the time), the API test kits showed reasonable figures on all three substances, e.g. ammonia and nitrite 0.25 ppm or 0.50, nitrate 5, 10 or higher up to 80.

When I now had a cyanobacteria outbreak and measured in the marine tank with the Dry-tab test kit I got ammonia/nitrite/nitrate 0.25/0.25/40 ppm.

The API test kit with the same water showed ammonia/nitrite/nitrate all zero.


To get an idea what's going on, I tested my RO water and my tap water with the Dry-tab test and with those water samples the Dry-tab shows everything zero as expected.

So, it looks like that the API test is simply not sensible enough. What is most astonishing is that the API nitrate test colour chart has a colour for 0 and the next one for 5 ppm. It showed zero on the marine water.
But the Dry-tab test has colours in steps of 0, 20, 40, and showed 40 ppm for the same marine water but zero for both tap and RO water.

I did those tests twice on two different days with exactly the same results.

So, somewhat fishy is going on there. There is a difference between the nitrate in the tank water and RO water that the API test doesn't show even with the finer grained steps of 0 and 5 ppm.

I forgot to mention that I got also an oxygen test from Salifert that showed always zero with every water sample even with the LFS's water.
I got the test replaced and now I am getting reasonable results. That is 5 ppm in the marine tank and 8 ppm in the brackish tank.
 
I use RED SEA test lab and the testing procedure to be fine.
Exactly how are you performing the tests
Regards
BigC
 
I am using it as instructed on the little colour chart and I read the little book/leaflet thingy as well. I am not saying Red sea tests are rubbish I just think mine are faulty. The ammonia and nitrite tests (nothing important around the time of cycling :lol:) never change colour they remain the same. Ammonia test sample is a mint green colour and nitrite is clear and pretty much colourless with a hint of bluey green ( that is if you try really hard to see it). I have tried numerous different samples and they all give the same result. As you may have read in my last thread I have two clowns and my CUC in the tank which are thriving; doesn't sound like 0.5 ppm of ammonia and 0.1 ppm nitrite are in the tank does it?

Regards
 
Sounds more like Zero Ammonia and near Zero Nitrite to me.
My Ammonia went off the scale >7.5 (dark blur/purple) then after about 2 weeks its where your at now
Once that fell the Nitrite readings were bright red/pink and then also dropped to where you are at, after a further week.
I then did a 50% waterchange and tested for Nitrates, this came in very low and I added some CUC
Hope this was of some help
Regards
BigC
 

Most reactions

Back
Top