Flossybean
Fish Fanatic
- Joined
- Nov 21, 2018
- Messages
- 62
- Reaction score
- 3
Id like to keep corydoras julii and they need a ph of 6 to 7.5 could i add peat moss to make a difference?
Don’t miss out on the best deals of the season! Shop now 🎁
But the original post pH gone up to 8 tap water is also 8. suggests tank and tap is at 8
Yes, agreed. My post #6 was an explanation of the likely reason the pH test results for the tank water went from 7.2 to 8.
Id like to keep corydoras julii and they need a ph of 6 to 7.5 could i add peat moss to make a difference?
I am clearly misreading something then, you are suggesting that dissolved CO2 is causing an increase in pH from the old tap reading of 7.2 to the new tap reading of 8? with no apparent behavioural change in testing method?
No. The water in the tap and in the tank is basically the same pH, 7.8 or 8. The OP said his earlier test was 7.2, and this was subsequently confirmed to have been tap water that had not been out-gassed, so the CO2 that seems to have been in the tap water then resulted in a false and lower pH reading.
Yeah but my point is if the OP didn't know to off gas the water all of his readings will be affected by the inclusion of CO2?
His past tap readings (which were not off gassed) were 7.2 this has risen to 8 (not off gassed) and has dropped when been left for a while to 7.8?
No, not necessarily. CO2 in the tap water can vary from hours to days. If he off-gasses the tap water and then tests it, the pH should be close to accurate so it eliminates any possibility of CO2 affecting the test.
The new test with off-gassed tap water should confirm all this. Now, water in an aquarium with fish naturally tends to become acidic due to the organics. The GH/KH factor in. Then there is the diurnal issue of pH changing over every 24 hours in an aquarium, and we do not know when in the day these tests were carried out, so that could easily explain a change of 0.2 or even 0.4 in pH from a test in the early morning to a test in the late afternoon.
Oh, ok , is there much difference between the two then?Just because the label said julii doesn't mean they are julii. It is very common for shop to put a julii label on a tank full of trilineatus. It may not even be the shop's fault - if that's what the wholesaler calls them, that's what the shop calls them.
Thank you xThere is not much difference, it's mainly a question of knowing what fish are in your tank.
http://www.seriouslyfish.com/species/corydoras-julii/
http://www.seriouslyfish.com/species/corydoras-trilineatus/
Some of the parameters in the profiles are in different units - you can use the calculator in the How To Tips above to convert them.