I had a very Large Red Breasted Pacu, that I grew up, when I had tanks 20 years ago... I always fed him Gold Fish, & Hikari Cichlid Gold, color enhancing food, large pellets, he started out about baseball size, & went almost 24" before I lost him, knocking off a weighted tank cover... as he got bigger, I had to discontinue feeding him gold fish, he was like a big puppy in a kiddie pool, & gallons of water would go on the floor, while he chased them... as he continued to grow, the grey color took over, & his fins & tail lost their red color... I did some reading... ( ya know, back in books, before the www. ) & found out a major portion of their diet was roots, fruits, & seeds... I promptly plopped a carrot in the tank, but he wouldn't touch it... I trained him to eat them, by 1st dicing them up the size of the pellets... eventually he learned to eat whole carrots, chomping them like Bugs Bunny... a strange thing happened though, he started getting his color back, in his fins and tail... I wasn't really expecting to see a change, as he had pretty much grown up on the "red" pellets...