I Give Up

riverman444

Fishaholic
Joined
Feb 13, 2006
Messages
462
Reaction score
0
Location
Omaha, Nebraska USA
I have been adjusting lighting schedule. I have changed up fert and trace schedules, but this black hairy crap still clings to the outer edges of the leaves on my sword plants.

Does anyone have a good way to get rid of this crap. I hate it. It makes my sword plants look like they have hair and I see it every time I look at my tank.

Help
:-(
 
Hi absolute nightmare that algae i had that on my swords for ages but its gone now if the leaves got to covered i removed them.I also placed over the area in my tank where all my swords are a floating plant amazon frogbit,i started with a few plants but now the area is completely covered so they are not getting as much light and the algae has now completely gone.
I have staerted the EI dosing method this week just hope it does not come back
karl
 
Overdose the tank with flourish excel, this will definatly get rid of it, search this section, ive written some lenghty posts about this in the past and i have done it myself, just be careful doing it especially if you keep shrimp in the tank as it will probably kill them.
 
I have an anubias with the same problem. Removing leaves on one of those is much more drastic than with the swordplant! So I have just been trying to keep it shaded and basically, doing nothing and wishing it would go away! I don't see it anywhere else in the tank.
I have vals in there and have heard excell kills them. The anubias would be easier to move, so my question for Zig would be do you think it would work for me to set up a small extra tank to dose the anubias with the excell? Or would it just get "reinfected" upon returning it to the main tank?
 
Overdose the tank with flourish excel, this will definatly get rid of it, search this section, ive written some lenghty posts about this in the past and i have done it myself, just be careful doing it especially if you keep shrimp in the tank as it will probably kill them.


Thanks, Zig. I've got some Excel in the fridge along with some other Seachem stuff. I'll give it a try and let you know how it works.
 
I have an anubias with the same problem. Removing leaves on one of those is much more drastic than with the swordplant! So I have just been trying to keep it shaded and basically, doing nothing and wishing it would go away! I don't see it anywhere else in the tank.
I have vals in there and have heard excell kills them. The anubias would be easier to move, so my question for Zig would be do you think it would work for me to set up a small extra tank to dose the anubias with the excell? Or would it just get "reinfected" upon returning it to the main tank?

Tammyliz......Anubias just seem to be prone to algae, if it was just one plant i would use a spot treatment with the excel, basically you get a syringe and fill it with some excel, use about 5ml for a 10gallon, switch off your filter and make sure the water is still, and then you inject the excel from the syringe at the infected areas of the plant under the water, its a localised treatment rather than treating the whole tank, within a couple of days you should see the bba change colour and then you know it is working.

Follow the instructions on the label, you might not have to overdose if you do it this way, excel will definatly affect certain plants and probably kill them, vallis and egeria are the main ones that people seem to have the most trouble with but it can affect other plants as well, you can never be sure until you dose your tank, some people have no trouble at all and with others it just melts certain plants really quickly, within a few days.

The plant shouldn't get reinfected if there is not bba in the other tank, if there is, treat the whole tank.

The thing is with bba that i find, is that if you dont treat it or get rid of it, it will spread throughout the entire tank and is really stubborn and difficult to remove entirely, ODing the excel is a good effective method of dealing with it, just watch your plants and fish when you do it though, i had no problems with my fish but it did melt some of my plants, but it got rid of the bba.
 
Get a SAE.......that's the ONLY fish that will actually eat this stuff......get 2-3 of them.......they prefer being kept in small groups. Careful not to get a Flyin Fox or False SAE instead.......SAE has black horizontal stripe from tip of snout to fork of tail, all fins are clear.

I have tried the black out method, various algae removal products.......without success.......only a SAE did the job, and did it well........reducing the amount of potasium and direct sun light is a huge help also.

G-luck.
 
Thanks Zig, I guess I'll try that spot treatment. You said three days...am I leaving the filter off the entire time or just for a short while? And am I dosing once a day? Or just once?

I think its just on this one plant but I have no way of being certain there isn't some tiny amount on something else I can't see. Are you sure I shouldn't just take it out, along with the small piece of bogwood, put it in a 2 gallon tank and treat it there?

Tammy
 
Thanks Zig, I guess I'll try that spot treatment. You said three days...am I leaving the filter off the entire time or just for a short while? And am I dosing once a day? Or just once?

I think its just on this one plant but I have no way of being certain there isn't some tiny amount on something else I can't see. Are you sure I shouldn't just take it out, along with the small piece of bogwood, put it in a 2 gallon tank and treat it there?

Tammy

No you just leave the filter off for about 10 minutes when you are administering the dose to stop the excel being blown all over the tank and not ending up in the spot we want it too, and then turn the filter back on as normal, its just a localised treatment aimed directly at the algae, in this case the bba on the anubia plant. So just knock the filter off for about 10 -15 minutes in total each time you dose the excel at the algae, it just gives the excel a better chance to have a more direct impact without ending up somewhere else in the tank where you dont want it.

You can put it in the 2 gallon if you want and just treat the whole tank, just do a search for previous posts, good luck with it.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top