ok thanks , i did'nt think if she could eat them or not ! well i can count four fry now at least ( i think there are 6 ) so I am moving her back to the community tank and leaving the fry in their tank alone with some ' first bites' i think she is still expecting but i don't want too many fry anyway with it being the first pregnancy i have dealt with . If she does have some more in the community tank they will have to fend for themselves but there are a lot of hiding places for them but 3 tiger barbs to deal with as well ! I'll just wait and see but thanks for your help x