Head First Into The Salt

Today i feel like quiting and since this is my journal on a fish forum site you all get to deal with my rant... unless of course you don't read the post haha.

Snails....*insert non family friendly language here* Snails..... I have had nothing but problems with snails... i have some nasaurius ( sp? ) that are around still although from what i read they don't eat a whole lot of algae but any time i add any variety of Turbo snail they just stay where i put them till i decide they must be dead (usually 3 - 4days) or less if its obvious as in shrimp turn them over and start picking... so without snails in the tank i have had CUC issues and wow is it starting to show, i have hermits and some emerald crabs and a few shrimp.. but its a 90G tank...... And to make matters worse i was at 6 LFS's last weekend and the only snails any of them have are turbo's and i would rather try something different before going back to turbos cause seriously... Ive tried different acclimation processes and practices to no avail, biggest confusion here is that other inverts and corals seem to be doing just fine GRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

Tank looks absolutely Terrible right now.. mostly due to afore mentioned CUC issues and there being fish... in hindsight i shouldn't have added anything after my clowns once i realized the snails were becoming an issue..... *facepalm* Again corals/fish seemed (i say seemed cause there are some fish issues now) happy and healthy, mostly its the sand that looks awful, i have been doing WC's more than i had hoped to be doing but its not making much differnce and my water tests along with tests done by 3 fish places all agree that my water stats are good... again as evidenced by coral health and such... the other day i siphoned a bunch of algae out as part of a wc, and it looked ok for a few days but then....... *le sigh*

I've lost a coral and a few fish i will admit, mostly due to my own lack of knowledge and just not doing things right.. and maybe not doing them in the right order.. for example the firefish who got chased around by the flame angel for 2 days then went and hid never to be seen again.... then there was the orange spot goby.... no idea what killed him, feel terrible about that... Only coral i lost was a frogspawn that i really think just got too cold since it was nasty out when i picked him up.. also i think some of the heads were physically damaged during transport.... so that one i chalk up to Upsetting, but educational.

Also in an attempt to deal with bubbles on the back wall i upset my BTA (purchased in a moment of weakness but with weekly feedings was doing great) who is now moving around the tank looking for a new spot.. not a huge deal but seems to be putting itself in some pretty strange places, but that i can deal with.

And then a little ago i made my biggest mistake... Every week when i went to the one LFS i spent a good 15min just watching a beautiful powder brown tang... the 3rd week the store owner goes.. why don't you just buy him.. i say hmm... how long has he been here, owner says 5 weeks... he looks healthy, ive been watching him for 3 weeks so after some price negotiation i take him home, i'd purchased other fish from him in the past and he is one of those owners who asks all kinds of questions before selling you a fish, one of those ones that cares about the hobby not just $$$$. Everyone was doing great then a few nights ago i notice The tang, Flame Angel, and Royal Grammas seem to have "gone to bed" a little early, i didn't really worry about it, everyone still eating and active, then yesterday i notice the tang swimming pretty much strait on into the Vortech.. okay a little strange but the clowns play in the current to so whatever... then last night the 10000k lights go off and under the blues.... Tang is covered... and i mean Covered in white, some looks spottish like salt, some more like a... i cant even describe it... flossy? i dunno... needless to say... :angry: *also insert some colourful language* at myself for not doing things properly. As of this morning i can see spots on Tang, Flame and Royal Gramma... only 1 now the other died today, but didn't look white spottishy, im kinda wondering if it had a run in with Nem who has moved into the area it called home because was alive but swimming stiffly this morning then later was dead beside the Nem... Tang is still active, and everyone is still eating, clowns so far seem unaffected. So now i have Ich in my reef tank... TO THE INTERNET...... no such thing as reef safe treatment *more adult language* ... awesome..... so now i need to dismantle the tank to get the fish out... but next issue being... i have a 20g sitting here... but if i put all the fish in there they will probably stress themselves to death.. so now im looking around for a cheap or free tank i can use as a second hospital tank.. im thinking if i can find a 30 i can put just the tang in there or maybe tang and flame angel... so i have a HOB filter running in the sump and extra filter media floating as well hoping i can have colonized media for filters for Hospital tanks...

Today i considered hitting the tank with with a hammer a few times and just calling it fixed, but i think i would regret that almost immediately after doing it so decided not too..... really im just frustrated cause my tank isnt the amazing window to another world that i know it can be with a little work..

really i think i just needed to type all that out....
 
AAAARRRGGGG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


well, that was fast.

Overnight the Flame angel and other Royal Gramma passed and the Tang is MIA.... MIA meaning i have yet to see it alive or otherwise today, flashlight (torch if you prefer) searched the tank to no avail, if i haven't seen him by this afternoon i will have to start dismantaling the rock work to find him i guess, but to be honest at this point i am assuming the worst. Also.. how long is it going to take for that filter media to get populated hanging out in my sump? if im going to dismantle rock work in search of Neil id like to move the clowns to a treatment tank rather than needing to dig them out of the rock work at a later date.. the plan is to do a water change on the display, use the water i've removed from the display to start the hospital tank, that way water params match.. then im not sure on water change schedule in the QT during treatment but plan to have lots of pre-mixed water on hand for duration of treatment... Now am i correct in thinking that while i treat the surviving fish i should still be okay to add CUC to the tank (give me a chance to sort out the snail issue) as well as continue to build the reef with corals and such? From what i've read the Ich doesn't affect them at all so while i am waiting out the death of ICH in the tank ( most reading suggests 6weeks? ) was hoping to get the "reef" look going.

anyway... not a happy exciting update, but an update nonetheless.
 
:( I'm sorry to hear about all this, Trev. Water changes while medicating generally depends on levels being built up by the fish as well as the medication. I believe most ich medications suggest 25% daily water changes.

Ich does not affect inverts, so yes, you are free to add them to the main tank. I hope things brighten up..
 
Sorry mate :( I've had both your problems and know how stressful it can be. My tank came down with ich after adding a new fish as well. I did something a little crazy though and against widespread advice, I added a medication to the tank that I couldn't regulate ie Herbtana. I just couldnt stand to think of having to move all my rock and coral and fish etc etc the stress of it all. Luckily after two consecutive treatments with herbtana everything survived and pulled through, maybe an option for you if ever you end up with Ich again (though I know most people do not agree with it, it did work for me and all my corals were absolutely fine).

I also had the 'nem moving' issue, very very stressful. I kept thinking i'd wake up with it in a powerhead. Hang in there, BTAs will settle once they find a nice spot with good light/flow etc and the parameters are good. They are more prone than other anemones to wander about though.

Hope it all works out!
 
Well so far has been a crazy busy day, i am in the process of setting up QT and moving the clowns, i think i found the tang... will need to move rocks to get to it, but at least now i know where it is.. hopefully the clowns arent to difficult to corner... i may take this opportunity to re-scape will see how things go... the nem seems to have settled but in an obsurdly odd place but if it chooses to stay there, i will let it be.. rather have it happy in not my first choice of spot than forever wandering the tank.

Just glad i have the day off.....
 
Whew!

that was a lot of work. But the clowns are now housed in a 20g tank in the basement. They don't appear to be suffering from Ich, but will keep a close eye on them. I only had to dismantle half of the live rock to get them out of the display so that was a bonus, resulted in a little re-scaping and adjustment of power heads, so i fully expect the Nem to keep moving... but hopefully it settles soon and then i can work on building a thriving healthy coral display while i wait for it to be safe to put the fish back in... but will keep the QT up and running to hopefully avoid a situation like this in the future.

Clowns in new home
100_2499.jpg


and kinda what the tank looks like now, you can definitely spot the pieces of rock that have been rotated so a different side of them is exposed to light. Ha haha
100_2491.jpg
 
To the Optimists out there: At least i don't have to remember to go downstairs and feed the clowns.

To the Pessimists out there: They're Dead..... They're All Dead.

To my fellow fish-keepers: CENSORED
 
Snails....*insert non family friendly language here* Snails..... I have had nothing but problems with snails... i have some nasaurius ( sp? ) that are around still although from what i read they don't eat a whole lot of algae but any time i add any variety of Turbo snail they just stay where i put them till i decide they must be dead (usually 3 - 4days) or less if its obvious as in shrimp turn them over and start picking... so without snails in the tank i have had CUC issues and wow is it starting to show, i have hermits and some emerald crabs and a few shrimp.. but its a 90G tank...... And to make matters worse i was at 6 LFS's last weekend and the only snails any of them have are turbo's and i would rather try something different before going back to turbos cause seriously... Ive tried different acclimation processes and practices to no avail, biggest confusion here is that other inverts and corals seem to be doing just fine GRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

Something's not right here. Healthy Turbo species do NOT do this so quickly after being introduced. They should be cruising right out of the bag open up while you're holding them underwater and start wiggling around. If these are true Turbo species then you need to either worry about some kind of chemical poisoning or very bad treatment at the stores. Are they active in the stores? If you see them just kind of sitting around or even worse sitting in clumps at the bottom, pass and look elsewhere since those are stressed and probably on their way out already. If they're acting healthy as I've described at the stores and only turn ill when you bring them back, there are a few things other than acclimation to check:
- Make sure they're not being ripped off the sides of the tank roughly, as this can injur them.
- Run carbon if you aren't already
- Make sure they're actually in the Turbo genus and not a relative like Astrea, Margarites, or Cittarium. While all of those can do fine in certain setups, they are often much less hardy than true Turbo species in the average aquarium.
 
sorry to hear about your tank :(

and for future advice, tangs are always supposed to be put through QT because they catch ich almost instantly


hopefully things perk up soon, i too had a snail survival problems as well but that was due to some very hungry hermits.
 
sorry to hear about your tank :(

and for future advice, tangs are always supposed to be put through QT because they catch ich almost instantly


hopefully things perk up soon, i too had a snail survival problems as well but that was due to some very hungry hermits.

Every fish is going through QT from now on...well.. you know, as in get another pair of clowns in 4 weeks, qt for 2 weeks, leaving display fishless for 6 weeks, should allow things to run course.. and then after that every new fish will spend at least 2 weeks in qt. Probably picking up a carbon reactor tomorrow, cause cant hurt to run it.. have read about people running both phosban and carbon in a single reactor.... that would be handy but would need to do a little more reading before trying that i think...
 
Try checking if there are any traces of copper in your display. It is toxic to inverts(some moreso than others ).

Sorry to hear about all of the rotten luck. It'll get better before ya know it! Keep us posted.
 
i would personally recomend QT for a month just to be sure.
 
Well, holy crap where have i been??????

Ok so this is going to just be a quick note here that im back around a little more now and didn't actually throw in the towel on the salty tank. The tank was a disaster for a while there with algae, and for whatever reason i can not keep snails alive so i am done buying them, i may try again a few months down the road but for now... its algae scraper and a razor blade to keep my glass clean.

I started dosing my tank with Buffered vitamin c and it was amazing the job it did on the tank, the corals are looking good, and the anemone is doing great. I just got back to fish :yahoo: , added 2 clowns the other day who are currently trying to host the Torch Coral rather than the Anemone :huh: but will see what happens in time.

Im going to try and get some decent shots of the tank today and get them posted, but wanted to let people know that i didn't just disappear, of course the people in the chat room already know that :p
 

Most reactions

Back
Top