🌟 Exclusive Amazon Black Friday Deals 2024 🌟

Don’t miss out on the best deals of the season! Shop now 🎁

Guppy and Betta combo will it work?

Andrew#33

New Member
Joined
May 22, 2021
Messages
13
Reaction score
0
Location
Queen Creek, AZ
Hi everyone!
I have a question regarding Guppies and a betta can they be put together??
I have a 5 gallon tank that I put today four male guppies. I also purchased a female betta for the neighbor. But I found out she already replaced her Betta. I didn't wanna take back the female betta to the store . I quickly started to research if it was possible to put the female in with 4 male guppies. I did end up putting her in the tank so far it seems like it might work. I've seen her chase a couple. But she seems less aggressive. She is a Ventail.
Please help did I make a mistake??
Thank you!
Andy
 
Hi everyone!
I have a question regarding Guppies and a betta can they be put together??
I have a 5 gallon tank that I put today four male guppies. I also purchased a female betta for the neighbor. But I found out she already replaced her Betta. I didn't wanna take back the female betta to the store . I quickly started to research if it was possible to put the female in with 4 male guppies. I did end up putting her in the tank so far it seems like it might work. I've seen her chase a couple. But she seems less aggressive. She is a Ventail.
Please help did I make a mistake??
Thank you!
Andy
Unfortuntely not a good combination😔

Quite a few issues here...firstly both species require different water parametres. Guppies are hardwater fish and betta's need softer water so depending on your water hardness one specie will suffer long term.

Secondly a 5 gallon tank is sadly too small to house any of these species. (Some fishkeepers keep a single betta in a 5g however a 10g is better preferred across the hobby)

You will probably find out quickly with them both occupying the same level in the tank the Betta will start becoming stressed and attack the guppies.

Sorry to sound negative about your set up, its just sadly got the odds against it 😔
 
Unfortuntely not a good combination😔

Quite a few issues here...firstly both species require different water parametres. Guppies are hardwater fish and betta's need softer water so depending on your water hardness one specie will suffer long term.

Secondly a 5 gallon tank is sadly too small to house any of these species. (Some fishkeepers keep a single betta in a 5g however a 10g is better preferred across the hobby)

You will probably find out quickly with them both occupying the same level in the tank the Betta will start becoming stressed and attack the guppies.

Sorry to sound negative about your set up, its just sadly got the odds against it 😔

Wow I thought they had similar Parameters that's why it was suggested suggested that they could be tank mates. Makes sense anout the 10 gallon definitely more room.
Was thinking I do have a 3gal that I could use for the betta but I know 5 gal is the minimum for them.
Trying to figure out what I should do
Thank you
 
Last edited:
Here they are in the tank
 

Attachments

  • 20221029_152512.jpg
    20221029_152512.jpg
    172.9 KB · Views: 39
  • 20221029_152503.jpg
    20221029_152503.jpg
    294.1 KB · Views: 37
Wow I thought they had similar Parameters that's why it was suggested suggested that they could be tank mates. Makes sense anout the 10 gallon definitely more room.
Was thinking I do have a 3gal that I could use for the betta but I know 5 gal is the minimum for them. I follow KG tropicals they suggested they could be together in a 5 gal :(
Trying to figure out what I should do
Id suggest firstly trying to figure your water hardness out. You could take a sample of your water to your LFS or look it up on your local waterboards website.

From your water hardness you could then keep the fish better suited to your water. Sadly that would mean rehoming or taking the Betta/guppies back to store but this will be better for you and the fish longer term.

If you could then at some point upgrade to a bigger tank (i.e10g+) you will have more options depending on what you keep.

If you have soft water, you could always keep your 5g for shrimp then🙂
 
Here they are in the tank

Just from the photos, it already looks as though the betta is establishing the whole tank as her territory, and the guppies are afraid and trying to hide away by huddling in the top corner. You've already seen her chasing some, and that's a threat. She's trying to chase them out of her territory, but there's no where for them to escape to. You're very likely to wake up one morning and find dead guppies. They don't stand a chance if she decides to attack them.

Lots of places online will say it's okay to keep bettas with various other fish, but anyone can write a blog or internet article, or make youtube videos giving bad advice. It's tough to sift through the bad advice and find out what really works for the fish, and avoid the tendency to only want tiny tanks. Remember that the fish have no choice about what enclosure we trap them in, or what fish we trap them with... they'll do their best to survive whatever it is, but it doesn't mean that they're "happy" or thriving. Bigger tanks are also easier to maintain, since more water means it dilutes fish waste more than a small tank. Small tanks need more maintenance and experience to have them work long term.

Bettas are a solitary, territorial fish. They don't like other fish in their territory. Females don't tend to be as aggressive as males, but they're also solitary and very capable of killing other fish, especially fish that look a bit like another betta. The worst thing to put with a betta, is another betta. The second worst things are gourami and guppies. Those flashy tails and busy activity especially seem to trigger a bettas "drive it away" instinct, and the guppies are well aware that a bigger, more aggressive and potential threat is in the tank with them.

I agree with @AquaBarb , Bettas are a soft water fish, guppies need harder water. Find out the hardness of the water where you are, so you can choose which fish would work better for you in the long run. :) @Essjay is brilliant at helping people find out their water hardness! If it turns out to be on the softer side, I'd return the guppies and keep the betta, so long as you're content to keep her as an only fish. If the water is harder, and you want more of a community tank (do you want to get more fish for the tank at any point?) then i'd return the betta and upgrade the tank size for the guppies, and decide what other fish you'd like to have, and what size tank they would need, whether they could live with guppies etc.
If you have soft water, you could always keep your 5g for shrimp then🙂

Soft water is needed for caridina shrimp, but you can have amanos and neocaridina (cherry shrimp and their colour variations) in harder water! :)
 

Most reactions

Back
Top