First Half-moon bettas

The February FOTM Contest Poll is open!
FishForums.net Fish of the Month
🏆 Click to vote! 🏆

lljdma06

Retired moderator :)
Retired Moderator ⚒️
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Messages
11,767
Reaction score
17
Location
Miami, FL
Hello everyone,

I am new to this forum and have already posted my introductions in the newbie, though newbie I am most certainly not. I have been keeping tanks for over 15 years already, has it been that long? But questions still come up, and though I've kept bettas, I've usually kept them alone.

As some of you may know, I have a 15-gallon high in my apartment that's been running for about 2yrs. The last major catastrophe involved my best friends toddlers dumping an entire container of fish food into the tank :sick: , killing my school of neon tetras, and really making me mad. She never compensated me for the fish, nor the labor. Some people just don't think that fish are important and that their lives are not worth much. Try telling that to the millions who pull their hair out to make the best conditions for their little babies! :angry: There were 15 of them and they made a lovely school.

Well, I cleaned up the tank, it took a few weeks to get the water where it was before the mishap, but it's alright. So, I set up a partition dividing the tank in half, the partition allows water to circulation, but no fish. Now, the tank is home to two blue half-moon bettas, Fassolt and Fafner, extra points to whoever can guess where these names are from :) . I'm very pleased with them and they are thriving, but I guess anybody would be thriving if you go from living in a little tiny box in a tank, to a spacious 7.5 gallon home with plants and his own little cave, and the mental stimulation of another betta.

But I digress, what I really want to know, finally she's getting to her question. I would like to put a few fish in there with them. I would rather keep the tank understocked, if possible, so the less, but more showy, the better. I'm too traumatized to consider neons again, after scooping 15 carcasses, you would be too. I had heard that some livebearers, especially swords and platies do alright with bettas, so does anyone object to perhaps a trio on each side? That would make about 8 fish total, so it is a very workable number for a 15-gallon, in my opinion. That would allow just the right amount of color and a good size, without getting too large. My experience and inclination are towards platies, however, since swords, the ones I've kept at least, were rather agressive.

Any opinions. Love to hear from you guys.
Sorry for the length, I'm getting my doctorate in music and everything I write tends to turn into a dissertation. :D
 
Welcome! We want pics of F & F! :whistle:
I kept 2 platies in a 10 gallon with my first betta and I never had any problems, but it usually depends on the temperament of the betta. Some don't mind the company, others want to be 'King of their Castle.' So you could give it a try but be prepared to rehome the platies if something goes wrong. Also with having 6 platies be prepared for some babies that might get eaten by your bettas. Let us know how it works!!
 
Thanks for the input, I've also read a lot of sources that said it was a bad idea, so I think I'm going to wait a little bit and see what the pet store has tomorrow. The tank can have a few more fish, but I'd rather wait.

:D
 
Siamese Fighter05 said:
id go with a shoal of about 5 cories, but thats me i love the lil things! :wub: o btw you keep the two males together without a divider?
[snapback]872956[/snapback]​


Goodness no! There is a partition dividing the tank in half! I wouldn't do that at all! There have been enough posts regarding that subject in this forum. ;) Read the thread entitled "My community betta tank", and you'll read a delightful saga. :crazy:

I love cories two, they are a fun fish, and I may consider them, but only if I can find a species that is very small, as space in my tank is rather limited for a shoal like that, because of the partition. I've had as many as 8 together in a past larger aquarium though, and they were a great contrast to the the livebearers that shared the tank with them.

Thanks for the response, though. It's nice to get fresh opinions.

:D
 
well mhm...albino corys always look good an they are some of the more active corys. if you dont want them you could get a few otos. they(or mine at least) are VERY active. one attached itself to another today an the other tried swimming with his friend on his back for a sec :p for kinda of substrate do you have? if you have some nice soft sand i would recomend about 3 khuli loaches on each side. they are very neet looking an will make your tank look more exautic:p an they slither on the ground like a snake(not recomending you put them on the ground an see for your self) of maybe a few cloud minnows on each side...right now i have a 10gal for my betta an there are 2 corys an 2otos an about 10 oto fry that my betta is ACTUALLY TAKING CARE OF :wub: an all is good.

sry for a long post but i had much to say :p
 
Lol i read the betta community post and added my reply a few days ago, i was just checking to make sure lol :*) after seeing those pictures i really dont think there is anything that can surprise me in the fishkeeping world now. There are the dwarf cories (Pgymy??) and another variety but theyre never available around here :(
 
I hear ya, that entire thread drove me nuts! :crazy: I can't stop thinking about how callous people can be about the wellfare of animals. So I don't blame anybody jumping the gun and thinking that my bettas weren't divided. I was ambiguous with that post, but I posted it before that famous thread and I just assumed that keeping two males in the same tank would carry the given assumption that it was divided. We all know what the first three letters of assume spell, so I'll take the blame on that one. My goof. :p

Unfortunately, my substrate is regular gravel, so unless there's a new, industrial spieces of kuli, they're not going to happen in my tank, though, I think they're absolutely adorable. :rolleyes:

I love corys and ottos and when I look at fish tomorrow or Friday, I'll look into those species. I have a little algae, so perhaps a few ottos wouldn't be a bad idea. Gotta remember only a few at a time, though, I hate overstocking, and Fassolt and Fafner are doing so well. They have rival bubble nests now. I might invest in some floating plants, that would be rather nice, and the gentlemen will have a better spot to anchor their nests than the tank partition, and maybe I'll nip that little algae problem in the bud. :shifty:

As far as white clouds are concerned, my tank is on the warm side, so I don't think they'd be happy in the long run.

The suggestions I've heard so far have been great and I look forward to getting more opinions. I'll let you know what I find if I go to the good pet store (they do exist!) tomorrow. And long posts are awesome; means you took the time to write! This is coming from a future dissertation writer, so all my posts are like little dissertations. Sorry about that!

Hopefully, I'll get my camera phone on Wednesday and hopefully by Thursday you guys will get a few pictures of my setup, which is no too bad on a student's limited budget.

:lol: :D
 
Siamese Fighter05 said:
There are the dwarf cories (Pgymy??) and another variety
[snapback]873100[/snapback]​

:nod: They're completely adorable, too- Corydoras Pygmaeus, Habrosus and Hastatus are all considered 'dwarf' cories, and they're just too cute :wub: As you said, though, very hard to come by in some places; you may find it necessary to order them online :(


lljdma06 said:
Unfortunately, my substrate is regular gravel, so unless there's a new, industrial spieces of kuli, they're not going to happen in my tank, though, I think they're absolutely adorable.  :rolleyes:
[snapback]874077[/snapback]​

:lol: I just got this mental picture of what a new, industrial species of khuli might look like . . . little hard hat, pickaxe . . . *dies*

ETA:
loachmin.jpg


Yes . . . I am bored, and I am taking cold medication :*)
 
That pics great :) Its a shame you've got gravel, its a wonder how something long, thin and wriggly can be so cute :) I'd be slightly wary of putting other fish with them, after being alone bettas tend not to like other fish a lot. Although you'd probably be relatively OK with bottomdwellers as long as you provide plenty of cover (near the glass so you ca see them).
 
OohFeeshy said:
That pics great :) Its a shame you've got gravel, its a wonder how something long, thin and wriggly can be so cute :) I'd be slightly wary of putting other fish with them, after being alone bettas tend not to like other fish a lot. Although you'd probably be relatively OK with bottomdwellers as long as you provide plenty of cover (near the glass so you ca see them).
[snapback]874821[/snapback]​

That picture was awesome, so funny :rofl:. Now imagine if Kuli's were proportionately that big. They'd be like 4 feet long. That would be scary. :hyper:

Well, as promised I went to the good LFS that I live near and scoped out the merchandise. So nice not to see dead fish, they have the best selection of cyprinids, very unusual types. No floating plants, but I did come home with two nice bunches of lace java ferns.

Also, went home with 3 harlequin rasboras for Fafner's side. They are schooling nicely now, and Fafner's ignoring them. Boy, did I end up with the most mellow half-moons or what? I like the harlequins, haven't had them in over ten years, but I have good memories. When the Bridget rasboras reach their time, I'll put three harlequins on Fassolt's side. But before, since the little guys are still going strong, I think I'll add, drum roll please, two little pygmy cories on each side. :lol: But that won't be for a while yet, maybe in 2-3 weeks, they have several varieties in that LFS. I'd rather buy a few more Java ferns, I forgot how much I like plants, and this LFS is known for their plants. When all is said and done, it will be a very boring tank, but almost completely symmetrical. Wierd.

Fassolt's bubble nest is huge! He's been workin overtime. He definitely beat Fafner. He might need to borrow the kuli's hard hat later, if he continues this construction frenzy.

Only one more day until I get my camera!!!! Can't wait, and everybody gets to see my lovely's. I'll get the camera Wednesday, but have to charge it, learn how to use it, and all that nonsense. :/

Take care everyone, and I hope you feel better Andie, but you're very "constructive" for a sick person. :rolleyes:
 
lol I came into work because I had to, but that doesn't mean I have to work like I'm supposed to :rolleyes:

Oooh, you mentioning the rasboras got me all jealous. I saw some Harlequins the other day and almost brought home six myself- I love the little darts of colour, and if I thought I could trust my four shrews at all then I'd give them some Harlequins for company, but as things stand now I can't even house them together, so nothing doing :lol:

I'm actually jealous you got such laid-back boys- I haven't had anybody so mellow since Fysh died a year ago!
 
Andie said:
I'm actually jealous you got such laid-back boys- I haven't had anybody so mellow since Fysh died a year ago!
[snapback]874884[/snapback]​


Yeah, I just think they notice eachother. They're trying to see who's prettier. Though they're not half as pretty as some of the bettas I've seen on this board. I'm pleased, the tank still looks good, nobody's been eaten yet, and the Rasboras are doing great. Also, I got my camera phone today!!!!

:hyper: :lol:

So maybe by tomorrow, I'll have pics of my set up!
 
PS: I still haven't heard from anyone who can tell me where Fassolt and Fafner's names are from. I know, but does anyone else? :shifty:
 
I love the hardhat on the kuhli! For some reason, I can't view the photos on this site at work so I had to wait until I got home to see them.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top