End of Fishless Cycling Question

SnowLady

New Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2003
Messages
54
Reaction score
0
Location
Columbus, Ohio
OK - Friday's test showed ZERO Nitrites and Ammonia. Saturday's test showed the same.

Saturday I did a 60 - 70 % water change.

This morning I get up and see a 5.0 Nitrite reading. Add the amount of Ammonia I'd been using after the Nitrite spike, waited an hour and the reading is now 2.0 ppm Ammonia and 2.0 ppm Nitrite.

Now what?
 
I don't really know why that would happen but now you'll have to wait a few more days. I'd keep adding the ammonia daily until the nitrite reads 0 again. When my tanks finished cycling I did an 80% water change to make sure the nitrates were low. I'd also suggest that you test your tap water for nitrite. I've never heard of tap water having nitrite in it but you never know. I know there are some places that have high nitrate in their tap water. I'd just check it to rule that out as the problem. Good luck and keep us posted.
 
yeah i second what moe says, get ur tap water tested for high nitrate.... dont let ur fishes fall victim to ur water company!!!

like i did :(
 
okies, soz didn't mean to point out the obvious but it has been known :p Give it time, my readings were all over the place to start with but they do work out and the tanks running like a dream now
 
Ahhhh this is not a hobby for the impatient is it?! lol

Monday's readings were 2.0 Nitrites and 2.0 Ammonia

I also got rid of two of my plants that were riddled with snail eggs. :( At last count I've got three. Three too many!
 
I don't know how you stand it -- the waiting :)

I did my aquarium all wrong -- ran it empty but for gravel for 3 days, then bought some cichlids for it -- then found this web site.

Should have started with the web site, as then I would have at least attempted a fishless cycle. But it's been a week and they haven't died yet!

I have seen a couple of your posts about weird bumps in ammonia levels, and they seem to all come after a water change. I have had some organic chemistry in the past, so I can guess as to what is happening.

You tested your tap water for ammonia -- negative. You are also dechlorinating the water before you add it. If your water has chloramine in it, this may be the ammonia source. Chloramine has nitrogen in it (the amine group), but I suspect is stably bound up, so it doesn't react as ammonia (NH4) when you test the tap water. However, I believe there is a good chance when you treat the water for chlorine/chloramine, you are releasing some of the nitrogenous compound, which then either makes ammonia or is in another form that cross reacts with your test.

The way to tell this is to take your tap water as if you were going to add it to your aquarium (in a bucket or whatever you use), add the dechlorination stuff, mix it well, wait a bit, then test THAT water for ammonia and see what you get.

I bet you may be able to safely add fishies, but don't sue me if I am wrong.

Whew. Long post.
 
aschueler - I did what you suggested and got my bucket of water, added the approriate chemicals that I would if it were going in my tank, let it sit out over night and tested:

0.00 Ammonia and 0.00 Nitrites

So...
 
so there goes my bright idea.

Damn.

I was feeling pretty smart there.

Kinda reminds me of a Simpson's episode, where Grandpa Simpon's buddy got his beard stuck in a pencil sharpener, and to get it out Grandpa Simpson kept turning the crank..getting it more stuck...kept saying "let me try..." then another wind. Then he ran off yelling "you're on your own". I only had one idea too!
 

Most reactions

Back
Top