[Emergency] Small PH swing, fish possibly dead or dying??

Rocky998

Kinda crazy, but somehow they let me stay
Tank of the Month 🏆
Joined
Jun 25, 2021
Messages
13,907
Reaction score
12,147
Location
NC, U.S.A
My PH is normally 8.1. My peacock gudgeons have always been happy in this water and have even had successful fry.
With my KH also being high, I decided that maybe I could add in tannins to help with something bacterial happening to my corydoras without altering the PH.
After about 2-3 hours of doing the water change I decided out of pure curiosity to test the PH and it came back as being around 7.9 being my best estimate.
Then I check on my fish now and my peacock gudgeon (the one I literally raised from birth), went from looking a bit lethargic to looking like she wasn't even breathing...
I'm gonna wait until morning, but a shift of like 0.2 shouldn't cause a DEATH, right!?

I'm emotionally attached to her! I raised her! I'd be so sad if she passed!!
 
Not enough to cause anything. Especially over time.
 
My PH is normally 8.1. My peacock gudgeons have always been happy in this water and have even had successful fry.
With my KH also being high, I decided that maybe I could add in tannins to help with something bacterial happening to my corydoras without altering the PH.
After about 2-3 hours of doing the water change I decided out of pure curiosity to test the PH and it came back as being around 7.9 being my best estimate.
Then I check on my fish now and my peacock gudgeon (the one I literally raised from birth), went from looking a bit lethargic to looking like she wasn't even breathing...
I'm gonna wait until morning, but a shift of like 0.2 shouldn't cause a DEATH, right!?

I'm emotionally attached to her! I raised her! I'd be so sad if she passed!!
I suspect that you inadvertently introduced something into the tank with the tannins. The small change in pH is not the problem.
 
Not enough to cause anything. Especially over time.
Yeah... well I boiled the leaves to instantly get tannins, let the water cool, and then slowly added it to the tank along with the leaves...

Only 2 leaves were not boiled and just weighed down with a rock. Although I did rinse them under tap water.
I suspect that you inadvertently introduced something into the tank with the tannins. The small change in pH is not the problem.
That would absolutely suck... but it's weird. Everyone else is A ok (all things considered)... but of course my fish that I raised from birth gets hit with whatever is happening.

Don't know what they could've gotten from it after I boiled most of the leaves (besides two which I rinsed under tap)
How is your peacock doing ?
Well looks like she moved to a spot that wasn't too far away, but she looks exactly the same as last night... No visible breathing, but she hasn't rotted and the corydoras would've eaten her partially if she was dead.
Although now saying that, I see something below her stomach I can't see much. I might try to get something long to shift her position as gently as possible to see it
.2 Ph is not going to cause death. Assess what other changes have been made.
Literally nothing. I did the water change, put the amount of salt in to replace the salt taken out by the water change.
Only new thing is the Indian almond leaves
 
Did you add dechlorinator, since you said you rinsed a couple leaves with tap water?
 
Did you add dechlorinator, since you said you rinsed a couple leaves with tap water?
I added the leaves right before putting water back in and I put dechlorinator in with the new water. So it shouldn't have been much of an issue.
There was only a thin layer of water left on the leaf.
She only seemed different after adding the water that had the tannins.
 
@Colin_T @GaryE @WhistlingBadger @connorlindeman @CassCats
She switched positions twice. And once too far away to just be moved by current or another fish.
If you zoom in under her stomach, you'll see something protruding from her anal region. I think those are parasitic worms... if so she's shown no signs until now
20250114_143454.jpg
 
I turned her a bit and it look like she literally got mauled!? What the HECK!?
20250114_150649.jpg
 
Arched back also can be triggered by chronic/severe internal parasites. Given there is a prolapse in result of the worms here, you are unlikely to save this fish and she will need to be humanely euthanized. But the rest of the tank must be treated because if one fish has worms, they have all be exposed.

Whole tank needs a dose of dewormer. Flubendazole can be dosed to the water, but fenbendozole or levamisole need to be dosed to food as it is not water soluble. Treat every 2-3 weeks, monitor after the 2nd dose to see if you need to repeat.

I highly doubt the minuscule amount of tap water on a leaf would cause chlorine poisoning.
Many of us add tap water to our frozen fish foods without any negative effects.
Prior to the photos, that was the only thing to go off of being out of norm, some sensitive fish could react poorly but that's definitely not the case here now seeing the photos.
 
@CassCats
Nope, not worms.
Took the body out and dug around
[Warning, graphic fish death photos]
20250114_151908.jpg
20250114_152032.jpg
20250114_151915.jpg

Second photo looks like eggs, right?
 

Most reactions

Back
Top