different water conditioners are unlikely to be the cause. Most water conditioners only contain sodium thiosulphate and maybe a dye.
I would keep a close eye on the other fishes in the tank, especially any other guppies. If any of them even look like they are getting clamped fins then medicate the tank with a broad spectrum antibiotic. It will probably wipe out your filter bacteria as well so if you have to treat them cut the feeding back and monitor the water quality for several weeks after treatment.
If none of them show any signs and everyone seems healthy, then maybe try adding a few fish in a months time.