[/quote]
There is a problem when you are REPEATEDLY told NO, it not a good idea. You've been told many times that it isn't a good idea. And that your tank is inadequate for 8 rbp's and likely underfiltered for even a correct amount of rbps.
People doubt you've done your research because of the countless threads you start asking questions that have been answered time and time again. I personally doubt you've done much research if you are still asking questions like you are asking. Or maybe (probably?) you do research and completely ignore what everyone says. Your second to last post epitomizes this. You've been told no by me along with other members yet you still say, I'm gonna go do this against all advice I've received. If you are going to do it regardless of what people say, why even ask?
As people have said before, we are tired of being led in circles. You've repeatedly asked questions that would be answered by a simple search, been given the same advice over and over again, and yet still ask questions that result in the same advice given to you again. Then you go and say, well I'm just going to ignore everything everyone is telling me and go do it. Listen to people when they tell you something or don't ask the question. And don't come crying in 6 months when everything has gone wrong while people told you all along, DON'T DO IT.
EDIT: I'm not saying don't ask questions that may seem stupid, I'm saying don't ask the same question over and over again, get the same advice over and over again, yet still just decide to do it anyways.
[/quote]
ok well first i have a penguin 350B and also the 100B
and second i do do research and it says that there are no fish that will live with reds, but it says the same for oscars and i have an oscar with 3 other fish and they get along. so i figure well maybe some people were able to keep something with their reds, so i posted these. and as i think of another possible fish to live with my reds i post a thread to see about it...
what makes u all think im not taking ur advice
i havent put anything in with my reds? so clearly i have taken ur comments into thought.....just because i keep asking about a fish that can live with reds doesnt mean i havent used your advice, i just really want to find one that could work, so i keep searching.....
yes i could search web for answers to this but, it would be just a general, scientific fact that says nothing can live with reds; but once again like my oscar, it is said that nothing can live with them, but it is possible that something can......
with the oscar......ya i got it from a friend that couldnt keep it anymore, and when it comes to captivity it is really the same? sure 75gal. is bigger and better than 40gal. but its not like any fish is living a great free life.......