Can I Add An Angelfish?

Hollymolly4

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Dec 28, 2007
Messages
175
Reaction score
0
Location
USA
I have a 55gallon tank that will house Mollies and Polkatdot loaches. I'd love to add an Angelfish to the mix if it will work. If so, what kinds would do best? Can I keep just one or do I need a pair?
Thanks! :good:

BTW...There will be 6 Mollies and 4 Loaches.
 
yes it is feasible. with the mollies and loaches you could still add around 5-6 angels. the variants of the angels you want would depend very much on your own personal preference. i go for stripped variants with normal fin types while others may opt for koi angels with longer fin variants.
 
Mollies need salt, Link. I wouldn't be the loaches and angelfish in a brackish tank for any length of time, they may do fine with the salt for a while but long term I wouldn't think it would be great for them.
 
Right now I'm only using conditioning salt. I do believe in salt for mollies but I've also read that they can thrive without salt as long as the water is very good and well kept up with, which is how my tanks are. I have a few weeks left before I can get an Angel so I will do lots of research first. I want them all to be happy!
Thanks for the reply.
 
Pretty much. You don't have to have salt in the water if you don't want too. As long as the water like you said is clean. For the angel situation you can mix them with those guys since all of them as community. Beware angels grow and remember they are ciclids, they hunt small fish like neons and guppies when they are around the size of your dinner plate xD!
 
Will it outgrow a 55gallon? I have no plans to upgrade while I'm living in this house.
Thanks for the reply!
 
I have yet to see an angel that would outgrow a 55 gallon tank.
 
They might, but most likely no. Besides it will take years before they reach their full potential.
 
The only reason why people started to add salt to tanks containing Mollies is that it reduces the toxicity of nitrate and nitrite and Mollies are highly sensitive to these two compounds. Mollies can live quite happily in freshwater, and in the wild the majority of them do just that.
 
The only reason why people started to add salt to tanks containing Mollies is that it reduces the toxicity of nitrate and nitrite and Mollies are highly sensitive to these two compounds. Mollies can live quite happily in freshwater, and in the wild the majority of them do just that.

But that's not the "only reason". From the link I provided earlier in this thread-

The Background

The mollies you are most likely to buy at the pet store are hybrids. Black mollies, golden mollies, veiltail mollies, balloon mollies, and all the others are all hybrids created by careful cross-breeding of two or more species. Some molly species live in fresh water, while others live in brackish water. There's usually a little of both kind in any given aquarium strain.

The Problem

When mollies are kept in freshwater tanks, they often become sickly. Common symptoms are fin-rot, fungus, and the "shimmies". Fin-rot is a gradual decay of the fins, often with obviously dead, grey patches on the fins. Left untreated, this will kill your fish. Fungus usually looks like fine white threads and can appear anywhere on the body, though it's most common on the fins. Again, untreated, this is serious. Both fin-rot and fungus are easily treated with over-the-counter fish medicines. The shimmies are, as the name suggests, a bit like the dance of the same name. The fish seem to tread water, wobbling from side to side. Yet again, left untreated, this will kill your fish.

Yes, some people do have some success with mollies in fresh water, there are many factors which come in to play though. Personally I wouldn't keep them in fresh water, there is quite a high level of risk for disease due to inbreeding as it is. My LFS even keeps their mollies in brackish water to help stop disease.
 
April 15th 2006. Which may now be over a year again, but is not as old, compared to most fish books you will read.
 
April 15th 2006. Which may now be over a year again, but is not as old, compared to most fish books you will read.

Just wondered as a lot of the older literature, they recommend the benefits of old water, and as I am sure you aware old water will have a higher concentration of nitrates than fresh. Due to the sensitivity of Mollies to this compound and the fact that salt reduces its toxicity they found the addition of salt to be benifical. Adding salt to water can be used as a treatment for fungal and paracitical infections as they cant survive in a moderately saline environment. In a FW containing high nitrates the Mollies will become infected due to the fact that their systems are stressed by the nitrate, though in a tank with low nitrates the Mollies are no more likely to be infected than any other fish. Its not so much a case of the Mollies needing salt in the water more a case of the Mollies needing low nitrates in it.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top