Blue Lobster In My Mbuna Tank?

mark1980

New Member
Joined
Jun 22, 2007
Messages
50
Reaction score
0
Location
Alfreton, Derbyshire
I would like any opinions of whether this would be a good idea. I want one but i'm constantly being told they will each the fish. Just seen a video on youtube of an mbuna tank with several fish living in harmony with the lobster. I'm confused!
 
I would like any opinions of whether this would be a good idea. I want one but i'm constantly being told they will each the fish. Just seen a video on youtube of an mbuna tank with several fish living in harmony with the lobster. I'm confused!

I googled it, first response is here seems the subject has been done to death before. I know I wouldn't put one in, trying to feed it would be a nightmare I would be worried it wasn't getting enough protein and started midnight snacking on sleepy mbuna, or vice versa too much protein floating about the tank and a load of mbuna with bloat.
 
I've just been on you tube and searched blue lobster, try that search and the first half dozen hits are all films of blue lobster attacking fish, or each other and eating them.
There's your answer mate, what everybody keeps telling you obviously has sound evidence to support it.
 
Would an African Fan Shrimp (which can be colourful, not all are bland) be more appropriate, given they have no claws?
 
Would an African Fan Shrimp (which can be colourful, not all are bland) be more appropriate, given they have no claws?

Never seen them before but I found this, so if the original question of introducing them to an mbuna tank stands, then probably not, think my bigger ones would at very least pester it to death if not actually target it for elimination:-

Provide a tank of at least 20 gallons. The tank should be heavily planted and have many hiding places, because the African Fan Shrimp is very shy and likes to hide during the day. Do not house it with crustacean-eating fish such as large cichlids, puffers and loaches, because they will usually make short work of this shrimp.

Despite its extremely fearsome looks, the African Fan Shrimp is completely harmless to all its tankmates, even fish fry. They are peaceful among themselves and can be kept in groups as long as each one can have its own hiding place.

These shrimp are very hardy and can adapt to most kinds of water conditions, provided they are clean. It does best when the pH is about 6.5 to 7.5, although it can adapt to pH ranges beyond those as well. It prefers moderately hard water, but can do well in soft water aquariums.
Feeding: The African Fan Shrimp feeds using specialised fan-like appendages near its head to filter small food particles from the water. If kept in a well-established planted tank, there is usually enough suspended particulate matter to feed the shrimp. If, however, it does not appear to be getting enough to eat, a turkey baster may be used to squirt some zoo- and phytoplankton near the shrimp when it is in the feeding position. Because of the shrimp's nocturnal nature, this may need to be done with the tank lights out.
 
Fair enough, that's a no then, suspected as much! :D

Mark, how about some Red Claw (or similar) crab with an Atlantis underwater dome for their out of water needs?
http://www.crabhomes.com/
 
Not that bothered about a crab, I thought the blue lobster looked really nice in the mbuna tank on youtube but i'm not going to risk it. I like my fish to be as happy as possible and I don't think that sticking a lobster in with them would do that. Thanks for the opinions though.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top