Biggest Goldfish?

[kizno1]

Biffer no one it doubting that gold carp can grow that big what there saying is that the man and the fish are 2 separate pictures that have been edited together to make it look like hes holding the fish when hes not.

 

[the biffster]

so his he not holding
the fish in the photo i put up its
the same guy different fish
in that case why should they
edit then i am only saying its real

 

[goldies]

My biggest goldfish is true.

 

[goldies]

a golden carp? I prefer to believe that that is a photoshoped Goldfish rather than believing that it's a carp.

 

[hihi100202]

Yep, im going to go with this being FAKE

 

[the biffster]

well we will have to agree to disagree on this one its real
google the guys name
now can we have this thread closed please

 

[bae1994]

yes a golden carp a goldfish is a carp so yes its a gold carp however 100% fake

 

[bae1994]

yes a golden carp a goldfish is a carp so yes its a gold carp however 100% fake

 

[the biffster]

ask the gut himself he on face book along
with the photos

http/www.facebook.com/#!/profile.php?id=1602652403




can you please lock this thread

 

[Carlovel1]

It's so obvious that facebook pic has been photoshopped, I mean look at his arms!

 

[the biffster]

It's so obvious that facebook pic has been photoshopped, I mean look at his arms!

i am fed up of this when will you learn that these fish carp grow
this big so if it wasn't a golden carp and just a common carp the same size. you
would say that ,that as been photo shopped as well ???

 

[curlyriff]

i am fed up of this when will you learn that these fish carp grow
this big so if it wasn't a golden carp and just a common carp the same size. you
would say that ,that as been photo shopped as well ???

You have missed the whole point of this topic. For a start he was asking about biggest goldfish. Although we have since concluded that is a carp it is not an actual goldfish not in the aquarium world. If you took it loosely as a gold fish then yes it is.

On the other note everyone is pointing out is that carp can well grow larger but the exact photo originally posted is edited to show different originals together at different scales to suit so that it looks larger than this exact fish was.

At this time you just seem to be trolling for comments. You haven't justified anything about the photo in question which is what the op asked about and you are just going on about the size of carp.

I think we have all established it's fake apart from maybe a few people. If someone can explain why what some of us have pointed out to show the photo is fake then please let us know but at the moment I am personally struggling to see how it can be real with so many anomalies in the picture to suggest otherwise.

Kind Regards,

Adam

 

[the biffster]

if i was trolling for comments would i be asking for it to be closed ??
doesn't make sense as for anomalies i cant see any and yes it is a carp not a gold fish
and carp grow up to 90lb so why cant this one it far from 90lb

 

[Curiosity101]

It's not that it cant be 90lbs... it's that too many factors in the photo point to it not being the size and weight it seemingly is based on first glance.

This is the point you are repeatedly missing biffster.

No one says it isn't the fish you say, what they are saying is that yes it COULD grow as big as it looks and as big as the person who is 'holding' the fish says it is. But that based on indicators on the picture... it ISN'T, but that's besides the point anyways. Because the fish is actually a completely different picture, it's a carp that has been superimposed onto that man so he is seemingly looking like he's holding a massive fish.

If I were getting this much attention and there were no way I could get into trouble with the police then I think I'd be say 'Oh yeah it's true it's true'

Oh... and it's not your thread. And no one is being abusive, so even though I can't see why you want it closing, it's unlikely any mod will close it without the request of the original poster.

 

[goldies]

Goodnight guys. I have no sleep with my sick fish.