Bettas in jars?!

Nuttygal! :0)

Fishaholic
Joined
Dec 22, 2004
Messages
594
Reaction score
0
Location
There! ;0)
Does anyone keep bettas in jars? Is it cruel? Just wondering coz I know alot my LFS keep bettas in huge tanks with dividers so they have a tiny little bit each, but some have like 60litre tanks that just house 1 male betta and a cory cat or something.....
 
depends

If i would open up a store, i wouldn't imagine getting 2.5 gallon tanks for bettas. If course it would look nice, but bettas come and go every week. A store near me receives bettas 3 times a week and they always run out before the foloowing shipment so the bettas are kept in jars only a couple of days, which is understandable.

Like saying that the fish stores should set up tanks and stock them carefully, not overstock and provide hiding places for all their fish, and have suitable tanks for larger fish (like only keep 2 oscars in their own 100 gallon tank)


Now, if you go and buy a betta or any other fish to put him in a testraining home on purpose while you know it is wrong, then you should be shot, no trial, just straight to execution.
 
Personally I do not agree with keeping a betta in a cup, jar, or vase unless it can hold like 7-10g of water... and can be heated, and have a filter.

I keep my betta in a 10g now, and he loves it. I can understand why some lfs keep them in cups, but, if I had a shop I would still provide them plenty of room and the proper set up.. with plants and rocks etc.. so they would have a nice place to live. lol
 
Most stores and many breeders will keep bettas in tiny cups or jars. This is to fit as many bettas as possible in a small space as keeping them each in their own large tank would not be financially feasable for an industry trying to make money. Pet stores suffer massive death losses with bettas (in part due to too small of containers for the amount of waste they produce, I'm sure, not to mention the inadequate temperature), so if they bought even a gallon tank for each then lost half of them, they'd be losing huge amounts of money.

However, when you have your own betta, I wouldn't reccomend keeping it in a jar if you want it to live more than a few weeks. 1 gallon is considered the absolute minimum by most Americans who know something about the species, though with the tiny containers they sell in the stores, you should realize that few even get the priveledge of one gallon. I personally have found that bettas will live longer, healthier, and happier lives in larger tanks, 5 gallons being about minimum as this is the smallest tank size that is easy to keep heated, filtered, and "decorated" with plants and rocks for the fish's benefit. I consider 1 gallon and 2.5 gallons to be adequate when you first get the fish to slowly accustom it to larger tanks and filters, especially if the fish you get is sick (I happen to buy sick bettas soley for the purpose of rehabilitating them, and ones with fin rot and gill fungus can't handle big tanks and strong currents.). However, once the fish is healthy and strong enough for a mild filter and more space, I think that larger is better. My apartment only allows 5 gals, or mine would all be in 10's.

Now, you can technically keep bettas in cups, if this is what your asking, but consider the benfits of a good sized tank with a filter: Cleaner, freshed, better oxygenated water. Less concentrated contaminants. Weekly 25% water changes instead of daily 100% water changes. Room for a heater so you can keep the water temperature at the right level, and the temperature will remain more stable in larger amounts of water. While it may be more expensive than a cup, you're bettas will live longer so you'll buy fewer, and chances are they'll need less meds for ailments, less special foods for lagging apetites, etc. so in the long run it is better for you and the fish.

I hope this answered your questions ^^ I would read up on the betta forum, they have lots of great advice on betta care.
 
I think it would depend on the size of jar you are talking about.

I don't think you'd want to keep a betta in a cup or 2 of water, no. As there is really no way you could feasibly keep the water changed often enough.

Mine live in beanie boxes right now, and I know numerous people who keep theirs in the same size containers as well.

They are perky, and happy, and hungry, and healthy. They blow bubble nests daily and look forward to my company. I see no ill effects from keeping them in a smaller container persay.

Of course I want them to have larger, because I feel like they probably want something bigger. But who knows..they seem happy and content right now..getting fed 2-3 times a day, having their own plant, and having interaction time several tiems a day.
 
As long as the jar always have clean water and change every other day, I see no harm. Remember this picture? LOL :D
 

Attachments

  • post_31_1095877674.jpg
    post_31_1095877674.jpg
    14.4 KB · Views: 387
Ideally, a larger container is better, but there are other considerations (space, cost... etc). If the jar you put him in is bigger than the jar you got him from, I guess he is still better off. Better a jar than a small plastic cup.
 
I would say that bettas could live in jars but not in plastic cups or bottles, I would prefer space enough for a betta to swim at least around the jar and clean water. :)
 

Most reactions

Back
Top