Am I Nuts Or Is This A Good Idea?

LauraFrog

Fish Gatherer
Joined
Aug 25, 2007
Messages
2,372
Reaction score
0
Location
Queensland, Australia
Basically, I worked out how to make a set of plastic storage drawers (AU$25) house six bettas at a stretch or four comfortably.
There are two drawers inside a plastic case. This case keeps dust etc out, and heat and jumpy bettas in. Each drawer has three slots where dividers can be put. You can put a divider in the middle one or both the end ones, the first arrangement halving the drawer and the second cutting it in thirds. At a stretch you could keep six bettas in this thing, but I wouldn't do that unless I was totally desperate because that would make the divided sections too small. Each side holds about 2.5 gallons, so I wouldn't split it into three.
The dividers appear to me to be pretty tough. They have a split in them so there's a bit of give there, but I've whacked them with my fingers pretty hard and I don't think I can bust them. The container's roof stops bettas jumping the dividers. I'll give them a practical test later on - I'll put Valhalla in one side (that's where he's going to live) and Password in the other. Password can't stand to have another betta anywhere near him, he goes ballistic. If he can't knock it down, nothing can, so I'll test it out with him (standing there with a net of course!) Once there is gravel in it that will give the dividers even more stability. I reckon that with a decent light above it you could even grow some lowlight-tolerant plants (java moss, java fern, anubias nana) in it. I like it...

So... bettas can live without filters and in the tropics I don't need heaters really, but this could still be set up to take them or at the very least an airstone. It's only plastic - drill holes in it and poke the wiring through. The biggest problem is closing the drawers - you have to open them right out to feed the betta at the back and they are HEAVY - if you don't support the weight though, they just go flying. Then when you close them, the water sloshes everywhere if you aren't careful.

Anyway, what you all think? I think happy bettas!
 

Attachments

  • 1.JPG
    1.JPG
    18.7 KB · Views: 36
  • 2.JPG
    2.JPG
    17.4 KB · Views: 38
  • 3.JPG
    3.JPG
    25.4 KB · Views: 40
not something i would use, but i see the logic, lots of holes in the top will be needed for air circulation, tbh if i was a betta i wouldnt like to live in a set of drawers :lol:
 
lol!

I have to put bettas in things that aren't designed for fish though - if I can get it into the house without my parents realising it's for my fish, they never notice when I put fish in it! I do intend to drill some air holes in the lid though, and I might drop an airstone or two in there for entertainment. Depends which bettas I put in it really...
 
lol!

I have to put bettas in things that aren't designed for fish though - if I can get it into the house without my parents realising it's for my fish, they never notice when I put fish in it! I do intend to drill some air holes in the lid though, and I might drop an airstone or two in there for entertainment. Depends which bettas I put in it really...
:lol: so what happens when you parents decide to put away some clean washing? do you wake up with a betta wrapped in a pair of knickers in the tank, yup you are nuts but a good idea i suppose :lol: :lol:
 
Love the amount of thought and effort. However, this hap-hazard method is riddled with future problems. Keeping living creatures hidden in a drawer, only seeing daylight a feeding or when you fancy a peek seems unfair. The fish deserve to see you too! Why keep so many? Surley a gold fish bowl with one would quench your thirst until your parents trusted you with a larger tank to hold more favouably??
 
Well this time they know what I'm doing with it :hyper:

The drawers are see-through and are getting a lot of natural light, and they will be decorated and planted. I don't keep my fish hidden away in the dark. You're dead right, that's cruel. I already have five bettas (yep, I'm nuts) but I'm not planning on getting more. This might even just end up as a spawning arrangement (preconditioning) or a livebearer fry raiser. It occurred to me also I could use it as a breeding trap for livebearers by drilling some biggish holes in the divider. It's just there if something absolutely irresistible turns up. I can sort of see where my parents are coming from (six tanks counting this one) but I don't necessarily agree. Anyway, they know about this one.
 
I really like this idea. Its a great way it keep bettas comfortable. Whats up with all the new members thinking there friggen betta specialits. I had someone yell at me earler( a new member) saying they were going to call the aspca on me because i was keeping my bettas in tubbaware containers.

Anywho. Well its a good idea. The betta in the front would be able to see you perfectly
 
i dont like it i think its cruel how would you like to live in a 300 sqr. foot house your whole life huh? huh?!?! thats right !
 
I have used this type of drawers before, althought not for fish. I would just be careful of pulling the drawers in and out. Your right the drawers don't slide very easily, plus with water in them they would become heavy. Anyway it seems like a great idea. Worth a try!!!
 
Zafirah, I use tupperware containers for lots of my fish too. They are far, far cheaper than glass tanks, lighter and easier to move, plenty strong enough, and set up with heaters, filters, lights, aerators etc. I would prefer glass of course, but since my option was culling all my fry as soon as they were born (livebearers) I really don't appreciate being flamed for it, as I have been on more than one occasion.

I'm looking into getting a piece of wood to sit in front of the drawers so that when they slide out, they don't drop down.

Texan, I don't mean to be rude, but my house is very small, I have lived in it my entire life, and I don't feel cramped in the least. What you put in the space is as important as how much space you have. I am absolutely NOT condoning people who put bettas in cups, or starting a flame war, but I wouldn't be even considering this if I didn't think it was suitable.

If I remove the divider from each drawer, that gives the betta more than 2.5 gallons of water all to itself, which is over the recommended minimum and more than double the absolute minimum for bettas. Even divided, each section is over the 1 gal minimum if I only split each section into two (and I will not split it into three, the sections are really too small if I do this.)
 
Your nuts, this is a TERRIBLE IDEA. Just kidding =]. I like the idea, it osunds good adn all, but it will be a HUGE hassle opening and closeing those drawers. If you could sort out that issue, i think its a great idea. But, what about the fish sloshing out of the container. Becasue you obviously wont fill each 2.5 thing up, you'll not have exactly 2.5 gallons, then when you open those drawers the water will slosh around, and since the bettas like to float at the top, wont they fly out? Or wont you spill alot of water?
 
This is the major problem with it so far. I've been working on it. I measured the water as I was putting it in, there were no capacities on the box, and there's about 2.3 in each side in the photo. It's probably going to stay about 2.3 actually because I've put some gravel in there but not much more water. If you open the drawers very slowly, it seems to be okay. The problem is the raised rim on the front of each drawer - it's the last 5mm or so that splash water, so you have to be careful about it. I'm still working on this.
 
Laura try filling them with water and opening and closing them. I've got some with paperwork in and once the weight is in them they can be a devil to open and close
 
i think so long as you can deal with the splashing/drawer dropping aspect it looks like a great idea, especially for fry (more space than most "jarred" fry get even if you divided into 3)
in terms of heating, if you decided you did want to heat it, i would think reptile heat mats would work really well, they don't get really hot, so no worries about melting plastic or the like, and they keep it at a nice even temp. just got one myself recently for my fry "jars" so i'm a bit of a convert.
 
k, thanks for the hint ibble!

The drawers are full of water and gravel now. They are ungainly but manageable. You have to open and close them VERY slowly, but I have managed to do it several times without spilling a drop.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top