A Few Lr Questions

saltwater

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Mar 25, 2006
Messages
66
Reaction score
0
When you get those littler hitch hikers on your LR do they survive the cycle?
I know LR removes ammonia and nitrite but does it remove nitrate?
What would be the benfits of having 30 pounds of LR in the main 30 gal aquarium with the fish and corals and 30 pounds in the 30 gal sump? (so basically 60 pounds of LR over 60 gallons of water filtering the waste capacity of a 30 gallon tank)
Is there any clear difference in performance of LR and LS?
Why is live sand so much more expensive per pound?
Im still a bit confused about coralline algae, could someone explain it?
 
When you get those littler hitch hikers on your LR do they survive the cycle?

Usually. The common hitch hikers wont have a problem, but sometimes you can get fragile organisms on there that will perish.

I know LR removes ammonia and nitrite but does it remove nitrate?

In theory, yes, in practice, sometimes no. It all depends on how long your LR was left out of a curing tank and without a food source... Alas, there is no real set formula.

What would be the benfits of having 30 pounds of LR in the main 30 gal aquarium with the fish and corals and 30 pounds in the 30 gal sump? (so basically 60 pounds of LR over 60 gallons of water filtering the waste capacity of a 30 gallon tank)

More filtration capacity and more area and possibility of being able to process nitrates more effectively. Basically makes the tank less of a worry from a nitrogen cycle standpoint. It also provides a great way to colonize and grow copepods which is a natural food source for many reef fish.

Is there any clear difference in performance of LR and LS?

Complicated answer here. IMO, LS is a waste of money. Sand becomes live very quickly (within a month or two) when LR is present in the tank. So I tend to advocate spending money on LR as opposed to LS. Shallow sand beds 2" or less in thickness will not harbor dentrivores that process nitrate. Deep sand beds (DSB) of 4" or greater will process nitrates if given a very long time for the anaerobic bacteria to grow there. The downside to DSB's in the display tank are twofold. #1, they take up a lot of viewing space. #2, they can harbor pockets of cyanide which if disturbed will of course kill your livestock. For these two reasons, especially #2, most people who choose to use a DSB have theirs in their sump, not in their display tank ;)

Why is live sand so much more expensive per pound?

I'm not really sure there...

Im still a bit confused about coralline algae, could someone explain it?

Sure, its an algae type that grows in reefs. It requires calcium, light for photosynthesis, and nitrates for growth. Its basically a plant that grows its shell out of calcium. It looks really pretty (usually purple colors) and can process nitrates. Given enough time it will cover many surfaces of your tank including glass and plastic.
 
When you get those littler hitch hikers on your LR do they survive the cycle?
Some do some don't - can't say more than that really

I know LR removes ammonia and nitrite but does it remove nitrate?
Mature live rock contains anerobes which are Nitrogen fixing bacteria, these convert Nitrates to Nitrogen thus completing the Nitrogen Cycle

What would be the benfits of having 30 pounds of LR in the main 30 gal aquarium with the fish and corals and 30 pounds in the 30 gal sump? (so basically 60 pounds of LR over 60 gallons of water filtering the waste capacity of a 30 gallon tank)
Erm..........really good filtration?

Is there any clear difference in performance of LR and LS?
Live rock and live sand contain the same bacteria (in live sand only if there are anerobic areas) so the only difference will be surface area, the one with the most will be better

Why is live sand so much more expensive per pound?
Because it is collected along with seawater to keep the organisms alive, this means more weight which means more cost to transport plus the added bit for the 'convienence' of it

Im still a bit confused about coralline algae, could someone explain it?
It's a purple algae that grows in well maintained marine tanks and helps with Nitrate reduction. Too much, however, blocks up the porous live rock and therefore has a negative effect on NItrate reduction.
 
So I can culture copepods in the sump and then net then out to feed my fish? Nice! In that link it said to feed that liquid phyto-food, where can I buy it?

Also, would they be good for freshwater fish? I have various puffers and they cant get enough of live crusteaceans!

Hold on, how big do these things get? They reccomend using a plankton net, wouldnt they just get sucked up the pump and go into the main tank?
 
The majority of 'pod life won't survive the journey through the pumps impellor so this is not really a viable way to feed the tank. THe best way is to setup a refugium above the tank which has water pumped up to it and then gravity takes water bak to the main tank along with live 'pods.

If it's a freshwater puffer then I wouldn't think you could feed them to it, if it's brackish or marine then there shouldn't be a problem (the 'pods won't survive very long out of saltwater though.

Liquid Phyto is great as a food source and some LFS will sell it, otherwise you can buy it on eBay or make your own
 
Netting them will be nearly impossibel cause they are EXTREMELY small
 
I have collected 'pods from my sump and added them to the display tank in the past but it is a pain. The best way I found to do it was to lift out a piece of live rock and shake it in a bucket of tank water then add the water to the display tank.
 
I have collected 'pods from my sump and added them to the display tank in the past but it is a pain. The best way I found to do it was to lift out a piece of live rock and shake it in a bucket of tank water then add the water to the display tank.

I was thinking doing something similar but using a clump of Chaeto instead of LR ;)
 
Copepods sound like a good idea to feed my bumblebee gobies! Does anyone know if they are healthy for freshwater fish? (or in this case weakly brackish)
 
Copepods only survive in marine conditions so you would have to set up a marine tank to breed them in which would in essence be a Nano tank and not the easiest of tank to look after if just for a food source. No where I know of sells copepods as a foos source.
 
I am aware they require marine conditions, I was referring to culturing them myself. Maybe something like a heated, bare bottomed, ten gallon with a few pounds of live rock would be a good culturing site.
 
As posted:
you would have to set up a marine tank to breed them in which would in essence be a Nano tank and not the easiest of tank to look after if just for a food source.
The time, effort and costs involved would make it totally uneconomic to produce a viable food source IMO
 
Im not setting up a reef tank. Just a ten gallon tank setup cost $20 plus $15 for liverock, Regular lighting, RO water wouldnt cost anything at 75 cents a gallon for a ten gallon tank. Little time, effort, and cost.

I dont consider that uneconomical.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top