He's dying!

Red15

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Jan 17, 2022
Messages
71
Reaction score
22
Location
Earth?
My Dumbo ear platinum red tail guppy is dying!
He was fine when I brought him 2 months ago though he had an injured tail. Then for the last three weeks he started to develop fin rot which was too mild and slow to notice. Three days ago, I noticed one of his fin was ripped really badly.
So I quarrentined him and three other male guppies with tails smaller than I remembered. I added some aquarium salt too.
The next day, I found my cobra guppy dead, who except for the missing chunk of his tail seemed too healthy to die and white tuxedo guppy whos tail had a chunk missing which hadn't been there before I moved him. So I removed both the tuxedo and another cobra male and put them in main tank.
Today both of them seem better, the tuxedos tail seems to get surprisingly better in the difference of one day.
But the platinum red tail has gotten worse. He's too weak, his beautiful tail and fins both are too damaged, he's losing balance and he has a small, round thing sticking out of his belly.
I know that it's too late for him to survive and it's really sad cause he was my first fancy guppy. But I'd like to know what is causing him death, and why was it that he and other males looked healthy and fine in main tank but moving them had made them worse in shape?
IMG_20220206_123859.jpg
IMG_20220206_123843.jpg
 
Last edited:
I am very sorry for your loss. I used to have beautiful guppies too and my favourite one was found as a skeleton in the morning.
Sorry for yours too.
I don't know- I never wanted to keep guppies, but when I visit fish stores, I can never come back without one, yet I wouldn't say that they are my favourite cause I do know that they aren't.
They are such beautiful and mesmerising creatures, they make me feel like I'm their mom...And I didn't expect it to hurt as bad as it does.
 
I'm so sorry for your loss. What is your tank params? Is there anything in the tank besides the guppies?
 
I'm not aware of the water parameters since I don't own a kit but I do a 20-30% water change every weekend and all other fishes in my tank seem just fine.
Other than guppies, I have Molly, swordtail, SAE- one pair of each, and 7 neon tetras.
 
I'm not aware of the water parameters since I don't own a kit but I do a 20-30% water change every weekend and all other fishes in my tank seem just fine.
Other than guppies, I have Molly, swordtail, SAE- one pair of each, and 7 neon tetras.
Knowing water parameters is essential... Did you know you have fish from two different kinds of water? Neon tetras are soft and acidic water fish, while mollies and guppies are hard and alkaline water fish. Depending on if you have soft water or hard water that says what fish you can keep. So defintiely get the API master kit and the API GH and KH kit which will test for water hardness.
 
I will but I'm really busy with college and stuff. Do you know what actually happened to my Dumbo ear?
 
I will but I'm really busy with college and stuff. Do you know what actually happened to my Dumbo ear?
Without knowing your water params, all we can do is guess...my guess is ammonia poisoning
 
Without knowing your water params, all we can do is guess...my guess is ammonia poisoning
I don't think it was ammonia poisoning. While I can't guarantee that a cent percent, I can assure that I do a very thorough cleaning in my tank, sometimes even two days a week. And most of the time, whenever I'm free, I take some water out and pour some in.

I know that ammonia poisoning can still be a suspect but my guessing would be some sort of parasite since he had a round ball sticking out of his belly, yes, that comes from poor water condition too but each of my fishes is perfectly healthy and my other guppies that I'd moved again to the main tank look so better and active than in the new water, the tuxedo even revived the edges of its tail that had been frayed.
Or maybe I'd like to believe so.
However, I know that I need one of those kits, guess I'll buy one next time I visit the store. But thanks for reminding me.
 
Last edited:
I don't think it was ammonia poisoning. While I can't guarantee that a cent percent, I can assure that I do a very thorough cleaning in my tank, sometimes even two days a week. And most of the time, whenever I'm free, I take some water out and pour some in.

I know that ammonia poisoning can still be a suspect but my guessing would be some sort of parasite since he had a round ball sticking out of his belly, yes, that comes from poor water condition too but each of my fishes is perfectly healthy and my other guppies that I'd moved again to the main tank look so better and active than in the new water, the tuxedo even revived the edges of its tail that had been frayed.
Or maybe I'd like to believe so.
However, I know that I need one of those kits, guess I'll buy one next time I visit the store. But thanks for reminding me.
It doesnt matter how well you "clean" the tank. Sometimes tap water has choromines which is a mix of chorine and ammonia and both are highly toxic for fish. If you only use a water conditioner that rids of chlorine, the ammonia is left in the tank amd kills the fish. And another reason for ammonia in the tank is not having the tank cycled. Without a cycled tank ammonia AND nitrites build up and then kill the fish. I also noticed that you have guppies. Guppies are hard water fish while bettas are soft water. If hard water fish are in soft water it leads to kidney failure and vice versa with with soft water fish in hard water.
 
It doesnt matter how well you "clean" the tank. Sometimes tap water has choromines which is a mix of chorine and ammonia and both are highly toxic for fish. If you only use a water conditioner that rids of chlorine, the ammonia is left in the tank amd kills the fish. And another reason for ammonia in the tank is not having the tank cycled. Without a cycled tank ammonia AND nitrites build up and then kill the fish. I also noticed that you have guppies. Guppies are hard water fish while bettas are soft water. If hard water fish are in soft water it leads to kidney failure and vice versa with with soft water fish in hard water.
I learnt that the preference of water is different in guppy and tetra after you said that. Now that I have one tank, I can't separate them either. As always, my bad.
But I did cycle my tank for three months before adding fish to it.
What about leaving water for a few days before using it? I read that it could work, does it not?
If it doesn't then what product do you recommend I use?
 
Last edited:
Umm...actually I don't have Betta fish. But I do have neon tetras and I learnt that the preference of water is different in guppy and tetra after I bought them. Now that I have one tank, I can't separate them either. As always, my bad.
What about leaving water for a few days before using it? I read that it could work, does it not?
It does, but only for chlorine, not choromines as I think ammonia does not evaporate from water. I think, I don't absolutely know.
 
It does, but only for chlorine, not choromines as I think ammonia does not evaporate from water. I think, I don't absolutely know.
What product do you recommend I use then? To treat water?
 

Most reactions

Back
Top