What kinds of fish to get?

Indigodragonfire

New Member
Joined
Jan 6, 2022
Messages
26
Reaction score
13
Location
Louisville,KY
My fiance had his 18 year old cat pass away recently and my elderly rats also passed.I decided to get back into keeping fish.What kinds of fish need smaller tanks and are easiest to care for?I used to have a 20 gallon full of some kind of tetras and occasionally other fish as a kid but it's been a while,I no longer have that tank and plan on purchasing a smaller one.I have a smaller apartment so a tank that could fit on a table or desk would be great,unless I convince my roommate to let me have a bigger one in the livingroom.
 
Certainly a loaded question! The fish you should get totally depends on your tank, level of free-time, water parameters (water hardness and pH are the ones most referenced here, as they're typically unchanging figures that can make or break the peace in an aquarium), your wants, e.c.t.

For a tank that could fit on a table or desk, you're looking at maybe 5-15 gallons? Of course that depends on the table size (and sturdiness). Many people suggest bettas (or Siamese fighting fish, as some still call them) for smaller tanks. They're a solitary, generally calm fish that don't mind living in a smaller space. Most recommend at least a 5 gallon tank, but bigger is always better! While aggressive towards their own species and others, they can usually be seen housed with shrimp such as cherry shrimp. Vibrant, attractive, small shrimp that add a lot to a small space. Easy to build a colony of them too, if you're planning on taking over the world with them. Both cherry shrimp and bettas prefer a more neutral pH, and softer water.

For bigger tanks (20+ gallons), the possibilities are almost endless. In my 230L (~60 gallons), I keep three species of plec, tetras, fan shrimp and more. It's around 4ft, and provides more than enough space for my young fish that are all within the 6 months to 1 year old age range. Take a look at some of the tanks owned by people on the forum. You can find "journals" of tanks, including many photos from forum users and how they get their aquariums to where they are. Lots of folks have links to pics of their tanks in their signature, such as @WhistlingBadger and his setups. Here's a full thread by @Slaphppy7 showing off all his fancy thingamajigs.
 
Certainly a loaded question! The fish you should get totally depends on your tank, level of free-time, water parameters (water hardness and pH are the ones most referenced here, as they're typically unchanging figures that can make or break the peace in an aquarium), your wants, e.c.t.

For a tank that could fit on a table or desk, you're looking at maybe 5-15 gallons? Of course that depends on the table size (and sturdiness). Many people suggest bettas (or Siamese fighting fish, as some still call them) for smaller tanks. They're a solitary, generally calm fish that don't mind living in a smaller space. Most recommend at least a 5 gallon tank, but bigger is always better! While aggressive towards their own species and others, they can usually be seen housed with shrimp such as cherry shrimp. Vibrant, attractive, small shrimp that add a lot to a small space. Easy to build a colony of them too, if you're planning on taking over the world with them. Both cherry shrimp and bettas prefer a more neutral pH, and softer water.

For bigger tanks (20+ gallons), the possibilities are almost endless. In my 230L (~60 gallons), I keep three species of plec, tetras, fan shrimp and more. It's around 4ft, and provides more than enough space for my young fish that are all within the 6 months to 1 year old age range. Take a look at some of the tanks owned by people on the forum. You can find "journals" of tanks, including many photos from forum users and how they get their aquariums to where they are. Lots of folks have links to pics of their tanks in their signature, such as @WhistlingBadger and his setups. Here's a full thread by @Slaphppy7 showing off all his fancy thingamajigs.
Oh shrimp and beta are a great idea!My fiance used to keep ghost shrimp so has a bit of experience with some shrimp.I was actually planning on this being a suprise for valentines day this year,he is moving in with me and we had planned on his cat that passed joining us.I talked to his mom and subtly asked him if it was ok.Also,where are good places to get fish and stuff?I am a bit wary of pet stores I've gotten really sick pets from ones in my area.
 
Oh shrimp and beta are a great idea!My fiance used to keep ghost shrimp so has a bit of experience with some shrimp.I was actually planning on this being a suprise for valentines day this year,he is moving in with me and we had planned on his cat that passed joining us.I talked to his mom and subtly asked him if it was ok.Also,where are good places to get fish and stuff?I am a bit wary of pet stores I've gotten really sick pets from ones in my area.
Would totally recommend going to independent (and reputable) shops. Steer away from places like petco, petsmart, e.t.c. since their fish are usually riddled with disease.
 
Would totally recommend going to independent (and reputable) shops. Steer away from places like petco, petsmart, e.t.c. since their fish are usually riddled with disease.
Yeah my fiances last fish had some sort of parasite that ate a hole through them.Not cool:(
 
Welcome to the forum! As PG predicted, it would be really helpful if you could let us know how hard your water is, and what size tank you decide on. Those are good places to start. Bigger is better generally, but you can do some cool things with a 5 gallon, too.

As for sources, I almost always order from The Wet Spot in Portland, OR, or occasionally from reputable ebay shops. I'm not sure how well they ship all the way to KY, but if you give them a call they have great service and they'll help you out. Of course, if you can find a great fish retailer closer by, you'll save lots of money on postage. Perhaps some other members will chime in on good sources in the eastern US.

Very impressive username! Keep that indigo fire away from your fish!
 
Welcome to the forum! As PG predicted, it would be really helpful if you could let us know how hard your water is, and what size tank you decide on. Those are good places to start. Bigger is better generally, but you can do some cool things with a 5 gallon, too.

As for sources, I almost always order from The Wet Spot in Portland, OR, or occasionally from reputable ebay shops. I'm not sure how well they ship all the way to KY, but if you give them a call they have great service and they'll help you out. Of course, if you can find a great fish retailer closer by, you'll save lots of money on postage. Perhaps some other members will chime in on good sources in the eastern US.

Very impressive username! Keep that indigo fire away from your fish!
How would I even figure out what water conditions are here?
 
Welcome to the forum! As PG predicted, it would be really helpful if you could let us know how hard your water is, and what size tank you decide on. Those are good places to start. Bigger is better generally, but you can do some cool things with a 5 gallon, too.

As for sources, I almost always order from The Wet Spot in Portland, OR, or occasionally from reputable ebay shops. I'm not sure how well they ship all the way to KY, but if you give them a call they have great service and they'll help you out. Of course, if you can find a great fish retailer closer by, you'll save lots of money on postage. Perhaps some other members will chime in on good sources in the eastern US.

Very impressive username! Keep that indigo fire away from your fish!
And thanks,it's the username I go by just about everywhere.I really like dragons and my favorite color is indigo!
 
I found some information on my city's water!
USER_SCOPED_TEMP_DATA_orca-image--572947788.jpeg
 
As stated in your other thread, you have soft water (123 ppm/7 dH) but very basic water. These do not usually go together and make it difficult to stock a a tank as most soft water fish need pH at or below 7.


Have you tested your tap water pH yourself - both freshly run and a sample that's been left to stand overnight? If the water provider adds something to change the pH, it may well gas off on standing.
If you don't have a test kit yet, you will need one to set up the tank.
 
As stated in your other thread, you have soft water (123 ppm/7 dH) but very basic water. These do not usually go together and make it difficult to stock a a tank as most soft water fish need pH at or below 7.


Have you tested your tap water pH yourself - both freshly run and a sample that's been left to stand overnight? If the water provider adds something to change the pH, it may well gas off on standing.
If you don't have a test kit yet, you will need one to set up the tank.
I'm going to get stuff to test my water soon if I can find it.On amazon maybe?and I am considering a beta!I'll hop back on here after I've tested our water.
 
I ordered the water test kit.Talked to roommate and we are getting a 10 gallon instead.My fiance apparently loves pea pufferfish but I'm not sure if we could manage those.He thinks they are cute and chubby,maybe I can find something else he thinks is cute?
 

Most reactions

Back
Top