Ravenes
Fish Crazy
Is their any preparation involved with play sand? I know I have to wash it but can I just put it in my tank without harming my fish or do I have to drain the entire tank?
Was wondering about play sand?
- Thread starter Ravenes
- Start date
Rinse the living daylights out of it.
But otherwise nah its good to use.
May be easier to move the fish out while you replace the substrate though
But otherwise nah its good to use.
May be easier to move the fish out while you replace the substrate though
Ravenes
Fish Crazy
Ok, anyways was wondering about plants do they go well in sand?
Yep!
Any plants like swords or crypts will need root tabs, but thats the same even with gravel. Just research what plants you like and see what care they may need, but any plant can be planted just fine in sand.
Any plants like swords or crypts will need root tabs, but thats the same even with gravel. Just research what plants you like and see what care they may need, but any plant can be planted just fine in sand.
Ravenes
Fish Crazy
What are root tabs?
Koglin
Fish Crazy
They're like substrate fertilizer for plants, just use as directed and any plants that rely on a planted root system will benefit from the added nutrients to your sand. They last a long while too, few months or so if I remember right. I had dwarf hairgrass in sand that was just slow to grow until I popped in root tabs, now it's booming.
You can usually find API or Seachem root tabs at most pet stores, think they're usually ten bucks or so for a pack.
Last edited:
Ravenes
Fish Crazy
Ok thx just wanted to know. I was also wondering does it matter how hard the water is? Do plants do well with naturally high hardness?
Retired Viking
Fish Connoisseur
I switched one of my tanks from gravel to sand and I am happy with it. I added extra plants like hornwort to protect against a spike in ammonia. I placed all my fish in a plastic bucket with aerator and covered the bucket with a dark towel (fish went to sleep) I removed everything from the tank and placed live plants in their own buckets. Then I removed the gravel, washed out the tank and added the sand. I use flourish root tabs for my rooted plants.
Yes most plants do well in hard water as the minerals they require for growth are more abundant
Koglin
Fish Crazy
Do you know your water parameters by chance? They'll be available on your water sources (or county) website if not.
Kind of depends on the plants though. Generally, plants thrive with certain minerals such as calcium and magnesium present in the water, but you can get those from a liquid fertilizer. You'll wanna watch your hardness for your fish needs first.
Might help to pick your plants based on your fish, and match the water needs that way.
Ravenes
Fish Crazy
What about if I had corydoras would they be safe?
I would be careful if the sand has been crushed and is silica sand. It is like putting slithers of glass into your tank, naturally formed sand has rounded edges and there for I feel is a much better option.
I switched to play sand last week from gravel. I didn't have a mini cycle luckily bit tested daily. My filter & driftwood/decorations must've had enough bacteria. It's made a hard he difference to the look of the tank.
I've less plants now as my plants couldn't get deep enough root in my gravel & wasted away. I've 2"/3" sand and the plants have better space to grow.
Another big advantage is I find sand much much easier to plant in. My OH says with sand it looks less like a giant fish toilet
my water is 250ppm so hard.
I've less plants now as my plants couldn't get deep enough root in my gravel & wasted away. I've 2"/3" sand and the plants have better space to grow.
Another big advantage is I find sand much much easier to plant in. My OH says with sand it looks less like a giant fish toilet
my water is 250ppm so hard.Attachments
Ravenes
Fish Crazy
So I was wondering do I have to remove my gravel? Could I just build on top of it?
Similar threads
Most reactions
-
347 -
237 -
227 -
220 -
209 -
194 -
179 -
141 -
136 -
123 -
99 -
98 -
93 -
88 -
88