What's new
By:
Filters

Unexplained red gourami deaths

Chuunofish

Chuunofish

New Member
Joined
May 7, 2020
Messages
29
Reaction score
7
Location
Rugby
Hi All,

I have a 90g which is 3 months old, ph 7, ammonia nitrite, nitrate, phosphate all 0, kh5, gh8 tank has 9 zebra danio 6 otos , 1 emperor pleco, 2 pearl gourami and 2 red gourami. Lots of plants and wood all seemed fine. Last week the Male red started looking very weak, very lethargic unless I was trying to catch him had problems with swimming upright but no real issues with buoyancy. Next morning he was dead. Today same thing with the female. No visible signs of parasites, discolouration, or lesions. Have had them from LFS for 3 weeks.they seemed really happy for the first few weeks.
Any ideas on what may have caused this and should I worry about the rest?
 
Dwarf gourami are very very prone to disease, particularly DGD which claims many of them. At no fault to you. Just poor luck with them. Finding healthy dwarf gourami is very difficult.

Since you also have pearl gourami in the same tank, do not get more dwarf gourami. Mixing them is risky because there is a rare chance virus can spread to other gourami species.
 
It's no good that your nitrate levels are 0, it indicates that you tank isn't cycled and you do not need to include your phosphate levels.
 
Its possible to have 0 nitrates. Tank is 3 months old and fairly stocked, they should have a cycle unless their filter was changed or broken down.

Lots of plants can reduce nitrates to nothing (which makes me jealous ha!)
 
Salty&Onion said:
It's no good that your nitrate levels are 0, it indicates that you tank isn't cycled and you do not need to include your phosphate levels.
Click to expand...
Tank has cycled, ammonium, nitrates and nitrite have all been high and managed with regular water changes I have been measuring daily for 12 weeks, after the initial cycle I did have an ammonia spike when the plec was added but treated with niteout and amorax filter media to reduce rapidly as had fish was around week 7 I happy tank has cycled unless it is normal for an upcycled tank to produce high levels of ammonia followed by nitrite followed by nitrate all reduced to current level.
 
Chuunofish said:
Tank has cycled, ammonium, nitrates and nitrite have all been high and managed with regular water changes I have been measuring daily for 12 weeks, after the initial cycle I did have an ammonia spike when the plec was added but treated with niteout and amorax filter media to reduce rapidly as had fish was around week 7 I happy tank has cycled unless it is normal for an upcycled tank to produce high levels of ammonia followed by nitrite followed by nitrate all reduced to current level.
Click to expand...
But I'm sorry, nitrate of 0ppm is indicating that your tank isn't cycled at all :(
I know it's frustrating.
 
Salty&Onion said:
But I'm sorry, nitrate of 0ppm is indicating that your tank isn't cycled at all :(
I know it's frustrating.
Click to expand...

Salty&Onion said:
But I'm sorry, nitrate of 0ppm is indicating that your tank isn't cycled at all :(
I know it's frustrating.
Click to expand...
I bow to your superior knowledge, how will I know that it has cycled as this is the data which suggests it has so not sure how I will tell when it has cycled
 

Attachments

  • 20200507_212219.jpg
    20200507_212219.jpg
    3.1 MB · Views: 95
Last edited:
Chuunofish said:
I bow to your superior knowledge, how will I know that it has cycled as this is the data which suggests it has so not sure how I will tell when it has cycled
Click to expand...
Lol, technically your test strips will tell you or API Master Kit.
You have to test your every single day to see how it goes on and if your ammonia and nitrite levels are 0ppm for 7 continuous days ^_^
Hope this helps! :lol:
 
Salty&Onion said:
Lol, technically your test strips will tell you or API Master Kit.
You have to test your every single day to see how it goes on and if your ammonia and nitrite levels are 0ppm for 7 continuous days ^_^
Hope this helps! :lol:
Click to expand...
If you look at the chart that's what I did, nitrate levels followed and reduced to 0, as nitrifying bacteria can form on any surface in the aquarium is it possible that the large piece of wood is acting similar to live rock would in a reef tank?
 
Chuunofish said:
If you look at the chart that's what I did, nitrate levels followed and reduced to 0, as nitrifying bacteria can form on any surface in the aquarium is it possible that the large piece of wood is acting similar to live rock would in a reef tank?
Click to expand...
Yes you're right, but basically 0ppm of nitrates indicates that your tank is not cycled.
 
Found this for you:

'A reading of 0 Nitrate means either the tank is extremely clean, or completely without a functional cycle. Or maybe a tank without any live animals. If you want a cycle you need someone pooing in there. ... If not Nitrate, then nitrite. If not nitrite, then ammonia should be present'

Which, in your case, your tank is uncycled..
 
Ok, now I am confused, it has had all those things and they have reduced to 0, i am using RO water and 10-20% water changes per week. So maybe it is just very clean, I am also doing 2ml seachem flourish twice per week as plant food
 
Sorry, @Salty&Onion, i have to disagree. The tank can be cycled and still show 0 nitrate. It isnt the norm, but not impossible, especially with the use of chemical media that reduces nitrates. I use Nitrazorb which reduces nitrate. In a tank of low nitrate (a 90 gal with that stock is pretty lightly stocked), chemical filtration can reduce nitrate to nothing.
 
NCaquatics said:
Sorry, @Salty&Onion, i have to disagree. The tank can be cycled and still show 0 nitrate. It isnt the norm, but not impossible, especially with the use of chemical media that reduces nitrates. I use Nitrazorb which reduces nitrate. In a tank of low nitrate (a 90 gal with that stock is pretty lightly stocked), chemical filtration can reduce nitrate to nothing.
Click to expand...
There is a nitrate filter in the juwel filter stack
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

J
Help! My New Fish Are Struggling ---Flukes?—What Should I Do?
Replies
7
Views
438
Colin_T
Colin_T
PygmyPepperJulli
Sudden Pearl Gourami Death- concerned for tankmates
Replies
12
Views
664
PygmyPepperJulli
PygmyPepperJulli
Tyler777
Angels n gouramies
Replies
2
Views
579
Tyler777
Tyler777
L
Moonlight issue
Replies
6
Views
734
FranciscoB
F
J
Do I just restart all of my tanks?
2
Replies
23
Views
1K
Lcc86
L

Most reactions

Useful Links

Back
Top