What Colour Lights for a tropical fish tank

Simon101

New Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2021
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Location
Sidlesham
Hi i currently have a twin T5 tube set up, one white and one pink. I am thinking of changing to leds, for a tropical tank what is best 1 white and 1 pink or 2 white (or 2 pink). I have read the pink is best suited for tropical but unsure as to have a mix or have both the same? If i kept 1 white what is best Marine white or freshwater white.
I am looking at these Arcadia T5 LED Aquarium Tube Lamp - Tropical Pro
and either Arcadia T5 LED Aquarium Tube Lamp - Marine White or Freshwater Pro

Any help will be great
 
First, are live plants intended? Light has to be specific in intensity and spectrum (the colour temperature) for aquatic plants. If no live plants, then you have a wider option, though I personally prefer a natural daylight and avoid extreme colour choices. Light does affect fish, (that is an involved topic I won't get into) so in all cases, less intense light is preferable to brighter light, something to keep in mind. Floating plants can help shade light, a real benefit to fish.. Knowing about the plant issue should allow members with experience of the mentioned lights to offer advice.
 
Im just starting with live plants with just a couple of hornwort in the substrate but wanting to go for a lot more plants!
 
Of course, Byron is correct... unless you have plants, lighting is more for us to better observe the fish. Fish in the wild often live in very shaded or even quite murky waters. As for plants, because of proximity, floating plants do well under almost any lighting. Then too, for LED lighting for planted tanks, they often contain white, red, and blue LED's. If I was you I'd just get an LED light intended for a planted tank and try to find a good value (they can be a bit pricey). :)
 
Im just starting with live plants with just a couple of hornwort in the substrate but wanting to go for a lot more plants!

Then look for decent "plant" light, as AbbeysDad rightly pointed out, you are best with a "natural daylight" spectrum. You can fuss over various technical issues, but I have never found it necessary to go much beyond spectrum which is expressed in Kelvin, and light that is natural daylight will have a Kelvin rating in the range of 5000K to 6700K. A higher number means much less red and much more blue for a much "cooler" white, while lower numbers are more red and less blue for a "warmer" white. Unfortunately, words are useless here because they can mean different things depending who uses them, so it is the Kelvin number on the package/tube/fixture you need to use. But even then not all "6500K" is the same, I have discovered.

Intensity is a very different distinct issue, regardless of the Kelvin. So "X" manufacturer's 6500K LED unit might be very different intensity from "Y" manufacturers 6500K unit, not to mention the colour may be different too. I can't help beyond this as I have had no real success with LED and still use T8 fluorescent which I do understand and with which I have had tremendous success, but my tanks are fairly low-tech and I don't try to grow difficult plants.

The colour I should mention about, this is critical for plants because aquatic plants need red and blue to drive photosynthesis--remember, the intensity enters this too--but if there is not sufficient red especially, photosynthesis is slowed and can be stopped. This is why almost all the non-plant LEDs fail, they are much too "cool" (high blue) with very low red in the mix making up the "white" light. BTW, "white" light is of course a mix of several colours, and mid-day sun is the aim, which not surprisingly is best achieved in the 5000K to 6500K range.
 
Hi i currently have a twin T5 tube set up, one white and one pink. I am thinking of changing to leds, for a tropical tank what is best 1 white and 1 pink or 2 white (or 2 pink). I have read the pink is best suited for tropical but unsure as to have a mix or have both the same? If i kept 1 white what is best Marine white or freshwater white.
I am looking at these Arcadia T5 LED Aquarium Tube Lamp - Tropical Pro
and either Arcadia T5 LED Aquarium Tube Lamp - Marine White or Freshwater Pro

Any help will be great
What size tank? What length?
 

Most reactions

Back
Top