What Are Some Compatible Fish With.....

`Peter

Fish Crazy
Joined
May 19, 2010
Messages
262
Reaction score
0
2 angelfish, 1 clown loach, 3 otos, 1 honey sunset gourami, 2 glow light tetras, 2 emerald corydas catfish. What other fish are compatible with my current stock. I was considering getting a school of cardinal or rummy nose tetras but what other fish can I buy? Ph is about 6.2 with live plants and driftwood inside the tank.
 
Just to let you know that eventually when the angels get big enough the glowlight tetras will become a light snack... so if you plan on keeping the angels to adulthood I would stay away from anything that stays under 2 inches......
 
What size is your tank? That will in part determine compatibility. Also your water stats as some fish do better in different water environments. Also how old are these fish? Corys should always be in a school a minimum of 5 individuals and preferably more. Same thing with tetras. And loaches really.
 
You guys are sort of exaggerating. I have a 29 gallon. I've had one of the angels for 2 years now and he is pretty big. He has never even chased my glowlights around so I don't think he will eat them >.>. The other one is still pretty small and they get along great. Corys do not need to be kept in 5 or more either, my 2 emeralds are very happy swimming together and healthy. And if there is a problem of the clown loach getting too big for the aquarium there isn't because it hasn't grown an inch since I got it.

Just give me some compatible fish lol not a aquarium lesson.
 
I have heard of certain angels being compatible with small fish... not mine, even when they were quarter sized they chased anything that was smaller..... guess it depends on temperment.... I think a 29 gallon is way too small for angels... you should have ATLEAST 18 inches in height excluding gravel etc...
ALSO.... EVERYWHERE I have ever read or witnessed people chatting said that cories should have a group of 6.... never kept them myself tho
 
Your tank might already be fully stocked, you haven't said what size it is? Ooops, sorry, just seen :blush:
 
Sucks when people tell you something you don't want to hear though don't it.

I'd say your pretty full already.

The fact your clown loach hasn't grown since you got it isn't really a great sign. And it isn't that cory's HAVE to be in a group of 5 or 6 but it does help. They'll be a lot more active, less stressed and more fun to watch. You seem to be lucky with the tetras, 2 years would seem that they are safe, some things can change in an instant though so be careful. If you want to be picky, angels actually would do better in a tank on their own and are also supposed to be in bigger numbers than 2. I'm told 1 or 4 or more.

If you want constructive advice -

Remove the clown loach
Add 3 more corys
How about upping your group of tetras if you confident they'll be ok

I think you already have something in mind though and are just waiting to see if someone mentions it :p
 
You guys are sort of exaggerating. I have a 29 gallon. I've had one of the angels for 2 years now and he is pretty big. He has never even chased my glowlights around so I don't think he will eat them >.>. The other one is still pretty small and they get along great. Corys do not need to be kept in 5 or more either, my 2 emeralds are very happy swimming together and healthy. And if there is a problem of the clown loach getting too big for the aquarium there isn't because it hasn't grown an inch since I got it.

Just give me some compatible fish lol not a aquarium lesson.

Holy crap way to throw back any help, dont think its worth adding anything but I want to put my thoughts on it because it might change your mind and realise why people are giving the advice they are.

Basically what was said is right, one of wild angelfishes main sources of food in the wild is tetras. Specifically neon tetras so your glowlights might go unnoticed but the main point is that all angel fish will have an instinct to hunt and eat tetras but if they get well fed the risk should go down but all people are saying is it might happen not it will happen which is true. The glowlights and the catfish both need to be in groups of at least 6 but the bigger the better, they might seem fine in the tank but realistically they dont know if they should have a minimum number of fish and wont be able to tell you. While some fish are quite expressive at times they dont have particularly expressive faces like humans or even other animals like dogs etc so they might look okay but in small numbers like that the individual fish will be feeling like "hang on where is everyone else". In the wild they are often in groups of hundreds so 6 minimum is nothing really but its a compromise for us to keep them in tanks. As far as the clown loach goes, its one of those fish that is hard to win an argument over tank size. This is because they grow so slowly it takes years for them to grow to any real size at all so Im not suprised that its not grown an inch but it might have grown a little but so slowly you dont notice at all. Again clown loaches fall under the same category as schooling fish they need to be in groups - if there is any doubt in your opinion of these have a look at this - http://www.loaches.com/species-index/clown-loach-chromobotia-macracanthus

It also explains the advice you have been giving out which is questionable at best sometimes. Just because you have a 3 foot tank and your fish appear healthy (not saying they are not healthy but there will be some kind of underlying stress issues in them, I dont mean like human stress Im not saying your fish need therapy Im not some hippy, but its the best word to describe whats going on with them) but yeah just because your fish seem fine does not mean you are right. The advice people give here is based on fact such as tetras live in 100s in the wild and need to be kept in numbers in our tank fact. Not I have 2 tetras in a tank for a year or so and they are still alive so they are fine.

So yeah you do need aquarium schooling. So far as compatable fish, as was said up your numbers of cories and tetras but all of the same species like 4-5 more emerald cats and 4-5 glowlights. Then because of the low Ph I would stick to South American fish as they will be better suited but till the other fish are in the right numbers not sure what to suggest.

Also one last thing to add, your emerald cories are not actually cories they are a type of brochis catfish and they are slightly slow growing, but will get a lot bigger than regular cories just something else to consider.

If im being honest with you it does seem a shame your attitude is so bad because if your fish were kept properly your tank would look fantastic, very natural and a good mix of fish.

Wills
 
Like above, up your corys to 5 or 6, wouldn't think about adding anything else other than that.
 
It can be frustrating when you aren't hearing what you would like to. Fortunately there are a lot of people on this site who are very knowledgable about our hobby (Wills being one of them) and I for one will gladly listen to that advice.

I'm afraid I'd definately go with the advice above. Up the cory's and tetra's.
Personally I'd also think about rehoming the clown as they really do prefer to be in groups and you couldn't get more of them in your tank. You really won't see their best and funniest behaviour in singles, but thats a difficult decision that only you could make.
I really wouldn't get any more fish than that though I'm afraid.
 
I'm surprised you're even bothered about compatible fish with an attitude like that!
 
Ya sorry if I got on the wrong foot with some people and I knwo you all are trying to help. I will consider upping the number of corrys to at least 4 and today I made sure all my tetras are in schools of at least 5. As for my clown loach I will keep it alone for the time being. Both my clowns and corries are very active and well so atm I see no reason to change much. There are plenty of hiding spots in the plants and caves that I have as well. Maybe it is just a matter of personal opinion. I think I was cranky last night and that is why I kind of snapped lol.
 
Best to get rid of clown loach as they get huge, atleast 10". They do grow very slow, but doesn't help his growth in a small tank. I have a 29 gallon and I have serpae tetras and black skirts and both are alot better in schools. Cories are the same, up the number.
 
Its not a matter of personal opinion, schooling fish need to be in schools is a fact not opinion. Like I say you cant just say that it is fine in your tank so that is now the rule or the rule that I will go by. Keeping the numbers low because you judge it is fine is just irresponsible fish keeping.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top