The elusive algae experience

R3GG

Fish Crazy
Joined
May 5, 2004
Messages
242
Reaction score
0
Location
Devon, U.K
I've been taking pictures of my planted tank since i set it up so i thought i'd briefly run through the algae problems and redesigning that occured.

July 04 Before any beard algae growth, the plants in the tank here have just become established and frequently show signs of growth through bubbling. Some fertilizer Is used, no CO2 enhancement Is used:

0%20(Small).jpg


July/Aug 04 The tank is still developing rapidly here, filtration at this stage consists of an external fluval 204 filter only

1%20(Small).jpg

The plants are clean and new and grow at an amazing rate
2%20(Small).jpg


This growth continues for months and i trim the plants on occasion. The fluval 204 begins to lose power and gets blocked and i find myself having to wash it every week as it just dribbles water after a couple of days.
I introduce a 2nd hand filter. Its a biolife and seems to do the job. From now on my tank begins to decline. Hair algae starts to cover everything and plant growth altogether stops...

3%20(Small).JPG


A close up

8%20(Small).JPG


Its pretty depressing this stuff, it only comes off with intense scrubbing and you cant get it off leaves without damaging them. The tank looks nothing like it did. Whether this algae came in on the filter or in water from a LFS (most probably the former) i'll never know but something had to be done...
Amano shrimp, otocinclus and sucking loaches have no impact on the algaes growth.
5%20(Small).JPG


After reading up on black beard algae and seeking advice on the forums i decided the best option was to chuck the plants. Cleaning with bleach doesnt seem worth the effort as i dont think the plants would miraculously resume growing. Plastic plants would grow more than these !

6%20(Small).JPG

Here (above) the tank has been stripped of all plants affected by the algae and only a few very small plants from runners remain. The filtration is upgraded by the return of the fluval 204 (left of picture) and a powerhead to increase water flow (also left). The biolife is cleaned internally and externally and the bogwood and rocks are scrubbed of algae. Feeding of the fish is halted to reduce nutrient accumulation within the tank. A large number of fast growing plants are on order to replace the ones old ones. These include vallis, Mexican oak leaf and ambulia (thanks to gf225 for advice). Mechanical algae and waste removal continues.

07/04/05 To create a more natural ‘amazon’ look a large piece of bogwood is added (left of image below) and replaces the rock that lay there previously. Not only do the small number of cardinals look a lot brighter but all of the fish now appear more interesting as they swim in and out of the various holes and tunnels in the wood. I have also created the illusion that the wood stretches to the middle of the tank - this is infact a separate piece of wood. The water will become redder in appearance as tannins are leached from the wood, this will decrease over time with water changes and is not a problem as it will benefit some of the fish. I’ve done this before the plants arrive as I think it will be a lot easier than deciding to do it in a rush when they do arrive or when I’ve already planted them - i dont want to crush the plants when positioning bogwood so i feel its best to plant around it. The line to left of the bogwood is my twigcat ;)

7%20(Small).JPG


I await the arrival of my plants on tuesday, i'll take some pics once they are all in and update this post!
Thanks for reading
 
Oh dude, that is harsh.....lucky ive neva had that algae... :(

So whats the plan now?
 
Sorry to hear of your loss. Hair algae has to be the worst type. This may not be of much help but if you're using 6700K bulbs try reducing to 5000-6500K. This also helps red plants a lot.
 
Thanks for the comments, i know it looks pretty rough! im not giving up even though recovering the tank is proving expensive and time consuming - hopefully this will help others who find themselves in a similar situation! Im considering switching the tubes like you said Iron man and when my new plants arrrive im hoping they will outcompete the remaining algae to a degree (as i've chosen only easy & fast growers) whilst mechanical removal continues.
Thanks again for comments :p
 
adding CO2 helped alot for my algae woes. CO2, a heavy plant load and SAE's could solve the problem completely.
 
ye that is harsh it was a good looking tank in the first 2 pics but im sure it will be just as good second time round. :D
 
Thanks for the advice, it just so happens i that i made Co2 system the other day and it worked great. The only thing i was worried about was how it would affect P.H but i can keep my eye on it :)
thanks
 
Sorry to read about your alage troubles.

I have some of that algae too!
I knew and was told this would happen with the light upgrade.
I've told my self that if it becomes uncontrollable, I wont fight it. I'll just rip the plants out and replace with rock and wood.

All the time, money and effort of trying to combat it just doesn't seem worth it, and your post just confirms this!
 
Well hopefully it will be worth be worth it when its under control :p Im not resorting to a permenantly unplanted tank!
 
Ok, big update. I received my plants today and have positioned them in the tank...so here are the pics:

The plants after being washed, tidied and checked for larvae/snails
plantz.JPG


A water change was carried out as it would aid planting and was a convenient time
tankprogress.JPG


Cardinal amongst the new vegetation
cardinal1.JPG


I bought some lillies as an experiment to see if they would grow..
lilly.JPG


Left
left.JPG

Center
center.JPG

Right
right.JPG


3 water lettuce going in, the amano shrimp seem to be particularly keen on hanging upside down and travelling around the tank on them.
waterlettuce.JPG


The finished product, fully planted with only minor adjustments needed here and there:
replantfull.JPG


A comparison of 2004/Early 2005 and now
comparison.jpg


Its not there yet but hopefully i'll get a bit of growth over the next few months and it'll start looking a bit more established
Thats all for now...
comments welcome,
Thanks for reading ;)
 
Awsome! Once thoise plants fill out itll all be good! :thumbs: :) I like the idea of some water lettuce, but i dont have enough room for it to grow....
 
Yeah the water lettuce is pretty cool - gives the fish and shrimp something to hide under. Im glad you like it!! Thanks for all your comments! :D :D :D
 

Most reactions

Back
Top