Silver sharks

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dawney G

Fish Fanatic
Joined
Mar 28, 2005
Messages
110
Reaction score
0
I put up a post about a silver shark not long ago. All i wanted to know was 'is my tank to small, or are they always this jumpy?'
mrminow closed it because it got too out of hand by viewers.
By the way, it was a silver shark and NOT a catfish. Which i would have stated if it was. And she is about 6 inches long.
So please, I will ask again (without the huge, uncalled for, dissagreement) Are SILVER SHARKS always this jumpy or is my tank to small? She lives in a 16gallon tank now and i got her with a 10gallon tank which i bought from someone. So befor people think its me being cruel (wilder) i thought i had better state that fact!!!!
Please help. Again!!
xx
dawney g
 
Dawney G said:
Are SILVER SHARKS always this jumpy or is my tank to small?
Plain and simple; yes your tank is too small.
 
Silver sharks are always jumpy if kept alone as they are schooling fish.

They also grow rather large, far too big for 16g.

Just a note: 'Silver Shark' is the common name in the UK for what our American friends call 'Bala Sharks'
Not to be confused with the Silver (Columbian) shark catfish which is of course something altogether different.
 
I am not the author of this article.



Name: Bala Shark
Other Names: Silver Shark or Tri-Colour Shark
Scientific Name: Balantiocheilus melanopterus
Family: Cyprinidae

Distribution: Commonly Thailand and other parts of South East Asia.
Length: 12-16 Inches although captive Balas rarely exceed 12 inches. Documented balas have reached nearly 24 inches.
Diet: Omnivorous, will eat almost anything; will accept almost all prepared tropical fish foods, and many fresh vegetables (recommended).
Water temperature: 72-82 F (22-28 C)
Water Chemistry: Favour soft-medium hardness.
pH: 6.0 to 7.0 (But like most fish, if acclimatized correctly and slowly can adapt to pH 8.0)
Lifespan: 15 years +

Housing: True tank busters. Minimum recommended sized tank when adult would be 200 gallons plus. They ideally need a tank in excess of 84in x 24in x 24in. It is very important that there be no sharp décor.

Sexing: Males are considered to be more slender while females may be deeper bodied as with others of the Cyprinid family.

Breeding: Egg layer, not known to breed in aquaria, but has been commercially bred in muddy ponds in SE Asia.

Description: A large-scaled silver shark (it is not really a shark, as it is a freshwater species, but they are named sharks due to their unique appearance and prominent dorsal). Its caudal, dorsal, anal and pelvic fins are all pale yellow and outlined in black, hence its common name Tri-colour shark.
This large, peaceful, and often skittish fish is an ideal community fish for those people in the hobby that can provide them with 200+ gallon tanks.


Requirements: They prefer large tanks, which are medium planted. The plants should be some of the hardier ones like Anacharis and Vallisneria as they might withstand the attentions of a hungry Bala. There really are no guarantees on plants surviving Balas at mealtimes. They are shoaling fish; so require the company of their own kind. Should be kept in minimum of 4s although better in shoals of 6. A good heavy hood fitted to their tank is a must, they are excellent jumpers and if startled have been known to take flight. Care must be taken when setting up tanks for Balas; all sharp objects must be removed so they don’t damage themselves if dashing for cover.

Behaviour: When kept singly, Balas are prone to being very Skittish and have a tendency to take flight and knock ornaments over, uproot plants just by a flick of their tail. They are peaceful community fish. If kept well-fed, they are not prone to snacking on smaller fish in the tank. Although be aware, the rule still applies if it fits in its mouth its still considered food.
Balas can often be heard emitting noise (loud clicking or cracking similar to clown loaches) at night, which can be heard from their tanks and has sent many new owners running to check that their tank class isn’t cracked.

Tank levels: All over the tank.

Ease of keeping: Not a beginner’s fish, but Balas are relatively easy fish to keep, provided they are supplied with the basic necessities, lots of swimming space and company of their own kind. As mentioned they tend toward skittish, so slow movement is required around their tank at all times, as sudden movement can sent them dashing for cover. But due to their final adult size and tank needs, I wouldn’t recommend them to a beginner.

Ideal Tank Mates: Include silver dollars, rainbow fish, loaches, plecs. As mentioned can be kept with smaller fish but I must stress again the balas must kept well fed. Danios, guppies, swordtails and corydoras are all good tank mates.

Unsuitable Tankmates: This list should include all aggressive territorial fish. Also included would be slow gentle fish that get stressed by tank mates that zip around at a million miles an hour. Angel fish would be a bad idea, bettas to wouldnt be wise.

Miscellaneous: In the past the Bala shark had become highly threatened in its native countries due to its popularity as an aquarium fish. More recently with more success in captive breeding this has abated slightly, but the Bala is still firmly on the endangered list.
 
will you be able to afford a large tank for it? I know the profile says 75, but CFC isnt that just for one? I read else where 125 plus is best for a large school.
 
I really dont have the room for a bigger tank, and I cant afford a new one at all. I wish I could because I absalutly love this fish to bits. All I wanted to know is, is my tank to small. I now know, so thankyou for your answers, and I am going to give my fish to someone with a huge tank (and maybe more silver sharks) who will look after it well like I did.
I really care for my fish, and i feel really hurt by wilders comment in the old post. '16gal for a bala shark, thats disgusting, and they are jumpy fish'. If he had read my post properly then he would have knew I got her with a 10gallon tank that I bought from someone. I moved her into my 16gallon tank, which im sure we all know is better for her.
Thankyou all for your answers, Im sure i will find a home as good as mine for her.
xx
dawney G
 
also, CFC, for your information, I am sure there is nothing wrong with the profiles on this site at all. As it happens I am a new member and havent really been on here much but only to ask questions out about my tank and bits. I didnt know there was a profile thing on here where you can check about your fish. Im sure im not the only person who asks questions about things that they can find out by looking at the profiles.
I dont know about you but it seems like everyone is on my case today!!!
dawney G
 
Dawney G said:
also, CFC, for your information, I am sure there is nothing wrong with the profiles on this site at all. As it happens I am a new member and havent really been on here much but only to ask questions out about my tank and bits. I didnt know there was a profile thing on here where you can check about your fish. Im sure im not the only person who asks questions about things that they can find out by looking at the profiles.
I dont know about you but it seems like everyone is on my case today!!!
dawney G
That post wasnt aimed at you Dawny, sorry if you thought it was. Wilder has a habbit of using links and information from other sites to answer every question which has now drawn the attention of the mods.
 
I didn't no there was a profile either, then there is always someone who has a better one,it's a fact of life.
 
Im sorry for that CFC, it just seems like people are out for me today. I really didnt meen anything nasty.
see you soon
xx
dawneyG
 
Well i don't see whats wrong with wilders profile she gave you, but as for the question;
a. Yes your current tank is far too small for the fish and even though it was good of you to give it a larger tank than it previously had, it doesn't change the fact that its current tank is far too small- theres a lot of difference between a 16gal and a 75 gal.
b. either you get it a much bigger tank in another room of the house you live in, or you will have the rehome the shark in the very near future. Leaving it to grow to maturity in your current tank would be cruel for it(not that i am accusing you would ever do such a thing).
Its a tough choice i know, but if you have any responsablity for the fish and its happyness, getting a bigger tank or rehoming it is the only good choices :thumbs: .
 
Dawney G said:
Im sorry for that CFC, it just seems like people are out for me today. I really didnt meen anything nasty.
see you soon
xx
dawneyG
if you mean the other post, noone was mad at you at all. ;)
It was the other person trying to cause trouble.
 
Whose causing trouble in the thread.
 

It was the other person trying to cause trouble. [/quote]
Now, now, no need to troll- we are talking about silver sharks here and not who's done what wrong; if you are indicating wilder here i don't see what was worng with her link and why previous threads should be brought up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Most reactions

Back
Top