I have six hi fin serpae. they were the terrorists of the tank. I have removed four of them and the remaining two are fine. So my experience doesn't agree with the general wisdom. I will put the other two with the group in a new tank community. It's just not an emergency any more. The serpaes are pugnacious in my experience. Maybe it was the ones I got?
I also saw what I thought was spawning behavior , so that may have been the problem, too
When there was a group of six hi fin serpaes my cockatoos and other shy fish snuck around and couldn't eat peacefully. I don't have the same level of problem with the black phantoms, bleeding hearts (who are 3" or more), silvertips, two spot, neon varieties, or glo lights. My tank is well stocked at the bottom, but well filtered and planted with lots of hidy places and caves. I want fish that are not stressed by an active community.
The serpae have a 20 usg to themselves now and still chase and nip. I have finally put them on a Melafix/Pimafix treatment as their fins had not been healing well. I will get the other two out and into the treatment tank today. As I mentioned elsewhere one seems to have lost an eye in the last 9/11 serpae war.
They are beautifull and striking fish tho.
Weaver, I would be interested in your experience with the "mad tank" as that is what I have in mind to lessen the load in my big tank and change the community slightly. Should I start a new thread?