Seeking Help To Identify A Fish

Ptisan

New Member
Joined
Jul 1, 2008
Messages
3
Reaction score
0
Hello! I'm Bebe. This is my first time posting on this forum, although I've been a long-term silent user of the site for months. Today a friend of mine asked me a question to which I did not know the answer, and if nothing else comes of it, at least it gave me an excuse to register here.
My friend has endeavored to describe to me a fish that he saw years ago, at a park in Alva, Oklahoma. It so happens that when it rains there, it floods, forming large puddles. It had rained three days before, so he was able to approach a puddle about five feet wide, and 7-10 inches deep, or thereabout. In one of the puddles he saw a fish that neither he or anyone in his family has seen before, and he's attempted to describe it to me:
It was brown, and at least two feet/half a metre long, with "a strange, thin, long-finned tail, a square-ish body." It reminds one of the marine rattail fish, seen below, but since this was in a park, not the lower depths of the Arctic Ocean, we've ruled that out. It was in very good condition so presumably it hadn't just been left for dead by a careless owner. It had a large dorsal fin, which originally made me think of a catfish, but he said that the mouth was tilted upward, hinged at the bottom, which, if I'm clear about this, would suggest that it dwells at the uppermost part of the water column.
We've found pictures that remind him of it, that is:I couldn't decide between asking here or at one of the fishing forums that specialize in game fish--but as I said, I've lurked at this forum for some time and the worst thing that can come of making this forum is getting better acquainted with you guys.
 
American Eel? (Native)
Bowfin or Dogfish? (Native)
Eelpout or Burbot? (Native)
Northern snakehead? (Exotic)
Walking catfish? (Exotic)

These fish that I mentioned are probably will match your buddy's mystery fish, however I can rule out eelpout and walking catfish as they are not found in AL because eelpout are northern climate fish and there are no reports about escaped walking catfish in AL through there are reports about the snakeheads.

I would bet on bowfin as they are often found in the puddles at plowed or rice fields when the waterways flood.
 
American Eel? (Native)
Bowfin or Dogfish? (Native)
Eelpout or Burbot? (Native)
Northern snakehead? (Exotic)
Walking catfish? (Exotic)

These fish that I mentioned are probably will match your buddy's mystery fish, however I can rule out eelpout and walking catfish as they are not found in AL because eelpout are northern climate fish and there are no reports about escaped walking catfish in AL through there are reports about the snakeheads.

I would bet on bowfin as they are often found in the puddles at plowed or rice fields when the waterways flood.

Ha, we have it narrowed down between an eelpout and a walking catfish! He lives in Oklahoma, not Alabama; do you think that changes the likelihood of either of those? Though he's certain he's one of the two, which in itself is incredible--I had serious doubts that he'd ever know.
 
Well im sorry to tell you but there are no eelpout in OK as the eelpout are coldwater species and their native home range is in northern climate, won't survive in muddy puddle which bowfin can survived.

Still I thinks its bowfin or dogfish as they are native in OK. Its not uncommon for find bowfins in rice area or in puddles of the fields after floods.

I don't think its walking catfish as they are not native or found in OK waterways.

Again bowfin is your best bet.
 
Well im sorry to tell you but there are no eelpout in OK as the eelpout are coldwater species and their native home range is in northern climate, won't survive in muddy puddle which bowfin can survived.

Still I thinks its bowfin or dogfish as they are native in OK. Its not uncommon for find bowfins in rice area or in puddles of the fields after floods.

I don't think its walking catfish as they are not native or found in OK waterways.

Again bowfin is your best bet.

Sorry for my late response. From the few pictures I've seen of bowfish, it does seem to match the description, and your explanation settles the matter. I'll pass the word to my friend, and my greatest thanks to you for all your trouble and patience.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top