I used one succesfully for many years in a livebearer tank. It was a 55gal with a Magnum 350 canister. The only drawback to this design was that occasionally fry would get sucked up and somehow make it through the Magnum (there must be considerable media bypass but don't really know) only to get stuck underneath the UGF plate. Strangely enough, they stayed alive and grew to about 75% of the size of their upper tank compatriots (kind of reminded me of the Morlocks from "The Time Machine"). I ended up getting a sponge to cover the intake as a felt a bit guilty for this occurence, but was not about to tear up the tank. It was about a year before there were no morlocks left.