Need Help Iding

[Silentking]

I got a bunch of goldfish a year ago and this one is the only one that lived but every time I look up goldfish they have big eyes short body's and long tails

it's not a good pic

 

[Loko17]

I got a bunch of goldfish a year ago and this one is the only one that lived but every time I look up goldfish they have big eyes short body's and long tails

it's not a good pic

I'm sure its not exactly but it kinda looks like a female betta so you should look for certain types of anabantoids and/or gouramis. It doesnt look like any goldfish I've seen

 

[Silentking]

ok and he's kind of aggressive too

 

[Silentking]

i still havn't been able to find what type of goldfish this but i just see him (or her) eat one of my snails and it not like if i don't feed him

 

[snowyangel]

He looks like a goldfish to me but more of a koi type. Obviousey not fancy one like fantails or other smaller traditional goldfish.

 

[Silentking]

He looks like a goldfish to me but more of a koi type. Obviousey not fancy one like fantails or other smaller traditional goldfish.

ok but y is he so aggressive then aren't goldfish non-aggressive

 

[snowyangel]

ok but y is he so aggressive then aren't goldfish non-aggressive

Sorry for the wait(went camping).
It's aggressive as in actually killing fish or chasing after them and just nipping them? My goldfish can get nippy to other fish they aren't used to.
Check this link and compare your koi to it(not all goldfish have big eyes and long tails): http/www.pondkoi.com/koi_categories.htm

 

[Silentking]

i mean killing other fish and snails

 

[Spader]

I got a bunch of goldfish a year ago and this one is the only one that lived but every time I look up goldfish they have big eyes short body's and long tails

it's not a good pic

I'm sure its not exactly but it kinda looks like a female betta so you should look for certain types of anabantoids and/or gouramis. It doesnt look like any goldfish I've seen

definately not a betta dude, look up some more info

 

[Tokis-Phoenix]

I'm positive that it is a Common Goldfish .
Pic of common goldfish;

http/www.goldfishinfo.com/gallery/Goldfish-Photos/common

 

[black angel]

Its a common and a nice one at that.
They can get territorial if on their own for a while and in a smallish tank.
What size is she and how big a tank?

 

[tjp]

i have got noe of these in our pond . its just a normail golfish thats not gold lol

it looks like a male to me .. so thats why it cud be killing the otherfish

 

[black angel]

could you get another clearer shot of it, theres something not quite right, and another pic from above.

I see what look like the pectoral fins but as the pic is blurred are there more fins there? There also seems to be a lump at the belly.
Have you ever seen any breeding stars which are small bumps on the gill plates and sometimes on the pectoral fins?

 

[bribones]

theres something not quite right

the dorsal looks too far back,it might well be stunted,i thought and orf at first but cant be sure from that pic

 

[black angel]

Im looking at the pectoral fins as i see what look like another set of fins behind it
Now youve mentioned it bri the dorsal is too far back.