I think this is not what was sold

Oldspartan

Fishaholic
Joined
Feb 14, 2024
Messages
581
Reaction score
1,308
Location
Gansevoort
I few weeks back Linda was at the LFS to purchase something. While there she spotted this fish labeled as a BN Pleco Albino. She brought him home and I thought not but he was very small so she said maybe. Now he has grown out a bit and I think not. He looks more like some kind of catfish to me. Ihave skimmed my picture book and can not find him. I am thinking he will not be happy for long in a 44 gallon tank.
Identity please!

DSCN5492.JPG
DSCN5491.JPG
 
This is why I really - REALLY - dislike the actual LFS, not to be confused with the not so LFS. Since we started this adventure I do not believe we have had correct information from our LFS 10% of the time. I try to do as little commerce there as possible.

We keep a BN in most every tank, we just plain like them. This particular fish was very small and was Id'd on the tank as an Albino BN Pleco. I inquired of three separate clerks about the fish which to me, even at that size, did not look the part. I was assured he was as labeled, and Linda really liked the Albino look. As I have stated a few times on the forum, I generally try to get whatever she wants. At any rate, since day one I have been suspicious of what the critter really was and today was really the first time I took the effort to actually photo him or her.

I will now see how much Linda really loves the fella, especially when I tell her she will need a six foot or so long. She is going to be quite perturbed at the LFS and is going to insist on going there when I inform her. It will not be pretty.
 
If you nearly not feed it, it can take decades to grow.

But... Yeah when I seen the specs, I preferred to....

Better flush it while it wont block sewage.
 
This is why I really - REALLY - dislike the actual LFS, not to be confused with the not so LFS.
I guess a serious number of us have had such issues with an lfs...
 
This situation makes me extremely happy to have the not so LFS. They are far more interested in good information, good service and proper care than in making a sale. I think those attributes result in better sales over time, loyal customers, and the ability to sleep at night. It is well worth the drive to do business with them. I am willing to pay more to get more. Most serious people are because they understand that service costs money.
 
Yeah, but look at the albino bristlenose plecs...

And these bristles can take up to 2 years to "start" to grow.

Loll....
 
Linda likes this fish a lot. So, question. Is a 90 a large enough tank to satisfy this fella? I do not think so but told her I would pose the question.

Second question how fast does such a fish grow?
Third, at what point would it need to be put in a larger (and suitably sized tank)?
What is a suitable size tank realistically?

If the growth timeline fits my making fish room adjustments I might be persuaded by Linda's big, beautiful hazel eyes to keep Casper, her name for the fish.
 
They grow faster than you would expect. They aren't likely to reach 3 foot in an aquarium, but a solid 18 inches is possible. I saw a few of them dumped in Florida waterways at up to 2 feet. They weren't just long, but wide bodied and heavy. They had destroyed those streams.

A 90 will work for a bit, depending on the length of the front glass. If it's a 3 foot one, no, but a 5 or 6 footer will do. The thing people don't consider isn't just tank size. These are big fish, heavy bodied waste producers. There's nothing ballerina like about that fish. And as a big, heavy, waste producing fish in a 90, its tankmates will have to go. Yes, it can live in most 90s, but its bioload means it really should live alone, with excellent filtration and lots of water changes.

Not now, but in a year or two.

I was in a store once that had had an "adoption" policy for big Loracarid catfish. They would accept them from hobbyists, say they'd phone someone who wanted one, wait a few hours and then euthanize the fish. It was deceptive, but in some weeks, they could get 2 or 3 big ones (they didn't sell gibbiceps or common plecos) and they couldn't be placed. People who have large tanks usually dislike them. There are a lot of such "what, no, we aren't a kill shelter" places, trying to cope with them. Your fish has a better chance of a longterm home returned small.
 
Worse part is bigger they get the more you love them.

They love strong current, and if you can provide they become very strong, when they start to be intimidating is where I like it the most.

But to be honest they rarely go above 2 feet in aquariums, most I have seen being between 12-18 inches.

I kept mine in a 75 gallons with one huge comet goldfish and 2 Aquaclear 70 on one end of the tank to create a river alike tank. A big piece of wood reaching under the water return for plekky.

And the toughest filter maintenance and water changing schedule I ever had. No plants could survive in there. And they poop as big a pencil.
 
I have called the LFS and announced I will be returning the fish for the reason stated.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top