Eheim Wet/dry Or Pro Ii

[GrantyBoy]

Hi Folks

Tank is 52"x24"x24" which makes it 111g. In the tank at the moment is two fully grown Oscars and a 8" Plec.
The current filter setup is an Eheim 2028 Pro II, Fluval 304 external and a Fluval 4+ internal.

I'm looking to swap out the Fluval 304 external as its a pain to get started again when it comes maintenance time. The Eheim on the other hand is a breeze. So I'm looking to swap the Fluval for a second Eheim 2028 Pro II @ £120 (with media) or possibly get a Eheim 2229 wet/dry filter @ £170.

Is the wet/dry system worth the extra £50 over the Pro II and does this system work. What are peoples opinons on these two filters and my proposed filter setup, am I going overkill with two filters rated at 132g each?!?! Final question, does anyone have any other suggestions for a suitable replacement external filter.

thanks all

 

[andywg]

I wouldn't bother with the Eheim Wet/Dry filters. They are a true pain to set up properly. Stick with the more classic designs for far esier operation and better peace of mind for you.

 

[GrantyBoy]

Thanks Andy

Thought this could have been the case so I'll stick with what I know.

P.S. Awesome fish in your Sig. Can you PM me what it is, cheers

 

[Lateral Line]

I agree. I was given a "wet and dry" to trial when they were new, I had some trouble with it, which is unheard of with decent Eheim gear, (the ECCO models are "economy" Eheim gear and in my opinion, a mistake). I am also used to silent operation, the w & d was not.