Do Fish of different species, but that developed similarly, typically get along???

Magnum Man

Supporting Member
Tank of the Month 🏆
Fish of the Month 🌟
Joined
Jun 21, 2023
Messages
4,292
Reaction score
3,072
Location
Southern MN
not sure if anyone has ever set up a tank, with fish like this... for example, Rummynose Rasboras ( Sawbwa resplendens ), and Rummynose Tetras ( Hemigrammus rhodostomus )... or Drape Fin Barbs ( Oreichthys crenuchoides ), and Sailfin Tetras ( Crenuchus spilurus )... I know they won't interbreed, but curious if anyone has ever mixed them in a tank???
 
That would be an interesting selection of tanks to watch.
 
not sure if anyone has ever set up a tank, with fish like this... for example, Rummynose Rasboras ( Sawbwa resplendens ), and Rummynose Tetras ( Hemigrammus rhodostomus )... or Drape Fin Barbs ( Oreichthys crenuchoides ), and Sailfin Tetras ( Crenuchus spilurus )... I know they won't interbreed, but curious if anyone has ever mixed them in a tank???
Well, we know that Corydoras (Gastrodermus) hastatus will associate and school with similarly marked, caudal peduncle-spotted tetras such as Hyphessobrycon elachys.

In the same vein, I recently moved the lone survivor of an ancient school of Garnet Tetras (Hemigrammus pulcher) to a tank containing among others a school of Pethia setnai. I belatedly realized that the two species were similarly shaped and had a similar caudal peduncle pattern of a black spot associated with an area of gold. Sure enough the lone Garnet associated exclusively with the P. setnai.
 
Last edited:
Sawbwa and rummy nose wouldn't work because their water needs are so radically different. They might drink together a little, but.

My favourite version of this is Lucania goodei and Heterandria formosa. The first is the Florida Blue Fin Killie, and the second is the 'least killifish', which isn't a killifish but a tiny livebearer. I caught them together in Florida, and they don't look alike. But I was having trouble raising the blue fin fry, and realized they looked almost identical in their markings to the livebearer fry in the next tank. I put the two species together, and bingo. The fry shoaled and I had plenty of both.
All of a sudden where I'd been getting 2 or 3 bluefin fry a month, I was getting 10 or 15 in with the Heterandria.

There are lots of mimics - the Cory tetra thing @Innesfan mentions was a cool thing to watch when I got both.

It doesn't work with territorial fish, where they seem to compete. But with shoalers, it can be interesting.

I put a Tateurndina ocellicauda peacock gudgeon in with a male Fundulopanchax nigerianus killie. They come from a world apart, but have remarkably similar colouration and size. The killie just looked at the gudgeon with a "nice try, wannabe" look, and they ignored each other.
 

Most reactions

Back
Top