Culpera

psycho-killer

Fish Crazy
Joined
Aug 16, 2007
Messages
281
Reaction score
0
hey

dunno if i have it wrong but i recieved culpera from an order that i made just wanted to know if there is other people using it and how effective it is in reducing nitrates?

im running it in my sump with a 20W PC lights...

thanks..
 
It works well enough but be sure to keep your fuge lighting on 24 hours a day to reduce the chances that the algae will go into it's reproductive phase.
 
Is it "grape" or bubble? Racemosa Culpera? I hate that stuff. It can spreads everywhere in your tank display tank and can leech and disintergrate too. I had read about it after I had purchased some and removed it from my tank before it could take a hold.
 
Short answer: Cheato or bust for remote algae refuge.

No light live rock or live rock rubble > any algea growing.


JIMO
 
I wanted to add here that I've used Caulerpa in all my tanks and it's worked like a charm on the nitrates; I've seen no significant difference in effectiveness between Caulerpa species and Chaeto at nitrate removal. I have razor Caulerpa, feather Caulerpa, and one other type that I can't remember the name for offhand. I've kept grape Caulerpa in the past but it always got eaten. Also wanted to add that I've always kept my Caulerpa with 12on/12off lighting hours and that has never prompted it to go sexual. The handfull of times it has done so have been in direct response to bad physical damage that ultimately killed portions due to fluid loss. Also, I've only ever had feather Caulerpa do this - my other species of Caulerpa have never gone sexual even when I've deliberately tried to stress them to see what triggers the response.
 
caulpera is great, many would argue BETTER at nutrient export than chaeto. But, each has pros and cons....
 
no arguing there at effectiveness. Just, life has a way of sneaking up on you and get busy. If it does go sexual, its a quick road to meltdown. For me, I won't add another ticking time bomb to my systems. I already have to worry about my lack of plumbing super powers :shifty:
 
If it does go sexual, its a quick road to meltdown.

SH will hate me for this, but I have to argue here too. I find the notion that macro is some sort of an inevitable tank-nuker is a bit like viewing a fish dying in the tank as an inevitable tank-nuker, but nobody avoids putting fish in because of that. Instead, they see the dead fish and remove it rather than letting it sit to rot and nuke the tank. Same thing applies with macro. Even when in my 12g I had most of my feather caulerpa bleed out, go sexual, and turn the water opaque green due to my Turbos having a one-time strange feast on the main vascular structures, I saw no significant effect on the water except that it was ugly for 2 days while the muck was filtered out. PH and all other levels showed no change during that time. This was also a very large volume of macro...once removed, it was several cups worth of squashed and deflated Caulerpa, so it was no trivial amount for a small tank. However, I had previously prepared my tank for such an event by keeping good surface aggitation, having additional oxygentation, having a higher than normal turnover, and once I saw the problem I did a small water change to try to increase visibility and removed the dead macro. As far as post-event-management went, it's pretty much the same thing I'd do if I had a decent-sized animal die.

Where tanks can really run into problems is if you have barely sufficient oxygenation in the water and/or not enough circulation. That situation poses a problem for phyto blooms too - when stuff starts to die off or be decomposed, the O2 gets sucked up really fast if it's not abundant and everybody's gasping at the surface all of a sudden. Another possible complication can be pH, which can drop under similar circumstances. After having some experience with the fallout from repeated phyto blooms in another tank (many times worse IME), the solution is pretty simple and works for macro issues too: backup oxygenation, e.g. an air pump in addition powerhead aggitation. A small water change is a good idea once you observe the problem (just like taking a dead fish out instead of leaving it to rot), but if you prepare your tank well it shouldn't crash and burn just because you wern't there to catch it before the tank turned green. I've never done more than a 10% water change on the few macro occasions and on the more numerous phyto occasions, it's never been at the exact time of the event, and it's never led to a meltdown.
 
Interesting... I've always really liked caulerpa but have been put off by it's "danger". Will try it the next time I get a chance; I've had grape caulerpa before (in a refugium) but it was eventually taken over by hair algae.
 
Well, for each claim I've heard I've not seen it proven true yet with a solid case example that didn't seem to go back to O2 deprivation or some lack of filtration issue. As with any animal/plant/etc., tank prep is the key. Plus, most of the problems center around feather Caulerpa. I've never even gotten razor Caulpera to go sexual...it just seems to suck its fluids into the stems when stressed. I've even provoked Chaeto into going sexual recently (heat-triggered oddly) but razor Caulerpa seems pretty bomb-proof. I've never had much luck with grape Caulerpa. I've never had it go sexual, but it gets out-competed easily and it seems anything that eats hair algae thinks grape Caulpera is delicious.
 
Back when I had a tang, I used to stick macroalgae into my hob filter along with the lr rubble and wedge it in there. It seemed to help somewhat with the nitrates and I'd just pull out a bit every couple days to give to the tang, along with the dried sea lettuce sheets. He seemed to like it, along with my blue velvet damsel.
 
I have always run Caulerpa as it is all I can get hold of easily here. I was chatting to the lfs owner and he said he had never seen any go sexual and crash. I have had no problems at all, despite often letting it form a huge thick amorphous mass in the fuge.
 
Im totally with you on this one Donya. If your filtration and gas exchange is adequate there's no need to worry about it. Too bad many people's tanks are right on the "edge"
 

Most reactions

Back
Top